7 ms·
Mast Brothers: $10 a bar for crappy hipster chocolate (2015)
- oh_sigh 7y agoI don't really understand why a 4 year old article about a fake chocolatier is relevant to this site. I actually went to their store in Williamsburg before this drama unfolded, and I remember saying something along the lines to my wife 'Wow, I can't believe this is their only facility, it looks way too small to pump out so many bars'.
- neilv 7y agoIt can help us recognize parallels (and differences) in our own industry.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 7y agoI guess so, but a more relevant post might have been an article talking about the mast brothers fraud, and how it can relate to a tech industry. But what do I know. Based on the number of comments, readers love this post, so I was clearly wrong that it was off topic.
- vr46 7y agoNice to have some light relief and to see that the world outside tech is just as sketchy as inside. I loved the original expose on Noka, FWIW.
- smacktoward 7y agoMy BS alarms started going off on these guys when they chartered a sailing ship to transport cocoa beans to their factory, on the argument that you could taste the difference between beans shipped by sail and beans shipped on a ship with an engine (!).
- csours 7y agoI only accept chocolate made from cacao pods transported by African Swallows.
- joshstrange 7y agoWhat would you say the average windspeed for a laden African swallow might be?
- joezydeco 7y agoWait until you learn about Kopi luwak coffee...
- tsm 7y ago<pedantry> "Kopi" is Indonesian for "coffee", so "kopi luwak coffee" is in the same vein as "ATM machine" and "PIN number". "Kopi luwak" or "civet coffee" are the preferred terms. </pedantry> All that said, it's delicious.
- internobody 7y agoBut then, African Swallows are non-migratory.
- rickthomas1980 7y ago
- _1tan 7y agoSeeing this article on the frontpage of HN again feels weird. I am currently going down the deep rabbit-hole of chocolate making and re-read this just recently. Highly recommend the coverage on dallasfood.org as well: http://dallasfood.org/2015/12/mast-brothers-what-lies-behind-the-beards-part-1-tastetexture/ http://dallasfood.org/2015/12/mast-brothers-what-lies-behind...
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoCurious: what prompted you to get interested in chocolate making? Anything interesting and not-obvious you have discovered or learned so far?
- _1tan 7y ago1. It's delicious 2. It's nutritious 3. Too many people eat bad chocolate 4. There lies a very interesting challenge in creating more heat-resistant chocolate (think climate change) 5. It's a fragmented, huge market. 6. I was looking for a hobby involving manual labour that has the potential to turn into a company
- harryh 7y agoTitle note: should reflect 2015
- intsunny 7y agoNot only 2015, but the qz.com article is blogspam compared to the original investigation: http://dallasfood.org/2015/12/mast-brothers-what-lies-behind-the-beards-part-1-tastetexture/ http://dallasfood.org/2015/12/mast-brothers-what-lies-behind... The Mast Bros situation has been discussed to death, yawn.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI posted the article here - I wasn't aware of the previous discussion on HN. I guess there's probably a decent percentage of other HNers that wasn't aware either. I also wasn't aware of the dallasfood article either. You raise good points, but I don't know how I could have acted differently...
- mo1ok 7y agoI remember reading about the hysteria of this 4 years ago and wondering if me, a non-foodie, could actually taste the difference in chocolate quality. I finally had my first mast brothers bar recently and... ...yeah. It taste like a slightly better quality hershey's bar, definitely not a $10 bar of chocolate. I was kind of floored, it was actually pretty bad.
- gamblor956 7y agoI actually think that Hershey's has the edge over Mast. But either way, the new M&M bars taste infinitely better than both Hershey's and Mast.
- rsp1984 7y agoBut brilliant marketing. Even the skeptics wanna know how this outrageously expensive chocolate bar might taste...
- mola 7y agoBrilliantly deceitful. We should use correct adjectives if we are to make truth the norm again...
- ardit33 7y agosame, I tried it once, and thought it was bland..... and kinda crappy/cheap tasting. Now that I have been living in NYC for few years, my BS meter has improved. There are enough tourists and young people that come and go in NYC, and that propels a whole industry for "expensive/overpriced" but crappy goods and services. Both Brooklyn and Manhattan are the place of 100$ haircuts, just because your barber has a hipster beard....
- VRay 7y agoSeems like $100 for a haircut isn't that bad when you'd need to pay $3000/month for a bedroom within an hour's commute, assuming it's a fancy haircut that takes 40+ minutes
- 7y ago
- vortico 7y agoThis article is a reminder that many luxury goods don't have enough intrinsic value to account for their price. In those cases, marketing needs to actually add value to a product, not just inform people of the intrinsic value of a product. This practice is used in almost all end-consumer products on the market. Seeing an Apple ad of a shiny image of a new iPhone imprints that image into the customers mind, even after they purchase and use the product. Their perceived value of their iPhone one year after purchase is greater than if they have not seen any advertisements, because they keep associating the product in their hands with the very high quality image on TV. This is what's happening here with Mast Brothers chocolate. The high price itself can increase perceived value ("If it's expensive, then it must make me happy!"), appeal to values held by the consumer ("I support small businesses so I value the purchase more!"), and the packaging or storefront proximity ("Imagine how much value the product is since the packaging is such high quality, or the presentation on the shelf is high quality"). None of these have anything to do with the edible substance they're buying (the "end product"). In fact, I would argue that the end product matters the least for this particular product. Beyond some point, the quality of product does not affect its intrinsic value. Mast Brothers is beyond that point. The marketer therefore must use the above methods to further increase perceived value. If you are a business owner yourself, you can choose to increase perceived value of your product in ethical or unethical ways. Some customers will detect unethical practices, some won't notice (such as people who don't read this article), and some won't care.
