8 ms·
I distinctly recall a USA top-ten business school with an ad for "Financial Engineering MBA" (yes, real math) showing a small, smiling brown-skinned woman in Fo
by mistrial9 7y ago
I distinctly recall a USA top-ten business school with an ad for "Financial Engineering MBA" (yes, real math) showing a small, smiling brown-skinned woman in Fortune 500 business attire. At the same time, top management at GE mentioned "financial engineering" as a strength in the business press.
Perhaps it is an obvious evolution of their complex asset leasing models from forty years ago to "financial engineering", but the implications of a USA engineering firm, outsourcing all the work and focusing on money tricks instead.. it just shouts everything that went wrong with American Business, to me.
- breck 7y agoIt makes me sad every time I see strong American businesses getting into the "financial engineering" business. It's not just GE. Every time I take a flight nowadays the attendants come around pitching some airline branded credit card; you buy a shirt at a clothing store and are asked to sign up for a credit card; buying diapers at Target--"do you want to sign up for the Target debit card"? American banks and "financial engineers" are good at screwing over the 80% of the population, and transferring wealth to the 1%, and the fact that they are able to pull in great American companies into their schemes is embarrassing, disheartening, and in the case of GE Capital, foreboding. For decades they were screwing me over and then when I joined the 1% it was suddenly, "hey, come open a bank account with us and we'll give you $5K!" Shameless.
- mikestew 7y agoThe onslaught is so constant, I sometimes just want to scream at a clerk, "JFC, what happened to just exchanging money for goods and calling it a day?!" Of course, it's not their fault, the person I want to scream at is well insulated from screaming customers in some corporate office somewhere. But $DEITY forbid the clerk not ask, because someone's numbers will be down. That part will filter right the fuck up to the correct person. Ignore your twitching knee when I say this, but it's one of the things I like about Apple: "here's some money. Might I have one of those fine devices you have on display?"[0] "Certainly my good sir! Let me fetch one from the back...here you are. Apple Care? No? A fine choice, sir! Have a nice day!" No cajoling about some card. If you don't want the extended warranty, it's a simple "no" and done. No popups on their internet properties asking to join their mailing list. I give money, they give me stuff. I'm sure there's some dark pattern I've missed, but for the most part the experience seems to be free of such jackassery. [0] Admittedly, this part needs work lately at their retail stores.
- mey 7y agoNot sure how this will evolve but I will leave this with you https://www.apple.com/apple-card/ https://www.apple.com/apple-card/
- breck 7y agoThis does make me sad. The shift away from hardware and software to "services" and "financial products". Despite the fact that I want the banks to be disrupted, I'd rather have a Stripe or Square or Coinbase etc do it, and have Apple focus on other things.
- nothatsfalse 7y agoOh God no! Not Square at least. They'll happily send your financial statements to random other people, then act like it's completely normal that they did that, and really weird that you're upset about it. Plus their customer service (for end users who buy products, not the merchants) is extremely adversarial. They have a really shitty chat bot that is the only way to contact them to get help when they screw something up. It's awful and very anti-consumer.
- option 7y agoYes please, this is the only card I actually want mostly for security, privacy, zero fees and expense tracking reasons. Disclaimer: I used to work at Apple in their online services division, and I know first hand that (at least during that time) they cared a lot about privacy (often against short to medium term financial gains)
- mikestew 7y agoYeah, I signed up for that the day the beta invite hit my inbox. See above for reasons why. We'll see how it goes.
- listenallyall 7y agoWhen you get the device home you'll need (edit: be asked) to sign up for an Apple ID and an iCloud account, I believe? They may not bother you at the point of sale but that's only because they know you'll be giving up your private info soon enough.
- rolltiide 7y agoAirline branded credit cards are not the same as store branded credit cards and none of this has to do with financial engineering. None of the comments in this thread do.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoYou're probably right about that not being "financial engineering", as I wasnt familiar with the term prior to this article. But other than airline rewards being generally valued more than store rewards, how are they different? I guess I can always tell the store worker "no thanks" before they start the annoying pitch, while the loud sales pitch on airlines is unskippable, blasted through everyone's audio system, and often happens when people are trying to sleep.
