8 ms·
Uh Oh, Internet: Basic Mobile Video Will be YouTube-Only With MetroPCS Plans
- rue 16y agoI'm more stunned by the price: I pay 20€ for unlimited and unrestricted data access with a double SIM (one mobile broadband, other for phone). And they want to charge more for other video access?
- noamsml 16y agoWhoa. MetroPCS is considered cheap in the USA, as most plans are around 60 a month.
- rb2k_ 16y agoI was shocked too when I came to the US for a few months. In Germany, I just pay 9 cents per SMS/Minute and 10 Euros for a Gigabyte of data (per month). In the US, I had to pay about 50 USD per Month on T-Mobile. It would have been more if I actually told them I had a smartphone ("Nah, I've got an old Nokia, I just want to be able to get eMails").
- dantheman 16y agoI don't know what plan you have, but tmobile for me is 60 a month for unlimited internet, sms, 500 minutes, unlimited nights/weekends.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoWhat plan is that? I'm on tmobile and just upgraded to a Nexus S and all the unlimited internet plans seem to hit 70/mo or above. $30 for unlimited internet, plus $39 minimum for the rest. Would love to grab your plan if possible.
- rb2k_ 16y agoI used the "T-Mobile Even More Plus™ 500 Talk with FlexPay®" and added the featurephone internet "service"... I could only get edge anyway because of t-mobile's weird UMTS frequencies in the USA. I just had to set the proper APN and it worked (only edge, but that's just because I had a European GSM phone) p.s. I used google voice for texting, no need for stupid text message plans
- zacharyvoase 16y agoI’m shocked by how expensive mobile internet is in the US. I’m with giffgaff here in the UK, and I pay £10/month for 250 calling minutes, unlimited SMS and unlimited internet (no fair use policy).
- peterpaul 16y agoYea I was shocked after i moved from germany to the US. Even worse is the coverage here
- jonknee 16y agoPopulation density of Germany is 229 persons per km/sq. In the US it's 32. It's a lot more expensive to run the infrastructure for a country 27 times the geographic area and 1/7th the density.
- irons 16y agoThen explain why there's no EU-comparable regional service in areas of the US with far greater density, like any of the top ten metro areas. Even the cell carriers have large roaming-only gaps and dead zones, not just in the unpopulated western US, but on major freeways in California. Using national population density to explain the extraordinary relative suckage of US broadband is a straw man argument.
- kgermino 16y agoThere are some regional carriers but they're not necessarily well known. Not to mention that at&t, among others, have spent crap-loads of money lobbying to make it more difficult for smaller companies to get spectrum.
- metageek 16y ago>Then explain why there's no EU-comparable regional service in areas of the US with far greater density Because nobody wants regional service? There used to be regional service that was cheaper--I remember my parents signed up for it when they first got cellphones, around 2003--but it lost out in the marketplace, because people would cross a state line and be shocked by the roaming fees.
- dansingerman 16y agoMobile data seems very expensive in the US compared to Europe, but the States seem to be cheaper in most other areas: e.g. Petrol/Gasoline - $3 per gallon in the States, over $8 per gallon in the UK now.
- Tuna-Fish 16y agoMost of Europe taxes gasoline very heavily to encourage alternatives and discourage use. Here in Finland, roughly 75% of the price of gas at the pump is tax. Or in other words, we have a 300% gas tax.
- RK 16y agoMobile data seems very expensive in the US compared to Europe Just don't get on a train for a couple hours and stop in another country. Roaming data rates will kill you in Europe!