- smacktoward 7y agoOr artisanal products like Mast Brothers' are actually Veblen goods (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good), where demand for the product is driven by the high price because it lets its buyers conspicuously signal that they're better off than everyone else. Poor people can't afford $12 chocolate bars, so for a person who regularly buys $12 chocolate bars, part of the value to them is the opportunity to demonstrate how not-poor they are. All the markers of authenticity are just there to let the buyer convince themselves that they're doing something loftier than that.
- Animats 7y ago
- plink 7y agoMaybe by Mast Bros’ example there’s opportunity for Elizabeth Holmes to pivot into this field.
- mothsonasloth 7y agoTwo things * If you are willing to spend $10 on chocolate, well then you deserve to open yourself up to being hoodwinked by marketing and branding. * More and more people are buying stuff not for its intrinsic value but as a status symbol. From the super smug colleague showing off their Oat milk in the fridge and artisanal roasted beans. To the person buying bespokoe sunglasses (which are sourced from the same factory as Ray Ban). Not forgetting the Avocado on toast hipster, whose appetite is causing drought and deforestation across the world. Crazy times we are living in...
- PhasmaFelis 7y ago> If you are willing to spend $10 on chocolate, well then you deserve to open yourself up to being hoodwinked by marketing and branding. Disagree. If you get $10 worth of enjoyment out of a really good chocolate bar, and you can afford it, then it's perfectly reasonable to do so. > Not forgetting the Avocado on toast hipster, whose appetite is causing drought and deforestation across the world. Are you aware that the "avocado toast millennial" thing is nonsense? You've only heard of it because an out-of-touch millionaire claimed that millennials are only poor because they spend all their money on Starbucks and avocado toast, and the mockery he received went viral.
- LargeWu 7y ago> If you get $10 worth of enjoyment out of a really good chocolate bar, and you can afford it, then it's perfectly reasonable to do so. I think the insinuation here is that the purchasers of this chocolate are deriving their enjoyment of the product from the knowledge that they paid $10 for it, or from being able to tell somebody they paid $10 for it, not from the quality of the actual chocolate.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoYeah, absolutely, if you're only buying it for conspicuous consumption, that's silly. I just felt like mothsonasloth implied that it's fundamentally dumb to pay more than a few dollars for a chocolate bar.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoStories like this always remind me of the artisanal firewood spoof. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI
- neilv 7y agoI love that spoof. One big difference is that the artisans in the spoof appeared to be genuine true-believers, but the investigative articles around this chocolate story seem to allege intentional deception at some points.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOld news? Any they've amended their ways. And the 'crappy' label is a bit harsh?
- fnord77 7y ago> Mast Brothers have executed a brilliant marketing strategy, but don’t sell quality chocolate can't you say this about almost any high volume popular luxury brand?
- mixmastamyk 7y agoInteresting they mention Valrhona, which I get at Trader Joe's for 2.99 or so. It is the smoothest and least bitter 85% chocolate I've found in supermarkets, and slightly prefer it to both Ghirardelli and Lindt. I didn't know anything about it until now. So they started out reselling (remelting) it for 3x the price. Fake it till you make it, indeed.
- peter_l_downs 7y agoWas someone else recently reading Jia Tolentino's essay on modern scams, or is this just a Baader-meinhoff thing?
- anthony_romeo 7y agoAs I read the article, I can't help but feel that the tone is exceptionally unfair to Mast Brothers. It seems the primary charge is that 'some, but not all, of their earliest sold chocolate bars were made from mass-produced chocolate,' referencing bars sold at a flea market (wherein they allegedly acknowledged to a buyer that some-but-not-all were made from mass-produced chocolate). The article then criticizes them for browsing the largest Chocolatier forum on the Internet for advice... Is this supposed to be a serious criticism? Then it goes into the quality of the chocolate and alleges that it's overpriced. I would argue that it's subjective, and there isn't anything inherently wrong with strong marketing. Maybe their chocolate isn't that good (I've never heard of Mast before reading this) and they're just convinced it is? Finally, the article ends with attacks based on mere speculation and attacks on the general chocolate industry as a whole. I'm not making any judgment on Mast Brothers chocolate one way or the other. It's just that this article has a whole lot of aggressive language propping up some pretty weak evidence.
- itronitron 7y agoYeah, I found it remarkable that the Mast brothers were rather up front about the sourcing for each of their chocolate bars. If they have the skills and dedication then they should be able to improve their product to meet their marketing.
- beamatronic 7y agoI actually have a favorite chocolate bar that is about $10, made in Hawaii by Manoa Chocolate [1] They have a factory store in Kailua where you can do a tasting and they show you how it’s made. They also sell them in some Whole Foods. No chartered sailing ships as far as I know. [1] https://manoachocolate.com https://manoachocolate.com
- aaron695 7y agoThis is exactly what readers of HN should be doing. Fake it until you make it It's not like they were faking blood tests or fake solar roads that cause harm. It's just chocolate. I'd hope this old article is highly rated for that, or trying to understand how humans work and what they value, rather than the dopamine rush from trying to see people fail.