- rolltiide 7y agojust more fungible and improve travel experience and status. the cards themselves are more prestigious too and also accepted everywhere. not too much of a difference after that. consider noise cancelling headphones that aren't connected to the airplane media system
- listenallyall 7y agoAll your examples are marketing ideas and promotions. Nothing at all to do with financial engineering. As much as you seem to enjoy complaining, surely your favorite companies engage in the practice -- hedging currency risk, locking in stable fuel prices, avoiding interest rate shocks.
- breck 7y ago> - hedging currency risk, locking in stable fuel prices, avoiding interest rate shocks. I like these things. I have a lot of friends who are very passionate about finance and do very hard and valuable work in domains like that. Some do truly extraordinary work that goes on completely behind the scenes and makes markets serve businesses better. I guess what I don't like is when non-financial businesses get into the business of offering financial products. I would hope operationally they take advantage of smart financial engineering on the backend, but instead of spending valuable time in front of customers talking about credit cards, they should be talking about the thing they make (engines, air travel, clothing, retail, respectively). (Note: perhaps there's a better term for what I'm complaining about than "financial engineering")
- api 7y agoI've said for years that the MBA is the Western capitalist equivalent of the Soviet "apparatchik." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apparatchik https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apparatchik I wonder if the bullshit taught at top tier business schools starting in the 1980s isn't as responsible or perhaps even more responsible for the destruction of American industry than outsourcing, bad trade policy, and other more familiar villains. A generation or two of business leaders were systematically educated on how to trade away deep proficiency and substance for financial smoke and mirrors. GE is a microcosm of what the entire country has done.
- ineedasername 7y agoIt goes back further than the 1980's. It had its advent with the rise of business/managerial "science" that thought trained middle & senior managers could become standardized units of productivity to be swapped in & out of any position as equivalent units. It left out the fact that good managers have strong knowledge of the operations under them and the business as a whole, not just a managerial rule book.
- throwaway156503 7y agoIt would be helpful if people commented on why you were downvoted. Americans have no appreciation for businessmen and businesswomen with experience. Sales people at Levi's who don't know how to measure your waist, roofers who don't know how to repair roofs, only replace them, dealerships who don't know how to repair, only upsell to the newest car. Too much bullshit and not enough hardwork. Too many charlatans and not enough seasoned tradesmen, salesmen, and otherwise.
- bumby 7y agoIt's been a while since I read it but I think the book "The Firm" about McKinsey talked a bit about this movement and how business studies became a graduate degree.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoThe contemporary "top" MBA is a class reinforcement mechanism, nothing more, nothing less.
- ryanjshaw 7y ago> it just shouts everything that went wrong with American Business, to me. Quite the opposite. Sound financial management implies financial engineering. I recommend you study and understand the field before criticising it; it's not "tricks" at all.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoExcept when it is. See also Enron, the Trump "empire", Libor, gold price fixing, the 2008 crash, S&L, and many more.
- ryanjshaw 7y agoFraud != financial engineering.
- crispyambulance 7y agoGE was once a mighty company with amazing technology and R&D. Now they're a sad shell of what they used to be and consist of way too many bored finance people on a slowly sinking ship.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jhayward 7y agoIs that a definition, or a statement that financial engineering has nothing in common with fraud, or some other statement? From my view the greater the degree of 'financial engineering' in a company's P/L the greater the likelihood that some kind of fraud upon the investor or business partner is being conducted.
- jacobolus 7y agoAs an uninformed outside observer, I have seen a large number of companies that used to pride themselves on product quality, customer support, and treating workers well get bought by private equity or other finance guys (or maybe sometimes just taken over from inside), shed everyone competent, focus on cost cutting and nickel-and-diming customers, and start producing garbage products with no support, transforming the relationship with customers into a largely adversarial one. In many cases the finance guys have (legally?) embezzled large amounts of money while loading the companies with debt and then dumped them, leaving customers, employees, suppliers, and other investors holding the bag. I’m sure this process is considered to be “sound financial management” by some.