- bubing 16y agoYour satisfaction is our eternal pursuit. ( http://www.yessoso.com http://www.yessoso.com ) We specialized in the exportation of sport shoes and other products(clothing, bag,sunglasses,watches,belts,etc )which have great enjoyed popularty in the world market Many of our goods are on sales ,we can guarantee the crediblity by Pay-pal and delivery time .we would like to make a long termship. 1)Name : The perfect gift. 2)Grade : AAA+ 3)Package : in original boxes 4)Color : various 5)MOQ : 1 pc 6)Payment : Pay-pal/Western Union / Credit card/Moneygram 7)Ship-ping : 4-7 days with guarantee of customs clearance, drop shipp-ing is accepted to customers'demands. 8)Who-lesale: very low price, you can make a small order first to test quality and service. ( http://www.yessoso.com http://www.yessoso.com ) Online Contact . thank you.
- tjsnyder 16y agoThis is actually huge news as it marks the beginning of what many of us feared and destroys future entrpeneurship. I have no idea why the FCC decided mobile Internet should allow these practices.
- tzs 16y agoThere is competition in mobile internet, whereas for non-mobile many people only have one or two realistic choices. That could be why mobile gets less regulation.
- trotsky 16y agoSprint usb type mobile broadband plan: $59.99/mo for 5 gigs on 2 year contract. Verizon usb type mobile broadband plan: $50/mo for 5 gigs on 2 year contract AT&T usb type mobile broadband plan: $60/mo for 5 gigs on 2 year contract T-mobile usb type mobile broadband plan: $39.99 for 5 gigs no contract So yeah, it seems rather unlikely that any cartel like cooperation on tiering would evolve in this market. (EDIT: Updates, thanks for the pointers. I was cribbing from a dodgy web page it seems http://mobile-broadband-services-review.toptenreviews.com/ http://mobile-broadband-services-review.toptenreviews.com/ )
- asnyder 16y agoI don't know where you're getting your numbers from for t-mobile: T-mobile usb type mobile broadband plan $39.99 5GB no contract (even more plus webConnect)
- trotsky 16y agoHmm, you're right. I had gotten them from here: http://mobile-broadband-services-review.toptenreviews.com/ http://mobile-broadband-services-review.toptenreviews.com/ - I started getting them from sprint and verizon, but when I came across that and it fit what I had already found I went with it for the rest. Thanks for the catch! Quick check of the other 3 numbers shows that they're accurate according to the provider websites.
- baggachipz 16y agoAnd so it begins. The only way this won't run rampant is an immediate consumer backlash.
- jrockway 16y agoThey already solved that problem. Backlash-ing costs you $250.
- malchickhome 16y agoIs that the cost of an early termination fee?
- mcritz 16y agoNo. It’s $350 for an “advanced device”. So, backlash costs a great deal more than you think.
- runjake 16y agoUnless I read things incorrectly, current contracts are grandfathered in. Just don't renew.
- motters 16y agoBlocking sites because they're "not on the service plan" is likely to be much more acceptable in western countries than explicit censorship, as in Iran or China. It's authoritarianism dressed up as commercialism. In the post-Wikileaks era my bet is that governments will either encourage, or at least not do anything to hinder, the erection of walled gardens which make it more difficult for the average internet user to get access to unauthorised sources of content. The next decade could see a return to the Compuserve-like internet services which existed in the 1990s.
- grantheaslip 16y agoOh come on, do you really think that governments are so shook up over WikiLeaks that they might encourage ISPs to turn the internet into a series of walled gardens? For that matter, do you really think that they're that evil? Obviously they're not happy about WikiLeaks, and I'm not saying that governments or ISPs are perfect, but some perspective is badly needed here. What you've written screams hyperbole and is veering dangerously into conspiracy theory territory. Net neutrality is a real issue, but it's got nothing to do with WikiLeaks. Governments aren't as dastardly or hell-bent on destroying your freedoms as you (and many others on HN) seem to think. It's actually quite disconcerting that so many on HN think this way -- hackers (in the good sense) could have a lot of influence on the future of democratic nations, but this kind of anti-government slant has the ability to really hurt our credibility and keep us on the sidelines.
- mortenjorck 16y agoJust as the majority of hackers are decent people, so are the majority of people in government. But just as there are black hats among hackers, there are black hats in government. Just as it would be imprudent to ignore the potential threat of black hats on computer security, it would be imprudent to ignore the potential threat of black hats on freedom.
