13 ms·
Ceramic-bearing bicycle drive shaft (2018)
- avip 7y agoNot unrelated to the patent https://patents.google.com/patent/EP0105949A3/ko https://patents.google.com/patent/EP0105949A3/ko
- NietTim 7y ago2019-08-16 Application status is Expired What a funny coincidence (Not implying anything about the company in article, the article is from july 2018)
- to1y 7y agoThat can be very easily changed. Infact i'd say most writers do change it either to appear older(to add credibility) or newer(to stay relevant.)
- mattkrause 7y agoI, too, thought I had magic patent expiring powers, but that line shows today’s date and the status as of today. If you check tomorrow, it’ll say “2019-08-17 Application status is Expired” instead.
- NietTim 7y agoOf course, this makes so much sense, and it changed indeed, hahaha
- ptah 7y agoa video or animation would be helpful
- srrr 7y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UFAQ6CzNm7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UFAQ6CzNm7s
- londons_explore 7y agoThe sideways forces on those sprockets are going to lead to very rapid failure...
- laputan_machine 7y agoAbsolutely, putting full-load on those sprockets is not going to happen, either the sprockets will bend or the bearings will pop-out. Interesting design tho
- makomk 7y agoPrevious HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17494226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17494226 Can't imagine this catching on. Ordinary chains are already really efficient, and the efficiency of this will only last until dirt gets into all those tiny little open bearings. (Sealed bearings would eat into the efficiency gains.)
- jacobush 7y agoSomething which would be cool would be a electric hybrid drive. Electric generator + electric motor.
- nradov 7y agoYou can already buy electric bicycles. But regenerative braking on such a light vehicle doesn't gain enough to be worth the extra weight.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- braythwayt 7y agoI know someone who uses an electric cargo bike. It has regenerative braking, and perhaps the extra mass of carrying loads is what makes it practical. I believe it uses the Bionx system, which uses a direct hub drive. The company is lo longer in business, IIRC.
- jacobush 7y agoI don't know if it's feasible, but I was thinking motor <-- cabling --> crankshaft with integrated generator Not necessarily any battery, but the electric cabling replacing chains.
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoYou can buy e-bikes with regenerative braking. They don't advertise it much but as far as I know, all Stromer's [0] e-bikes have it. [0]: https://www.stromerbike.com/en_INT.html https://www.stromerbike.com/en_INT.html
- asteli 7y agoWhat are the efficiency numbers when using normal, grease and shield laden bearings? This might have a place in cycle sprints or other short distance disciplines where you have a lot of time for prep, but the benefits are quite moot if you have to swap or service bearings every hundred km.
- avip 7y ago92-96%
- logicallee 7y agoare those actual numbers or are you just showing it is high? I'd have guessed it's more like 99%. isn't anything that isn't heat or noise = perfect efficiency? a normal bike chain doesn't get hot or make much noise at all, does it? seems to me just about 100% efficient. maybe transfers a bit of vibration to the rest of the frame? but not 8%-4% of its transferred force....
- steve19 7y agoI think the GP is right, I did a quick Google and found sites saying 93-97.5% and it depends on power output. I would expect a dirty chain to be worse.
- logicallee 7y agothanks, that is certainly interesting.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoAn athlete will only generate ~200w which isn't a lot for a fairly large metal part with plenty of air cooling. Even if it was only 50% efficient you might struggle to notice an appreciable change in temperature. Motorcycles can have 150hp engines (~100kw) and even then the chain doesn't get particularly hot.
- vr46 7y agoI’ve had two shaft drive motorbikes now and appreciated the low maintenance and general cleanliness but they are heavier than chain drives. On a bicycle, this looks great, although it would be better off enclosed for protection - but fewer showhorse points.
- Theodores 7y agoThe detail about changing gears is glossed over, there is that big stack of what look like sprockets so it is assumed that changing gear is possible, but, get to the bottom of the article, and it isn't. This is doing well as a fake-halo product for Ceramic Speed and their existing products, it is a crowded marketplace and not many people care about bike bearings, this product makes people aware that there is room for efficiency gains.
- toxik 7y agoAgreed, shifting is the big problem. This would basically need a clutch to stay efficient.
