10 ms·
Terrible article: 1) It's only about the US. 2) Tesla's big seller is the Model 3 which isn't a competitor for the Audi e-tron and I-Pace. And given the size
by threeseed 7y ago
Terrible article:
1) It's only about the US.
2) Tesla's big seller is the Model 3 which isn't a competitor for the Audi e-tron and I-Pace. And given the size difference probably isn't a competitor for the Model X either.
3) No one is claiming to be a Tesla killer since no one really has direct 3, X, S, Y competitors. The existing car companies are all off doing their own thing e.g. VW ID.3 (hatchback), Hyundai Kona (mini-SUV), Renault Zoe / Chevy Bolt / Nissan Leaf / BMW i3 (small-car) etc.
- varjag 7y agoThey are aimed at the same crowd who buy models X&S, and they didn't have much a dent yet here in Norway as well.
- threeseed 7y agoAnd Tesla is definitely still beating them. But it's more than a little disingenuous to compare cars from different segments.
- varjag 7y agoI'm not sure if we can talk about segments here. The Audi for example aims squarely for the same premium SUV owners. That they didn't make them larger I suspect is the result of inferior technology. With increased mass and air drag the already modest range would have become laughable.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoThe Model 3 is cleaning up in Norway, but the new contenders are absolutely "making a dent" with respect to S&X sales. Both the e-tron and I Pace are individually outselling S&X combined to date in 2019. This is likely due to pent up demand, but it does show that Tesla's absolute domination of the US market hasn't played out in Europe. If you're interested in widespread EV adoption, this is probably ideal. It's concerning to me that Tesla may have so much mind share that even genuine competitors once they arrive will struggle to sell enough to be profitable. In which case, the steady state will be legacy auto makers doing the bare minimum as required under emissions legislation. In the EU that's probably ok, but not in the US. Norway 2019 sales for reference: Model 3: 10976 VW Golf: 6533 Leaf: 5441 BMW i3: 3671 E-Tron: 3114 I-Pace: 2372 IONIQ: 2168 Zoe: 1775 Model X: 1344 Model S: 969
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y agoI was in Oslo in 2018, before the Model 3 came out. I saw very many Electric vehicles on the roads, including numerous Teslas. Now, add to that the model 3 outselling the Model S by a factor of 11 to 1 this year, that is amazing.
- Proven 7y agoThat might be because Teslas seem relatively easy to set on fire that burns for a long time - that may be of interest to Electric Car owners in Norway (in the case you get stuck and it's cold)
- gibolt 7y agoEvery electric car slated to arrive has been called a Tesla killer in article after article, sometimes individually, often as a collective. Several of them are targeting Tesla owners with discounts, ads at superchargers, etc... The companies clearly think they are competing with Tesla, especially since they don't want to compete with themselves (ICE models). As for doing their own thing, most have a battery shortage and are confined to small cars with relatively small battery packs for now until more batteries are available (none of whom are vertically integrating production).
- rumanator 7y ago> Every electric car slated to arrive has been called a Tesla killer in article after article, sometimes individually, often as a collective. The number of Nissan Leafs sold so far are close to twice the number of Tesla model Ss sold.
- gibolt 7y agoNissan Leaf has been on the market with a low price much longer. Sales have slumped since the Model 3 scaled up, news about their battery overheating, and their refusal to produce a vehicle with larger range. It is not a Tesla killer, but was for many a stop-gap solution while waiting for the 3, and Tesla will soon eclipse them in sales. That gap is unlikely to narrow
- rumanator 7y ago> Leaf has been on the market with a low price much longer. So Nissan beat Tesla with a model not only in time to market but also with it's superior price, which resulted so far in selling twice as many cars as Tesla's direct competitors to the Nissan Leaf. > It is not a Tesla killer Nothing will ever be if the goalpost is kept moving like that.
- llampx 7y agoTesla is moving the goalposts by producing more and more electric vehicles that people want to buy. The Nissan Leaf and Leaf Plus doesn't come into consideration for me because of its pitiful range, the ChADeMO connector and lack of active cooling for the battery pack.
- alexkiritz 7y agoDo you seriously think most people who buy larger cars now actually need them? Of course not. People do cross comparisons and generally prefer the Model 3 for a variety of reasons. And it's cheaper.
- Erlich_Bachman 7y agoVery weird argument. So why are they buying them if they don't "need them". And why would that reason change for model 3?
- alexkiritz 7y agoBecause they feel they’re safer or cooler. Car companies are able to charge more for them so they’ve been pushing them in every way imaginable. Very weird that you didn’t know this.
- Erlich_Bachman 7y agoYou're using a very narrow definition of the word "need", well sure ok. Why would that change for model 3 again?
- thefounder 7y agoYeah but what they need is a 2 door electric Smart car not a model 3, right?
- alexkiritz 7y agoA 2 seater Tesla would sell very well. Tesla would make it cool. There are already multiple companies that have recently made very cool designs for 2 seater EVs but failed due to bad leadership and running out of funding. Unfortunately Elon is set on robotic Uber being the cheaper option.
- tyfon 7y agoi-pace is actually more comparable to model 3 than model S and X. It has about the same power and internal space, model x is _much_ bigger.
- marvin 7y agoYou’re saying it’s comprable to 3 in size and features, but S&X in price? I really don’t intend to be snarky, but I haven’t seen it, and this would be the implication if what you say is correct.