- hogFeast 7y ago2007 called. They want their insight back. GE sold off GE Capital over a decade now. None of the "financial engineering" relates to leases (although the dodgy accounting often does...but that is something else). Financial engineering is usually concerned with building and valuing pointless derivatives. In most cases, the derivative will pay equity-like returns with low volatility or income (stupid financial advisers go nuts for both). Invariably, these products self-destruct in a crisis (when the lads are off in their Ferraris) due to some bizarre optionality that is built in. The other side is valuation which is about employing a combination of inapplicable maths with a wilful ignorance of common sense (usually to satisfy regulators who will approve your bullshit and then come to work with you next year to make up more nonsense). The first task is dressing the pig up. The second task is inventing a mathematical formula that explains why the pig is actually a human. French banks are pretty much ground zero for this (I have no idea why). Also, nothing is particularly wrong with American business. Most firms are not involved in anything like this, and when they do get involved it is rarely a case of them deciding to do so. They do so because they feel they have no other choice (i.e. engineering firms provide finance so that people buy their stuff, GE Capital existed because of the torrent of cheap money that flooded the market in the 2000s). The general move to greater financial efficiency, however, has been a massive boon (look at places that haven't done that...Japan is a great example, you want to work 12 hours for a day for like $35k/year?).
- nosianu 7y ago> nothing is particularly wrong with American business I am in no position to argue and it is not my intention to do so. Instead, I have a question based on things I (causally) read. For example, this piece from a conservative source: https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/americas-monopoly-crisis-hits-the-military/ https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/americas-mo... Sample quote serving as TL;DR: > In fact, the destruction of America’s once vibrant military and commercial industrial capacity in many sectors has become the single biggest unacknowledged threat to our national security. Because of public policies focused on finance instead of production, the United States increasingly cannot produce or maintain vital systems upon which our economy, our military, and our allies rely. It is not really only about the military, but about a larger context. They seem to be quite concerned about the industrial base of the US, including in high-tech industries. In support of their point, when I look up chip manufacturing capacity worldwide - https://anysilicon.com/semiconductor-wafer-capacity-per-region/ https://anysilicon.com/semiconductor-wafer-capacity-per-regi... - Asia is 75% and the US ~10%. What is your opinion about the point made by the article? In the larger context, not necessarily the military focus.
- nguoi 7y agoI have no idea what the colour of her skin has to do with this story
- intuitionist 7y agoOr her gender. Or her size?
- salex89 7y agoVisualization sake? I often write like that, possibly under the influence of Russian/European 18th and 19th century literature I read during most of my life, thanks to education around here. It excels in overly detailed visualizations. Please don't start ringing alarms, not everyone is a biggot. Not saying the commenter isn't, just don't judge.
- esoterica 7y agoBrags about being a super duper educated person who reads 18th century literature and can’t spell “bigot”. Lol.
- salex89 7y agoFirst of all, English is not my native language nor I live in an English speaking country. Second, I didn't choose to read those books, the education system made me :). I don't read them that much today, but did enjoy it. Third, this is not bragging as I don't consider myself being super duper educated. I just read some books from time to time. I honestly thought it was the proper way to spell it, because I've seen it like that. The style just looked to me as people around me describe events, often starting with the look of the scene, including the person. Nevertheless, thanks for learning me how to spell a new word.
- dk1138 7y agoPerhaps just to call out if it triggers a memory for others who may recall the story?
- stickfigure 7y agoI think it's a mistake to imagine GE as some sort of monolithic "engineering firm". GE is a huge conglomerate with business in countless different industries (trains, nuclear plants, chemicals, light bulbs, jet engines, health care, missiles, oil & gas... the list just goes on). There's no way the MBA team at the top can have the faintest idea what's going on in each of those companies, engineering-wise. It's better to think of GE as a mutual fund. Management and financial engineering is what holds it together.
- jiveturkey 7y agoAll large companies, certainly 100% of the Fortune 500, are engaged in financial engineering. That GE does it is not at all surprising. To specifically call it that, publicly, is interesting. Was this a recent ad?
