7 ms·
What is the alternative? There is a finite amount of screen space for listing alternative search engines. How do you choose what shows up there? (I'm not saying
by jrochkind1 7y ago
What is the alternative? There is a finite amount of screen space for listing alternative search engines. How do you choose what shows up there? (I'm not saying there couldn't be a better one than whoever pays most, I'm just not sure what it is, and none were suggested in this article).
If you just put, say, a text-entry search box (or select menu with dozens+ of options?) there to choose any of unlimited number of alternatives (with none on screen to begin with), it will definitely result in even fewer users choosing something other than Google.
- guelo 7y agoThere is not a finite amount of screen space there, scrolling lists exist.
- jrochkind1 7y agoThere is a finite amount of space for what shows up initially on the screen, and what shows up initially on the screen will have a HUGE advantage. (In the possibly small pond of ANYONE that changes the default). I suppose deciding that "AAAAAdvantage Searches" shows up on the initial screen, like the old yellow pages, would be one alternative to the highest bidder. Someone might consider that preferable.
- guelo 7y agoThe Firefox model is a good example. The initial short list of available search engines (7 slots instead of 4) is auctioned off but there's also a "Find more search engines" button with a list of 3,823 providers. This is not a problem that a UX designer would have a hard time with.
- jrochkind1 7y agoSure, that works. Do you think that would satisfy the OP? Why don't they suggest it in the article/their press releases?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThe Firefox model is very close to what's being proposed here actually: This is the short list that ships by default, and you can pick whatever search engine you want after the initial setup anyways. I think it's reasonable for them to say they don't want to have 3,823 options on the initial setup screen for the phone, most people are just trying to get through it and don't want an extensive decision-making tree before they can write their first text message. The difference here is that Google owns Android and Google doesn't have to bid. In my book, this is the case-in-point demonstration why Android and Chrome are the two properties that Google must be forced to spin off. Letting one company own both the dominant platforms and the dominant services that run on those platforms is a very dangerous mix.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> The difference here is that Google owns Android and Google doesn't have to bid. This is a nonsensical argument. What is the practical difference between Google bidding and Google automatically taking a place? If Google bids, that money goes to Google, so it's as if they didn't spend any money. In both cases, by Google taking a spot, Google loses revenue from the bidder who would have otherwise taken that spot.
- solarkraft 7y agoThat's kind of the point: Google should have to bid and the money spent shouldn' go back to Google. Such a thing would happen if Android was managed by a separate company.
- joshuamorton 7y agoThe money would go to Android, to sponsor android development. Would it suffice if Google broke down their financials enough so that it was clear that this money was invested in android, and not in, say, maps?
- ocdtrekkie 7y ago
- cmiles74 7y agoIt's not clear to me that Google needs to _earn money_ through this auction (one they enter free of charge, even!) Simply randomizing the list is better than always placing Google in the first screen of slots and then charging everyone else for a slot of their own.
- disordinary 7y agoI recall Microsoft would randomly show a preferred browser after their antitrust case? Google could randomly order the search engines.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoI think the ultimate problem is Google doesn't pay anyone. Google is the default winner in this scenario, they always list for free. Essentially creating a scenario where no matter who is chosen, Google wins. Either the user selects Google and Google makes money off of them, or they select Google's competitor and Google takes money from their competitors. An auction is a fair way to determine a group of options, but an auction where one party always wins for free is not. The solution is to break up Google, and force Google to bid for the right to show up on the list on Android-the-company's platform just like everyone else.
- ucaetano 7y ago> I think the ultimate problem is Google doesn't pay anyone They pay the OEM, don't they?
- GuiA 7y ago> Essentially creating a scenario where no matter who is chosen, Google wins Given that this is something entirely orchestrated by Google in an attempt to make lawmakers think that competition is A-OK and no legislation is needed to curb Google’s power, this kind of thing is to be expected.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoOn the contrary, I think this plan took a lot of gall to come up with. If Google's trying to avoid legislation, it should be "self-regulating" itself hard to try and prove legislation isn't needed. But this system is pretty transparent what it is doing and the EU is going to see right through it.