- ajkirwin 16y agoI believe it, frankly.
- 16y ago
- maeon3 16y agoFacebook Fee: $.95 Youtube Surcharge: $1.53 blogging package: $.25 Roaming charge (non approved sites): $5.21 Wikileaks download penalty: $10.00 Destroying net neutrality, killing what made the Internet great in the first place: priceless.
- motters 16y agoRight. You can effectively censor sites simply by putting subscription charges on them. It's a westernised version of China's Great Firewall.
- JonnieCache 16y agoPotential cost to the establishment of forcing all the hackers onto darknets: who knows?
- roc 16y agoThe ssh and vpn charges will predictably be outrageous and seriously curtail the popularity of darknets. Similarly with any alternatives that are centralized by service or protocol. It'd be an awfully tall technological order to create a distributed Tor-style traffic relay to the darknets. Or are you suggesting pirate wireless carriers? That said, if such a too-difficult-to-effectively-filter Tor-style relay came into being, that certainly would be a Big Deal.
- JonnieCache 16y agohttp://www.i2p2.de/ http://www.i2p2.de/ If they start banning the protocol from routers, we can tunnel it through other protocols. You can push anything you want through an HTTPS link. Good luck banning that protocol. Or we can do the wireless-mesh thing. There are a lot of people working on mesh-based peer to peer routing layers and DNS. Wish I could remember what the projects were called...
- davidj 16y agothey can just ban all hTTPS and whitelist banks, paypal, facebook etc
- jsm386 16y agoRemember the leaked slides for differently priced mobile services that leaked out a few weeks ago? http://blog.grouptexting.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/dip.jpg http://blog.grouptexting.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/dip.... That seemed like a worst case scenario that we might expect down the road...not within days of the FCC giving mobile broadband a pass on net neutrality. Hopefully this move backfires and forces the FCC to revisit their ruling (http://gigaom.com/2010/12/28/who-wins-and-loses-under-the-fccs-net-neutrality-rules/ http://gigaom.com/2010/12/28/who-wins-and-loses-under-the-fc...)
- abstractbill 16y agoWell that really sucks. I wonder how they'll be implementing it, and how plausible it will be for other video sites to make themselves unblockable.
- w1ntermute 16y ago> I wonder how they'll be implementing it, and how plausible it will be for other video sites to make themselves unblockable. Yes, I'd like some information on this as well. Will it be possible to circumvent their block using encryption? The article says only the videos themselves will be blocked, not the websites.
- rmc 16y agoIt will almost certainly be possible for technical folks like us to bypass their filters but that will still exclude about 99% of their customers. That 99% will probably grudgingly pay the few dollars more and complain about phone companies screwing them again.
- w1ntermute 16y agoIf they complain loud enough, it might be possible to get them to reverse their stance. From my POV, the problem is that only technical people are complaining, and no one else cares. I'm guessing that people will respond the same way most people in China do to censorship - with relative apathy. They have better things to do than worry about whether the internet is censored or not.
- motters 16y agoBehind the scenes I bet it will be the same censorship technology as used in countries like China. The only difference is the way that the censorship is marketed, in the form of service plans.
- dfj225 16y agoThis needs to be stopped. Wireless will increasingly become consumers primary Internet connection. If this becomes standard practice for wireless providers, freedom to access what content the user chooses will be effectively destroyed.
- peterpaul 16y agoHas anyone actually located where MetroPCS makes sets these rules? I have not been able to find them in the TOS
- madmaze 16y agohere: http://www.metropcs.com/presscenter/newsreleasedetails.aspx?id=1 http://www.metropcs.com/presscenter/newsreleasedetails.aspx?... "The $40 service plan offers unlimited talk, text, 4G Web browsing with unlimited YouTube access."
- kin 16y agoHow does that limit video to Youtube only? You sure this isn't just a marketing phrase? Is there concrete proof that other video players will not work?
