6 ms·
Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a MicroSD Card (2018)
- ohazi 7y agoAlso A2 performance requires operating system level support, and all of these tips go out the window if you're using the card for a Raspberry Pi. https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2019/a2-class-microsd-cards-offer-no-better-performance-raspberry-pi https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2019/a2-class-microsd-card... https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2019/raspberry-pi-microsd-card-performance-comparison-2019 https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2019/raspberry-pi-microsd-...
- jsjohnst 7y ago> MicroSDXC cards use the exFAT system by default. Windows has supported it for over a decade, but macOS only since version 10.6.5 (Snow Leopard). Snow Leopard was released a decade ago[0], so seems like their choice of wording is indicating a bias there. [0] 10.6.5 was released in Nov 2010 however per Wikipedia, so almost 9 years. Still feel my point remains.
- Zenst 7y agoWorth adding that exFAT has aspects that Microsoft hold patents for. Yes they do license for a flat fee, though not aware Apple holds such a license. Also it wasn't until circa 2009 that the SDCARD collective adopted it as a standard. That and wasn't until 2013 that a GPL Linux driver was available. So yes, very unfair to bash Apple about over this, you raise valid concerns. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExFAT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExFAT
- gumby 7y ago> Worth adding that exFAT has aspects that Microsoft hold patents for. Yes they do license for a flat fee... When exFAT was released I added this to the Wikipedia entry only to have it reverted within hours. Hmm.
- csande17 7y agoThe article says it was "updated in" 2018, but the Wayback Machine has a copy of it from 2015 with that line included: https://web.archive.org/web/20151024052332/https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/5-mistakes-avoid-buying-next-microsd-card/ https://web.archive.org/web/20151024052332/https://www.makeu...
- zamadatix 7y ago> First, hardware that supports microSDXC slots won’t automatically support every size of card in this format. The Samsung Galaxy S9, for example, officially supports cards up to 400GB. There’s no guarantee that your 512GB card will work. Does anyone have a real life anecdote of a device which supports a given version of the standard not be able to use a card of the same version larger than the device supports? I've yet to run into it and always considered it a misunderstanding from issues when newer versions of the standard came out with higher capacity being conflated with what the manufacturer was able to validate on release date but maybe I've just been lucky.
- jbob2000 7y agoSure. The ecoboost Ford mustang. If you put the engine from a Mustang GT in the Ecoboost mustang, the crankshaft will explode. You can totally mount the engine from the GT in the ecoboost, it's the same frame, but the rest of the car is not engineered to support that much horsepower.
- nicoburns 7y agoI think the parent meant specifically with SD cards. I've personally never had issues using higher capacity cards in devices that didn't officially support them...
- stevekemp2 7y agoBack a few years I bought a large CF-card for a Canon 5D camera, which was just not recognized.
- jbob2000 7y agoOhhh my mistake, I thought they were looking for examples of this in other fields.
- rootusrootus 7y agoPresumably the crankshaft is in the engine, so it should be fine. The transmission, driveshaft, differential, and axles may not be up to the task, however. But it will be torque that breaks them, not horsepower.
- cbanek 7y ago> hardware that supports microSDXC slots won’t automatically support every size of card in this format. The Samsung Galaxy S9, for example, officially supports cards up to 400GB. There’s no guarantee that your 512GB card will work. This part drives me nuts. I wish devices would just follow the spec, and accept up to the maximum capacity. But it seems like device manufacturers end up testing the biggest card when they make the device, and as time marches on, you have to search Amazon reviews to see which cards work and which devices have hardcoded smaller limits on capacity.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> But it seems like device manufacturers end up testing the biggest card when they make the device I mean, they can't test hardware that doesn't exist yet, so what is the alternative? If there's a hardcoded maximum, that's one thing, but we don't know that's what is going on, do we?
- osamagirl69 7y agoThe lack of available hardware to test hasn't stopped PC manufactures from supporting media larger than available for a given interface. There are occasionally hiccups, like the whole debacle where the MBR partition table (from 1893) was limited to a few terabytes and the industry switched over to GPT, but even today if you put in a >2TB disk into an ancient machine that does not support GPT it can usually at least use the portion of the disk that it can address. Just read the spec and write your software to support it. It is not like we are asking for support of terabyte SD cards on machines released with the maximum SD card size was 128MB.
- Digit-Al 7y ago> MBR partition table (from 1893) I still think it's quite an impressive feat to support that much data before computers even existed though lol
- mixmastamyk 7y ago
- brazzy 7y ago> Counterfeit cards correctly report the capacity shown on the packaging, but actually contain far less. You won’t notice this until the card fills up unexpectedly quickly. Oh, it's much worse than that. Counterfeit cards are often manipulated to lie to the OS about their capacity as well. They don't "fill up" at all, they just throw away your data, or overwrite it silently.
- MisterTea 7y agoThat is downright evil. I suppose in order to find an evil card one would have to fill it with a file and then verify that files integrity, a very time consuming process form larger cards.
- Rychard 7y agoNot to mention that counterfeit cards are normally much slower, further increasing the tediousness of this process.
- rtkwe 7y agoYeah that's the only guaranteed way to find them I've found. There's a couple programs out there that do exactly that. Just start writing files to the SD card and read then read them back. I think they should be a bit more intelligent though, seems like right now they write the whole value you enter as the stated/test value then try to read it back, seems like you could detect bad devices much sooner by doing smaller read tests at set intervals.