- cr0sh 7y ago> The detail about changing gears is glossed over, there is that big stack of what look like sprockets so it is assumed that changing gear is possible, but, get to the bottom of the article, and it isn't. Actually, it's not - take a look at the renderings again. If you notice (and the article details) the rear "cassette" is actually a flat disk with concentric "gearing" which the roller bearing "gear" on the shaft interfaces with. Switching gears would be accomplished (in theory) by moving the roller bearing "gear" in and out along the radius of the rear disc "gear". It reminds me in a way of old wood "peg" and "lantern" gearing seen in wind/water mills and similar old power transmission systems, except in this case the "peg" gear is a formed or cast disc, and the "lantern" (which you couldn't shift due to the plates at the ends) is a "ring" of bearings, the bearings forming the "teeth" of the gear (which isn't that strange, if you understand how a simple gear is basically formed out of partial circles along the edge of a larger circle, all "joined up"). They do mention though, at the end of the article, that they can't shift gears easily and something about an internal wireless servo (which I think is kinda daft). I would instead use a splined shaft, and just change the "length" of the shaft to move the end-gear in/out of the wheel gear, and actuate it with a normal lever and bowden-cable type arrangement, though that might interfere with their efforts/want for more efficiency...
- Theodores 7y agoThe thing is that this gadget has been doing the rounds of trade shows for more than a year with this unfinished detail of having it actually change gear. There is this difference between theory and practice. So even if there was a solution - yours is elegant b.t.w. - then it would take a whole lot of testing and fine tuning to get right. I am actually quite astonished at how bicycle parts evolve, the derailleur took the best part of a century to get indexed gears and those took decades to go from clunky to smooth. What took so long to get right? Scores of refinements were needed, e.g. to the sprocket teeth profiles, to being able to manufacture a decent chain to basics of friction in cables. Then there is the challenge of mass manufacturing these things so they are durable and precise. I am not dismissing the ceramic speed shaft innovation - it gets people thinking - but I doubt my bike will be losing its chain any time soon!
- wlkr 7y agoI think the biggest innovation of this kind that I've seen in use (anecdata, of course) is the number of commuter bikes fitted with belt drivetrains (Gates Carbon Drive) paired with internally geared hubs. The reduction in maintenance effort is purported to be significant and it's not only limited to high-end bikes (plus it can be retrofitted although non-trivially for the majority of frames). When the cog wear becomes too bad on my single-speed I'll look into fitting a belt drive, if possible.
- nordsieck 7y ago> commuter bikes fitted with belt drivetrains (Gates Carbon Drive) paired with internally geared hubs. The reduction in maintenance effort is purported to be significant My understanding is that the tradeoffs are: 1. Weight 2. Cost 3. Lack of user serviceability. It definitely seems like a good tradeoff in some circumstances - particularly in rainy environments.
- maaaats 7y agoOr snowy with salt in the winter. For winter cycling the weight isn't really an issue for me, the bike is already sluggish with big studded tires and accessories and clothing etc. Maybe I will try it, the serviceability cannot be worse than the stuff I have to do now to maintain it..
- nordsieck 7y ago> the serviceability cannot be worse than the stuff I have to do now to maintain it.. My understanding is that you can't maintain the hub shifter at all. It's sealed so it's generally pretty low maintenance, but if/when it eventually breaks you have to send it to the factory for repair.
- romwell 7y agoIn my many years of having bikes with internal gear hubs, some new and some decades old, I've never had a single with them. The internal gear hubs have been perfected before derailers even became a thing; it's a very mature tech. You can[1] do some maintenance on them. I don't have any experience with that, as all my internally-hubbed bikes were stolen long before such a point :-) :-( [1]https://www.sheldonbrown.com/internal-gears.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/internal-gears.html
- Empact 7y agoWas a fan of Dynamic Bicycle's earlier (now discontinued) version of this, but not to the point of ever riding or buying one. They used an internal hub gear for shifting: http://web.archive.org/web/20160124015048/http://shop.dynamicbicycles.com/Runabout-8-18-Frame-Size-Runabout8S-18.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20160124015048/http://shop.dynami...
- iicc 7y ago(2018)
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 7y agoThanks for actually pointing this out, when I read the article I thought I'd seen the exact same concept bike in a Global Cycling Network (GCN) video last year. Makes sense.
