4 ms·
>...China can (and does) manipulate its currency and that devaluing one's currency is what has led to the shift of manufacturing jobs from the developed world t
by simonh 7y ago
>...China can (and does) manipulate its currency and that devaluing one's currency is what has led to the shift of manufacturing jobs from the developed world to China...
That's not what the article says, it only really addresses recent events. The main reason goods manufactured in China have historically been cheap is that Chinese labour and land is very inexpensive in absolute terms. They had huge amounts of land that was under-utilised and hundreds of millions of rural people with little or no economically valuable work to do, with very low standards of living. That's the basic source of China's manufacturing cost advantage.
It's also not true that China has consistently devalued their currency, they have frequently acted to prop up it's value especially since the financial crisis. Before 2007 the Yuan was much weaker, at over 8 to the dollar. The recent slide in the Yuan was a result of the latest tariffs. China didn't act to devalue it, they simply stopped acting to prop it up.
So overall yes, a relatively weak yuan has served China well, but much of that weakness is due to structural economic reasons. Labour and land was cheap due to low labour and land utilisation. Labour was also cheap due to very minimal standards of living. Manufacturing capacity was cheap due to enormous economies of scale. Those aren't a recipe leading to a naturally strong currency.
- underdown 7y agoSo you're saying the yuan hasn't been pegged to the dollar all these years? This is revisionism.
- kasey_junk 7y agoThe yuan is not pegged to the dollar in the traditional sense of the term. China is actually fairly opaque about how they set their rates but claim it’s against a basket of currencies. Here is a good discussion on it: https://www.cfr.org/blog/so-china-pegging-dollar-or-basket https://www.cfr.org/blog/so-china-pegging-dollar-or-basket
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Despegar 7y agoIt was pegged but they pegged it at a number that was stronger than it would otherwise be. China fears capital flight more than anything, and rich people in China would absolutely sell their yuan for dollars or euros in an instant if they could. Capital controls and the peg are why real estate in China is a bubble. There's no other place for people to put their savings. Rich people who know better don't trust the CCP.
- malandrew 7y agoWhat could the US do to assist in helping capital flight? I would imagine that just helping all the rich Chinese take their money out of China would go a long way to force Beijing's hand.
- chaostheory 7y agoAllow paying for citizenship via investment.
- ridewinter 7y agoJust become Swiss.
- helloindia 7y ago"EB-5 program basically enabled Chinese investors to get their green cards through a $500,000 investment in a regional center project, or a $ 1 million direct investment in their own company." https://www.forbes.com/sites/andyjsemotiuk/2018/06/22/the-l-1-work-visa-the-best-option-for-chinese-investors-wanting-to-immigrate-to-the-usa/#34bd83b221d3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/andyjsemotiuk/2018/06/22/the-l-...
- Spellman 7y agoThey did, but I believe GP is arguing they did it in the opposite direction as the recent movements. To make sure terms are correct, "Weak" currency means higher Yuan:USD conversion rate. Devaluing your currency makes exports more attractive to other countries and tends to create capital inflows (my 1 USD can buy a lot more Yuans, meaning cheaper to buy buildings/business!). "Strong" currency means lower Yuan:USD conversion. Flip above. Looking at the past, there's an odd floor that happens originally at 8.5 in the late 90s and 2000s. Many argued this was intentionally weak to help grow their export economy. Then the rate rose to 6.83 in the late 00s and 2010s. Some argued this was intentionally strong to prevent capital outflows. Since then the rate has been in the 6s and seems to float more naturally until the recent dive into the >7s, indicating a weakening of the Yuan. People always saw 7:1 Yuan:USD as the weakest point China was willing to let their currency fall. So, in the recent past, they're accused of artificially keeping the Yuan strong (esp in the global financial crisis) but now it seems like they're allowing it to devalue naturally. EDIT: for details/grammer
- khuey 7y agoChina is still acting to prop up the yuan today. If they eliminated or even relaxed their capital controls there would be a massive outflow of wealth.