- papito 7y ago"Financial engineering" is pillaging the company while diverting money into ludicrous bonuses and raises at the corporate office. The top skill of most MBAs is sorting an Excel sheet by salary, in descending order, and deleting the top 10 rows to "restructure".
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y ago...and the top skill of most tech people is spreading superficial, malignant stereotypes of professions they fail to understand. Those include everything that is not a direct derivative of classical logic and mathematics, because they refuse to consider any creative or social domains to be "real". Because of this narrow view of the world, the tech crowd is constantly perplexed by the continuing dominance of that other tribe in their organisations as well as society at large. This inferiority complex causes them to indulge in ritualistic in-group demonisation, whereas the reverse manifests mostly in brief interludes of eye-rolling whenever the internet goes down.
- papito 7y agoAll correct as well. Hey, I own it.
- kevinali1 7y agoWoah... tell me more
- manicdee 7y agoHeh heh. Reminds me of one CEO of mine proudly holding up a Nokia n95 Navigator and telling us how the iPhone was trash and the n95 was the future of mobile phones. This was his excuse for not signing our retail provider up to sell Apple phones. Within a couple of years he had left to join the board of a small credit union with his crowning achievement being the introduction of low-balance fees and cash withdrawal fees. So yes, I am perplexed at how people like this keep getting highly paid executive positions while I am stuck in a damp cell in a poorly lit dungeon.
- 7y ago
- hangonhn 7y agoIt's inaccurate to say that GE outsourced all their engineering. That's not true at all. GE Aviation is a powerhouse and their engineering abilities is still world class. Despite all of China's advancements, creating engines like the type GE Aviation created is still beyond their reach (although they will eventually catch up). GE Power made a bad bet against renewables and went with gas but that's a business mistake, not an engineering one. They recently hit a milestone with one of their biggest wind turbines. So they're slowly fixing themselves. This is again a management error, not a lack of engineering abilities. GE Healthcare is still a leader in their field and also VERY valuable (along with Aviation, these two parts are the best parts of GE). What the problem for GE is that they've saddled themselves with financial engineering and moved away from their core competency to generate the numbers they want. At one point that made a lot of sense because it enabled their customers to make those large capital investments but then GE managers started using GE financial engineering to smooth over earning reports. Anyone remember when GE was the darling of Wall Street? GE was touted as this well managed firm that gave steady dividends. Well part of that steady dividend and growth came from these financial engineering methods and rather opaque accounting practices (to be fair other companies did similar things). I can't tell you if GE is a good investment or not. I am long on GE but this new report is pretty damning but as someone pointed out, the person behind the report is far from neutral. Then again, having followed GE for so long (I was long on them starting 2008, sold it all before the plunge, and now long again), there are no real neutral voices in this debate. This though is the fault of GE management, which is not as transparent as they should be.
- swframe2 7y agoI'm curious. Why are you still long on GE given today's news? Do you disagree with Markopolos' findings?
- hangonhn 7y agoSome of the counter points to the report holds water. The interest of Markopolos isn't neutral. And some long time observers have pointed out mistakes in his report. Accusation of accounting issues with GE isn't entirely new. GE is a beast and it's not transparent enough so that leaves a lot of room for speculation. It's probably one of the most divisive stocks out there (strong opinions on both sides). I think people with an interest in shorting it assumes the worst and vice versa. Also, the CEO purchased a whole bunch of shares before the report and again after the report. He is probably well positioned to know GE fairly well. It's not a necessary move on his part but it does signal some confidence in GE. Also, having watched him, I can see some inflection points. If you were to graph "sentiment" of news for GE for the past couple of years, it would be kind of a parabola: lots of negatives, then less negative, then it's mixed, and now it's more of "not good enough" (although today was a hugely negative one). In the end it's still a gamble. I'm not betting the house on it -- it's in fact a tiny percentage of my portfolio (I generally stick with index funds) but sometimes I like to keep myself honest by putting some skin in the game along with my opinions.
- lonelappde 7y agoLet's just say that the fact you thought it important to mention the height of the person in the ad is the first of several clues that your comment is... suspect.