- the-dude 7y agoWhat is the news here? In NL cardan-bicycle's are commercially available.
- Jackim 7y agoThis design doesn't use bevel gears.
- snak 7y agoI'm an enduro and downhill rider myself, and I don't see these coming anytime soon to the "mountain bike" world. Looks fragile and susceptible of failure under high forces and dirt/mud.
- mellett68 7y agoI agree. I couldn't see it surviving many pretty routine - well, routine for me - crashes.
- collyw 7y agoI actually thought they had the potential to keep more mud out than a conventional chain.
- deaps 7y agoA conventional chain could be caked in mud, but it literally cleans itself - the contact points anyway. Also, if well-lubricated they're pretty good at keeping water and such out of the internals as well - or at least easy enough to clean up when you get home.
- salty_biscuits 7y agoI am waiting for gearboxes to become competitive with derailleurs. Would totally be up for getting rid of that fragile and expensive part.
- romwell 7y ago>I am waiting for gearboxes to become competitive with derailleurs You mean the internal gear hubs? They've been competitive for over a hundred years[1]. I had a bike with an 8-speed SRAM[2], it worked fine (got stolen one day). [1]https://www.sheldonbrown.com/internal-gears.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/internal-gears.html [2]https://www.sheldonbrown.com/sram-g8.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/sram-g8.html
- salty_biscuits 7y ago
- deaps 7y agoI think one of the biggest problems is as the rear cassette shifts toward a larger gear, flex could become an issue. The driveshaft will push out on those larger gears making the 'disc' flex toward the wheel. Those larger gears are where you'd be when climbing a hill - where you're typically putting out a good bit of power too. It's a great idea, and I do love innovation. I've honestly never really had a problem with a chain though, myself. I have about 6,000 miles on my cross bike (that gets used in some pretty dirty, dusty, sometimes-muddy conditions). And maybe 2400 on my newer road bike. I just clean the chain with wd-40 when it's dirty (sometimes water/soap first if really muddy), dry it well with a rag, then apply some liquid chain lubricant (sometimes after every ride, if it's needed).
- seedie 7y agoTheir motivation is not to reduce maintenance but to increase efficiency. "[...] the company had already pushed the envelope with lubrication, bearings and pulleys about as far as possible — creating a roughly 98% efficient driverain" “The quest was, how can we get a 99% efficient drivetrain?”
- samstave 7y agoI have more miles than you :-) (14,000) ((I have exclusively biked for over a decade)) But you know what might be an interesting design idea: Make a shaft drive like this which is centrally aligned. But the bike has TWO rear wheels as closely spaced as possible and the shaft drives a single axle for the rear -- but has more gearing up front... But make the two rear wheels with a camber such that they angle out slightly such that their centerlines are as clos as possible - allowing for turning to be essentially the same as a single-rear-wheel bike...
- cr0sh 7y agoI'm curious as to how you would drive both rear wheels with a single central shaft? Both sides would rotate in opposite directions; I can't find a good example to illustrate what I am saying, unfortunately. I trust you understand what I mean. Now - there might be a way around this, but it would probably introduce more complications and friction to the mix (one way would be to drop/raise the central shaft off-center of the driving wheels centerline, then have separate fore/aft gearing on the shaft to drive the wheels in the proper direction).
- betimsl 7y agoIt's never going to work.
- samstave 7y agoAs a 100% bike commuter for the last decade..... I need one of these YESTERDAY. How get. Ill trial the fuck out of this thing.
- rasz 7y agoyou need this 1% efficiency boost? one percent
- victorbojica 7y agoWhat I'm curious about is, how robust is it? How does it handle bumpy rides and rough terrain? The article doesn't say anything about it and i can't tell
- bdamm 7y agoNor can anyone, because it doesn't actually exist as a product that can be tested. This pops up every few months for some reason, with the same note: The rear shifter is not controllable. A wire to the back half with a bearing to a ring around the drive shaft would solve that, but I'm guessing that messes with their stated high efficiency goal.
- buro9 7y agoHaving been dumb enough to use ceramic bearings in a BMX bottom bracket, and in the hubs of a mountain bike... I would not purchase this system. The replacement rate for those bearings would be astonishing.
- olyjohn 7y agoCare to expand this comment? Do ceramic bearings have a higher wear-rate than a traditional steel ball bearing?