- mcritz 16y agoMobile broadband is becoming mainstream. Congress & FCC really screwed this up at the worst possible time for consumers.
- sdh 16y agohmm, I'd better find those America Online CDs....
- detst 16y agoIt seems to me that lowering phone prices[0] -- making subsidies, and thus long-term contracts, uninteresting to consumers -- and LTE compatibility across networks will create a more competitive market, lowering prices and forcing these tactics out the door. Obviously, the carriers will do everything in their power to prevent the commoditization of their networks but am I crazy in thinking that's at least a path we are inevitably moving on? [0] http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2010/12/the-smartphone-explosion.html http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2010/12/the-smartphone-explosion.htm...
- wmf 16y agolowering phone prices making subsidies uninteresting to consumers I doubt it; irrational consumers will still choose "free with contract" instead of $100. LTE compatibility across networks I doubt this too due to frequency incompatibility.
- metageek 16y ago>I doubt [LTE compatibility] too due to frequency incompatibility. Are you sure? AT&T and Verizon both have frequencies in the 700 MHz range; I'm sure they don't have the exact same frequencies, but I'd bet that the same hardware can support them. At least, it's more likely than having one phone that can support, say, 1700 and 1900 MHz. Last I heard, the lurking problem with LTE compatibility was that nobody had agreed on how to do voice over LTE. We might wind up with a situation where you can roam from AT&T to Verizon (it's all IP), but you can't take an AT&T phone and activate it for Verizon.
- detst 16y agoAnyone more knowledgeable on this issue care to talk about LTE network compatibility? I don't see why we wouldn't have chips that work on multiple frequencies like today but maybe it's not that simple. Like metageek said, there might be an issue with LTE voice. This would finally bring a market more like Europe and other places around the world -- including their much more reasonable pricing.
- jawee 16y agoThey have Android smartphones... I'm very much wondering how this service will ever be able to work between the plentiful applications, including third-browsers (plus Flash support on 2.2). I imagine that the power user, at least, will have no trouble getting around it; the block won't be total either way.
- minalecs 16y agoOS has nothing to do with what ISP can block. The only thing someone maybe able to do is run all their connections through a proxy or private vpn.
- jawee 16y agoIt said the site would load but the video would not in the original article, which was part of where I was coming from. Plus, features like Opera Turbo inside of Opera Mobile, for instance, would make such proxies transparent to the user.
- Sidnicious 16y agoWe're going to be the crotchety old men and women calling carrier tech support in just a few decades: "Back in my day, you didn't need some big corporation's permission to look at pictures of naked folks on the internet…"
- aw3c2 16y agoIf Google would like to make a big stance for Net Neutrality, they could block connections from them. But I think that would be a big issue by itself.
- mindslight 16y agoHow is this scary new development? The budget option of proprietary bundled services has always existed, with the upsell being the unfettered internet. Youtube and facebook are not "the internet", but proprietary services that have been developed upon it. Surprise surprise, network providers used to bundling services look for a lowest common denominator for their base product line. That these services happen to deliver over IP is of little consequence. However, don't think that I'm advocating for walled gardens - the important part is to keep innovating and creating a wide demand for The Internet at large so that carriers are unable to presume that most customers only want bundled discrete services in the first place (thereby pushing competition on generic bandwidth. bittorrent+RC4 has done wonders for wired net neutrality).
- mortenjorck 16y agoI really wouldn't mind this at all if it weren't being sold as Internet access. Mobile YouTube? Fine. Mobile Facebook? Great. If it's a walled garden, call it that and discount it accordingly. But once you have "Internet" and "more Internet," something's gone terribly wrong.
- nooneelse 16y agoIndeed, at some point filtering and traffic shaping crosses over into false advertising if the output doesn't go by some other name than "internet service". It would be like paring down a luxury car until it is little different from a golf cart, and trying to sell it as a Lexus.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]