- GuiA 7y agoIt’s a closed auction run on their own terms, that excludes entire classes of alternative search engines by design. A “lot of gall” is a very generous interpretation.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y ago
- aylmao 7y agoRandom. No joke, it's fair. I also doubt Google is auctioning this space for the sake of fairness. Their competitors are going to take a slice of their cake, and this is the most efficient (and legal) way to get as much of it back as possible.
- jrochkind1 7y agoSomeone else said 3,823 search engine options are given in Firefox. (They still auction off the top 7 initially-on-screen options, apparently). How many of those do you think are... even really usable? I think it is not unreasonable to suggest that choosing randomly (for default, or for whatever X can show up initially on-screen without scrolling) is going to give many many non-expert users an unusable search experience, and an unusable Android experience to the extent that search is significant.
- duskwuff 7y agoMost of those 3,823 options [1] are site-specific searches, e.g. Wikipedia, YouTube video search, Amazon and eBay product searches, etc. They aren't "search engines" in the sense of services which search the Web at large. [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/search-tools/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/search-tools/
- jsnell 7y agoRandom selection would be extremely easy to abuse, and result in a garbage user experience. With random selection, creating new shell companies running some basic web search implementation and a ton of ads. With random selection and an unlimited supply of such entrepreneurs, the users would statistically always be forced to choose from one of four scammer search engines to proceed with the setup.
- tsunamifury 7y agoRandom is neither definable, auditable nor equal. It would be the absolute worst solution
- bachmeier 7y agoThe ones that are used the most. Accurate numbers might be impossible, but not many search engines see heavy use, and those are the ones you want to show if you care about consumers. This is the best you can do in the absence of lookng inside the brains of consumers.
- jrochkind1 7y agoThat's not bad. But I suspect it would end up being about the same list as the highest-bidders (although Google wouldn't make money from the auction), cause what you have to bid is probably pretty correlated to how many users you have, and there's no way Ecosia would be on the list.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duskwuff 7y agoFrom a practical standpoint, there are only two globally relevant search engines: Google and Bing. There are a few country-specific engines (Baidu in China, Yandex in Russia, etc), but they have very little reach outside their home countries.
- la_barba 7y agoWithout using a bias or metric, there is no way to filter a list of items. The only other option is randomness, and there is a notion of fairness to it, at least mathematically. Maybe the list could be 5 options chosen randomly. As long as number of users is several orders of magnitude over the number of choices, it could be considered as somewhat fair.
- reaperducer 7y agoHow do you choose what shows up there? What's wrong with a simple RAND() function? Give every option an equalish chance of being above the fold.
- dontblink 7y agoBecause it's a terrible user experience. They do want end users to easily find and select their preferences after all.
- gregknicholson 7y ago> What is the alternative? Stop Android from being a monopoly. This solution has the same problem as the Windows browser ballot — it starts from the assumption that the OS must continue being a monopoly.
- toast0 7y ago> Stop Android from being a monopoly How? Apple doesn't care to compete, they've taken the profitable users and sell them higher and higher margin devices. Microsoft doesn't care to compete, they killed the windows phone team and then killed the goodwill they had developed by releasing windows mobile 10. KaiOS doesn't really compete. Blackberry 10 didn't really sell.
- gregknicholson 7y ago> How? How do we usually stop companies from being monopolies? Do that. I don't accept that phone operating systems are a natural monopoly and that it's OK to have only 2 companies in a position to control them.
- skybrian 7y agoSuppose Google donates the proceeds of the auction to charity. Would that make it ok?
- dehrmann 7y agoOne place I worked, someone made the observation that every time there was something we felt dirty about doing, we'd suggest donating some amount of the revenue to charity.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoMy best suggestion if it's to be truly neutral: Allow all search engines with more than some small number of European users (say 10,000 monthly active users for six consecutive months, or pick a higher but still broadly attainable threshold) to apply for inclusion for free. Randomly pick four or five to show on the main screen each time, in randomized order, without treating Google specially. If necessary, have one special slot that cycles randomly among all the top several search engines in Europe, and exclude those from the other slots. Have a "More options..." link which shows every search engine who has applied, again in randomized order. That's it. But yeah, I don't expect them to be that neutral unless forced.
- Nasrudith 7y agoYeah that honestly would be a pretty shit UX. The closest thing I could see for relevance would be listing by users automatically which could make them look bad given it favors them.
- tinus_hn 7y agoIt would help if the revenue did not go to Google but for instance to charity.