- parsimo2010 7y agoMuch lower wear and slightly less friction. But they cost roughly 10x as much going from a quality steel bearing. They are marketed as being faster but it's not noticeable in real world conditions. They might be worth it in some non-cycling applications (high precision motors or something). They also break if abused. Steel bearings might deform the balls or dent the race, but they will still turn. However, as long as there are people with $250 to spend someone will make a $250 set of bearings- don't forget to lube them with snake oil for the fastest results.
- speakeron 7y agoHambini has a good article on this[1]. The basic problem (apart from cost) is that only the ball bearing itself is ceramic; the inner and outer races are made of steel and the ball wears a groove into them which increases friction over time. Near the bottom of the article there's a 'power consumption vs kilometres' chart which illustrates this nicely. "Hybrid ceramic bearings are the equivalent of trying to run a locomotive on an asphalt road - the hardness differential causes the road (raceway) to become damaged." [1] https://www.hambini.com/blog/post/ceramic-bearings-vs-steel-bearings...-an-engineering-opinion/ https://www.hambini.com/blog/post/ceramic-bearings-vs-steel-...
- parsimo2010 7y agoYou fell victim to marketing. Full ceramic bearings tend to shatter. They aren't suitable for high impact applications, and just plain expensive for everything else. Hybrid ceramic bearings (ceramic balls, steel races) are cheaper, but the races will wear out at the rate of steel, so they are an expensive option that needs to be maintained. Your best value if you want fast bearings is to clean out the grease and replace it with something lighter like sewing machine oil or Bones speed cream. The downside is that you have to maintain it more often because oil doesn't stick around as long as grease does. Also, the difference between ceramic and regular bearings is on the order of 1 watt. You'd save way more time in a BMX race by wearing tighter fitting clothes, and if you are doing tricks instead of racing then ceramic bearings on a BMX bike makes no sense.
- parsimo2010 7y agoA little background on this and a thought: Friction Facts started out as a guy (with an engineering degree) that developed his own test equipment to measure drivetrain losses under load. He eventually published his own wax formulation so that a DIYer could replicate his best effort at reducing chain friction. It produced a chain that had about 4 watts of loss, which is pretty good. That's over 98% efficient for a person putting out 250 watts. 250 watts is high for someone that's never ridden a bike, doable for someone that commutes by bike every day, and a pro wouldn't even break a sweat. So going to 99% improvement, or "reducing friction by 49%" sounds like a lot, but you're only gaining back 2 watts out of 250. Also, Friction Facts felt really cool when is was just a backyard engineer publishing his results, but then he got bought and took all his results/website offline. Luckily the internet archive and many forum posts have the major results, but it felt kind of like he was selling out to the man. I understand that he has bills to pay so I'm not mad at him. I also understand that a regularly lubed bike chain has higher than 4 watts of loss and most people aren't willing to melt wax on their stove to wax their own chains (I do though). The CeramicSpeed concept couldn't shift in 2018 and they haven't demoed a shifting version as of August 2019. The pie plate at the back is only for looks, and claiming 13-speeds is totally worthless at this point. Heck, I could CNC a 30-speed cog for the back, since it would fit inside the diameter of the wheel. I predict that when a shifting system is functional, it will increase the complexity and add to the friction of the drivetrain, bringing to about the same level of friction as top end chain based systems from Shimano, SRAM, and Campagnolo. This is a promising idea, but ultimately it's worth more as a way to avoid patent infringement than it is to make a faster bike. Another smaller player, Rotor, makes a 13-speed system that shifts hydraulically. Rotor's marketing claims that hydraulics shift better, but everyone knows that it's just a way to keep from stepping on the established players' toes.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoIn round numbers, the drivetrain causes about 4 watts of loss. Tire rolling resistance costs about 40 watts (on regular roads with road bike tires; less in a velodrome and more with knobby, thick mountain bike tires). The bike itself costs 8 ~60 watts or so in air resistance, less for aero, deep-dish tri bikes and more for round-tube wide-tire gravel bikes. But more importantly, air resistance increases with the square of velocity, no matter your starting drag coefficient. The remaining 150 watts or so are caused by rider air resistance. And of course, all 250 watts are produced by the rider and dependent on their fitness level. Clearly, the best way to go faster is to put more energy in. Next, improve your posture to produce less drag. However, it's easier to spend money than to sweat and suffer, so people instead turn to aero bikes, tires, and the drivetrain.
