3 ms·
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/12/technology/leaked-google-video-trump.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/12/technology/leaked-google-...
by keiferski 7y ago
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/12/technology/leaked-google-video-trump.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/12/technology/leaked-google-...
- kajecounterhack 7y agoJust read the article. FWIW when conservatives are "afraid to share their views" it's different than when progressives do, because a lot of conservative views will run counter to a code of conduct. Corporations need to be inclusive environments where all competent people have the space to do their work. Rejecting intolerance in the workplace is the only rational thing to do. If you let people be racist, sexist, or otherwise make another person feel threatened, that's not OK. If you feel threatened because you're a racist or sexist, well the onus is on you to grow up and recognize what's really broken here.
- thosakwe 7y agoWhat I dislike about conversations like this on HN, is that comments like the above don’t get downvoted because they are detrimental to the conversation, or because they are in some way a rules violation, but rather because people just don’t like them. It defeats the whole “moderation” purpose of self-moderation. And it happens every single time a political issue like racial bias in the tech industry is the topic at hand.
- sloppycee 7y agoMaybe equating 'conservative views' to racism and sexism _is_ detrimental to this conversation? We're talking on an article where an employee interpreted _silence_ as racism! There is a valid point that (non-bigoted) conservative opinions are being silenced. i.e. Say you think that we should reduce the immigration rate, and wanted to discuss your reasons with your coworkers -- would you feel comfortable discussing that @ a SF tech company?
- fzeroracer 7y agoThe problem is that your opinion doesn't exist in the a vacuum. If you talk about reducing immigration while saying little to nothing about the horrible treatment of people at our borders, then naturally people are going to take offense because you're ranking the value of reduced immigration over the value of treating people humanely. I've had many discussions with coworkers with me taking up both stances as a steel man and/or devil's advocate and not once have I felt uncomfortable about the discussion. You should be concerned about certain actions of very powerful people in high offices poisoning the well of discourse before you consider what you're trying to debate because context is everything. I find that is something frequently ignored when people discuss why they feel like they can't speak about certain things.
- sloppycee 7y agoThat's great advice - but it amounts to 'be careful and qualify your opinion to show you're _not_ racist'. That's exactly what people are complaining about. The migrant detention issue has absolutely nothing to do with the topic of _legal_ immigration. Bringing it up does nothing other than to distract and prevent discussion on the original topic! If we could just discuss issues _in good faith_ and stop with the name calling we might actually be able to solve some of them -- together.
- fzeroracer 7y agoI mean, if you're talking about racially charged topics (of which immigration unavoidably is) you should expect to have to be careful. I'm not sure what else to tell you. The migrant detention issue absolutely relates to legal immigration because if you talk about reducing the number of legal immigrants, depending on your proposal that means people will be reclassified as illegal immigrants and subject to being detained. You can't talk about immigration while trying to ignore the elephant in the room. Because when people point out the elephant and you ignore it or don't have an answer, then your argument is a poor one.
- Supermancho 7y ago> If you talk about reducing immigration while saying little to nothing about the horrible treatment of people at our borders, then naturally people are going to take offense because you're ranking the value of reduced immigration over the value of treating people humanely. I don't care if people are offended. I don't think the topic about humane treatment is two-sided, so I have nothing to add. I think I have to figure out what I think about broader immigration issues, so I choose to talk about that. I do not subscribe to the implicit ultimatum of "either you are interested in what I consider the most pressing issue, or you're implicitly supporting the opposition". You think it's an elephant in the room and I would say granted that's true, I don't think it's an argument that needs to be rehashed. I think it will change toward the obvious resolution without additional fanfare (Trump will be gone within my lifetime), so I don't spend time on topics that I think are decided. Policy is always playing catch up. That's how this society works.