- michaelt 7y agoWikipedia calls the Model X, I-Pace and Model 3 "Mid-size luxury crossover SUV", "Compact luxury crossover SUV" and "Compact executive car" respectively. The I-Pace has 8% less length, 8% less height, and 12% less weight than the Model X 90D. The widths are comparable. The I-Pace has 9% more width, 9% more height, and 15% more weight than the Model 3 Range AWD. The lengths are comparable. I would say this puts the I-Pace half way between the Model X and the Model 3 in terms of size. In terms of class, I'd say the I-Pace is closer to the Model X, both being luxury crossover SUVs. More broadly, Jaguar is a historically British company, and Britain's roads and parking spaces are narrower than those in the US, so the truck and full-size SUV classes are much less popular.
- jaxn 7y agoSo the accurate comparison is the i-Pace and the Model Y. Jaguar beat Tesla to market by 12-18 months in the segment. Will be interesting to see if they can capitalize on the head start.
- mikeash 7y agoIt compares to the Model Y in size but to the Model X on price. This doesn’t seem like a winning combination. Edit: that’s a bit too glib. I’m sure it’ll do just fine as a niche product for a certain group of buyers, which is what Jaguar is all about. It’s just not really competing with Tesla, which is trying hard to go after the mass market.
- twsted 7y agoYou mean "...has direct S,3,X,Y competitors."
- pmorici 7y agoWhen Tesla's competitors stop designing and electric car and start designing a really great car that just happens to be electric then Tesla will have competition. Until then all the supposed Tesla competitors will be a joke. For example it was recently reported that the Jaguar I-pace requires that you drive 17 MPH with the climate control off to achieve the manufacture specified range per charge. [0] They have 6 months worth of unsold inventory sitting on dealer lots in the US. Tesla's strength is in getting market share from buyers who first and foremost want a great car. Everyone else is targeting suckers willing to make decisions contrary to their economic interest to show they care about the environment. [0] https://cleantechnica.com/2019/08/13/jaguar-i-pace-sales-have-crashed-dealer-inventory-exceeds-6-month-supply/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/08/13/jaguar-i-pace-sales-hav...
- LeonM 7y ago> When Tesla's competitors stop designing and electric car and start designing a really great car that just happens to be electric then Tesla will have competition. Until then all the supposed Tesla competitors will be a joke. This. I never understood why car manufacturers all make such weird wacky electric cars. When the Model S came out it was such a relief that finally there was a _normal_ looking electric car. What I want is an electric 5-series, not the wacky i3. Don't change the appearance, just the drive train.
- kylecordes 7y agoTesla is trying to make cars to compete with other makers’ non-electric cars. Other makers are trying to make cars to compete with Tesla, without competing with their own non-electric cars. Currently, it is probably impossible to achieve a good profit margin on a mass-market electric car. Battery costs are too high this early in the manufacturing process. Tesla is willing to operate at the bare edge of fiscal viability while they scale… maybe even below viability. Other makers would have to take a gigantic drop in profit to compete with that.
- CydeWeys 7y agoSometimes it's worth taking some temporary losses to get a new foothold in a growing market.
- delaaxe 7y agoTesla models are supposed to be listed in this order: S, 3, X, Y (Elon wanted the model names to spell "sexy")
- WorldMaker 7y ago> The existing car companies are all off doing their own thing e.g. VW ID.3 (hatchback), Hyundai Kona (mini-SUV), Renault Zoe / Chevy Bolt / Nissan Leaf / BMW i3 (small-car) etc. I'm not sure those are the strongest examples, as you can defend most of them (maybe not the BMW i3) as perfectly legitimate cars in the current market and maybe more than Tesla's counterparts: * The S and 3 are almost retro in how much they resemble a traditional sedan, and supposedly that's not what Americans want in the current marketplace. (Enough so that both Ford and GM saw boosts on the stock market for abandoning the entire class of vehicles [admittedly, to imports and the S and 3].) * The X looks like "soccer mom" minivan more than SUV, and I've seen Americans look down their nose at it as "uncool", very cool falcon doors aside. Meanwhile: * VW ID.3 looks like a modern reinvention of the classic VW Golf, a tried and true decades-spanning form factor. The VW Golf itself being something of the grand-papa of the modern hatchback trend and influencing almost everything else on the market (the Prius, the Tesla Model Y, everyone owes at least a little something to the Golf). * The Hyundai Kona is in a class of SUV that is very popular in American and abroad. (Look at uglier ICE relatives like the Nissan Cube and the Honda Element, both of which have been relatively high sellers, despite their boxy, not-quite-a-full-SUV thing.) * The Renault Zoe is in a somewhat common form factor space for European cars. Compare the Mini and the SMART. * Chevy's Bolt is trying to be a normal "cross-over", and that's again where GM and Ford are almost entirely focused outside of trucks. * Early versions of the Nissan Leaf were hatchbacks of a Prius (or Tesla Model Y) sort, and recent versions look like tradition sedans. All of that is of course my opinion, but claiming that the existing car companies are doing their own thing and Tesla is somehow the only one doing "proper" cars seems to be the inverse of reality: Tesla is doing their own thing, and everybody else is trying to do what they think the market will best support (and it is not traditional looking sedans). (Plus, the VW ID family is already gearing up to eat the rest of VW's lineup as they drop the diesel lineup like its hot. BMW is doing the same. We're about to the tipping point where EVs are beyond early adopter-focused, one-off models, and manufacturers are about to hit every form factor with an EV or two.)
- adrianmonk 7y agoMatching Tesla's models head to head isn't the only conceivable strategy for taking the electric car market from them. It presupposes that Tesla has chosen to target the right market segments with the right type of products, and all you have to do to win is make better versions of those products. I'm not saying that Tesla hasn't chosen correctly. Maybe their product lineup is optimal or maybe it isn't. I'm just saying that your criticism of the article is based on this assumption.