- ben7799 7y agoNot sure why this is coming up again a year later. They put it out as a marketing thing. It had a bunch of impractical caveats. They haven't announced they solved any of the problems with it in the year since they put it out. The friction thing & drivetrain is mostly a non-issue. If you're riding fast enough to care the % drag from the chain/drivetrain gets smaller and smaller the faster you go. It's pretty much a non-factor compared to air resistance. You get way more benefit from doing some extra stretching and yoga so you can lower your handlebars and still ride hard than you do changing to ceramic bearings or fiddling with expensive lubricants or chains/belts/shaft drives.
- hadlock 7y agoAgreed, rolling resistance at 30mph (about the fastest you'll ever ride a bike, even down a steep hill) is about 50w of energy, whereas wind resistance at that speed is close to 1000w of energy. Compare to 10mph (average speed for most casuals) where your total wind + drivetrain is about 50w of energy. Wind resistance goes up by the cube, drivetrain is mostly linear.
- u801e 7y ago> Agreed, rolling resistance at 30mph (about the fastest you'll ever ride a bike, even down a steep hill) What do you consider a steep hill? There are hills here that I can routinely get up to 35 mph with a little effort. Many cyclists have gone downhill at speeds exceeding 50 mph [1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sc2nqMXlZWg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sc2nqMXlZWg
- CamperBob2 7y agoMost people who aren't hardcore cyclists with really nice bikes are going to chicken out around 30 MPH. Or they should. 30 MPH is fast on a bike. If anything goes wrong, it's going to hurt.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y ago
- rienbdj 7y agoiirc a single speed or fixed gear setup is already as efficient and the prototype can't change gear anyway...
- johnr2 7y ago> Ceramic-bearing drive shaft is twice as efficient as Dura-Ace, company claims A conventional chain in good condition is >90% efficient. How do you double that?
- tln 7y agoMaybe they should have said "half the inefficiency"
- tlb 7y agoHere's a picture I took of the 1899 version, in the fascinating bicycle museum in Amsterdam: https://imgur.com/ZnA4kEM https://imgur.com/ZnA4kEM
- Animats 7y agoRight, this is about going from 98% to 99%, which is not all that useful. Bearings today are quite good. Before ball and roller bearings, though, it was really bad.[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Peu5hH9vy7E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Peu5hH9vy7E
- kazinator 7y ago"The first shaft drives for cycles appear to have been invented independently in 1890 in the United States and Britain." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaft-driven_bicycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaft-driven_bicycle) This basic idea has had over a hundred years to take off. The particular design seen here appears particularly impractical. The rear shifting mechanism has a poor selection of gear ratios for road use. The gear ratios are not sufficiently close. In my bike I have a Shimano Claris (or Sora?) cassette like this: with 12-13-14-15-17-19-21-23 teeth: https://i.imgur.com/BFFBYzj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/BFFBYzj.jpg Even if the drive train has a bit more efficiency, if the gear ratios are bad, that will be a deal breaker, because bad gear ratios wreck the efficiency of the human power plant. The system has to be extremely rigid for the gears not to skip. If there is any flexibility in the system, it requires massive preload to hold the parts in contact. The chain solves this problem; its own tension binds it to the sprocket teeth. The rear engagement mechanism has a kind of gear made up of a dozen tiny bearings. Once dirt from road spray gets inside those, they are done. This is a basically a fair weather toy for yuppies who don't know anything about bicycles.
- Grustaf 7y agoMy God that’s an ugly crank!
- tcmb 7y agoThere's a very in-depth talk by Keith Wakeham, arguing that shifting is practically impossible with this system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9d_cBGXMwY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9d_cBGXMwY If I understand it correctly, the issue is that the driveshaft has to move from one "sprocket" to the next in a very small amount of time at high rotational speeds of the cassette. Because of the weight of the bearings at the end of the driveshaft, a very large force is required to accelarate it.
- rasz 7y ago1% drivetrain efficiency using fancy expensive fragile materials ... or $100 300W hub motor for effortless commute? choices choices