- fheld 7y agothe German Computer magazine heise made a tool[0] to verify the capacity by filling it up with random files: [0] https://www.heise.de/download/product/h2testw-50539 https://www.heise.de/download/product/h2testw-50539
- gruez 7y agoYou don't even need such a tool if you're on mac/linux or have msys/cygwin/WSL installed on windows. just do dd if=/dev/urandom bs=1048576 count=5000 | tee test.bin | md5sum (substitute bs=1048576 count=5000 with the actual size of the sd card) then do md5sum test.bin and check whether the two hashes match.
- Causality1 7y agoSomething the article doesn't mention is that there are older SD readers with firmware limitations that drop their size limit even below the 2GB SD standard. An example of this is the reader built into the TC1100 tablet pc, which is limited to cards 1GB in size or less.
- Razengan 7y agoReading about all this kind of shows why Apple must have decided not to include SD slots in their iDevices.
- tacotime 7y agoI think a more likely reason is so that they can charge $150-200 for an internal storage upgrade of 200-250GB and push their iCloud service. This wouldn’t work so well for a manufacturer like Samsung who is not as differentiated from it’s competitors.
- poizan42 7y agoThe SD Card Association seems really short-sighted when it comes to capacity. Compare to the world of harddrive where ATA-6 introduced LBA48 which allows for capacities up to 128PiB all the way back in 2003, while SDUC introduced in 2018 is still limited to 128TiB.
- AnthonBerg 7y agoMy takeaway from the article is that SD cards are a mess information-wise and that I will continue to not buy or use them.
- alister 7y ago> We’ve all owned flash memory cards that have stopped working for no apparent reason. MicroSD cards and SSD drives use exactly the same technology (NAND flash memory), so it’s a mystery to me that microSD cards are unreliable, but SSD drives are extremely reliable. Genuine SanDisk cards have failed on me for no apparent reason, but I’ve never had a problem with SSD drives with much greater usage.
- alibert 7y agoIt's the controller and the reserved/backup flash. SSD have a powerful ARM CPU running and optimizing memory cell wear and replacing these on the fly with the reserve. SD cards doesn't have that mostly for cost and size constraint.
- rasz 7y agooh but they do https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=3554 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=3554 The difference is in using lowest quality leftover Flash memory.
- martin8412 7y agoI must say that I have never had an SD card fail on me. I use two in my primary camera that are setup for mirroring just in case. One in my pocket camera and one in a Raspberry PI. So maybe that's why I haven't experienced any failures. Don't know if model of card has any relevance, but I only buy the SanDisk Extreme Pro cards.
- egdod 7y agoWhat an absolute mess. I’m a technical nerd, and I can probably do the research necessary when I need a new card... but we expect ordinary people to figure it out? Not likely.
- la_barba 7y agoWhich part are you having trouble with? Seems very simple and straight forward to me. Your "ordinary people" comment doesn't mean much TBH. It is no different than buying a tire, you have your speed rating, section width, load index, maximum inflation pressure, wheel diameter, etc, etc. Wow.. so many crazy numbers !! How do "ordinary people" ever buy a tire.. :)
- egdod 7y agoThey don’t buy tires on Amazon. They buy them from someone who’s going to install them and make sure they fit.
- jolmg 7y agoPersonally, I always thought knowing how to buy a tire is common knowledge. They even sell tires at Walmart, and it's not hard to figure out, you just match the numbers. You've made me curious, though.
- egdod 7y agoI’m fairly certain my mom would have no idea how to pick out her own tires.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whenchamenia 7y agoTbh, most people get it wrong. Tire codes in the usa like 205/55r17 96R pack a ton of info into a small space. Sure, most people can match those, but knowing which you can adjust is helpful. 205 is the approx width of the tread in mm 55 is the height of the tire, expressed as a ratio reletive to the width r usually meant Radial type tire, but has just become part of the standard notation iirc. 17 is the inner diameter in Inches 96 is the Load rating expressed as non linearly scaling variable, needing a chart,in this case 1565lbs. R is the speed rating, which is usually, but not always in alphabetical order due to weird grandfathered codes. In this case, it means the tire is safe to speeds up to 106mph. While not hard, it is complex. You can run a taller(sometimes) or shorter(usually) sidewall, or wider(often) or narrower(almost always) tread (within reason), but you can not under rate the load, use a different inner diameter, or signifigantly slower speed rating.
- neves 7y agoI've had cards that I could fill with the designated size, but in speed tests would be slower than the manufacturer specification. Does anyone here also have these kind of problems?
- eitland 7y agoAny advice on where to get good cards for Raspberry Pi usage? I mean it seems like most I have had wear out way in a few months even with next to no use.
- finchisko 7y agoAlso make root fs readonly. DietPi distro claims they do it out of box. Same for openwrt, they mount /var dir as tmps and do writes only there. For raspbian http://blog.pi3g.com/2014/04/make-raspbian-system-read-only/ http://blog.pi3g.com/2014/04/make-raspbian-system-read-only/.
- lozf 7y agoPrevious discussion suggests using cards designed for Industrial use, and/or minimizing writes (e.g. mount /var on a tmpfs) where possible. More info in the comments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16775768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16775768