3 ms·
From your last paragraph the term you are looking for is "common carrier". Email goes over common carrier networks between private hosts and so is pretty close
by taneq 7y ago
From your last paragraph the term you are looking for is "common carrier".
Email goes over common carrier networks between private hosts and so is pretty close to a common carrier network. Twitter isn't and doesn't. Maybe there should be a way for web services to provide a similar service with similar protections.
- zenexer 7y agoIn the US, at least, this isn't true. ISPs aren't considered common carriers--you can thank Ajit Pai for that. If it were true, it would be true for both Twitter and email. Messages from both systems hop between neutral providers in the exact same manner.
- tremon 7y agoLet's avoid the contorted legal definition here, and instead use the real-world definition where "common carrier network" means using an established protocol for routing and delivery, in which many separate entities work together to establish network reach.
- zenexer 7y agoIn that case, it's true for both Twitter and email. The exact same network is used.
- DiseasedBadger 7y agoTwitter has denied that it is a publisher in court. It is a Common Carrier in effect, and has benefited - to the detriment of its competitors - from common carrier protections. Any time Twitter has been called to account for what it publishes, it claims it's not a publisher. Give them what they want.
- zaroth 7y agoThey are a platform distributing UGC protected by the CDA. Any discussion of “common carrier” is entirely orthogonal, and basically nonsensical in the context of something like Twitter. “Common carrier” generally arises as a trade-off for a government granted monopolies based on limited access right-of-ways. This was true for railways, and true for telephone wires. Why would this apply to a random service like Twitter?