5 ms·
Has anyone effectively dealt with the noise problem? Vehicles this size would be unacceptable almost anywhere people are present for the noise alone.
by tomcam 7y ago
Has anyone effectively dealt with the noise problem? Vehicles this size would be unacceptable almost anywhere people are present for the noise alone.
- sambroner 7y agoWould this be a problem if these cars exclusively took off from the top of sky scrapers? If I remember from my time in Nyc, above the 20th floor it’s quite hard to hear even the loudest noises from the street. Presumably from the ground, it’d be hard to hear one of these taking off on the 30th floor.
- downtide 7y agoI live rurally near a busy trunk road. I can walk about 1/2 mile away and the road is still in my line of sight, and it is still 'loud' (as in irritating). However, I'm blighted by this road as I'm so close to its proximity. And it disturbs me. However, I did notice when visiting a busy part of town recently that it was a complete aural assualt, and as such, you might hear/perceive less under the cacaphony of much. I can hear drones that fly over, but it's not a horrible noise. Much car noise these days seems to come from friction on the road as engines have gotten much quieter. So with that in mind, perhaps in all they'd be quieter, but I can't see an easy way to environmentally muffle the sound, could you invert the sound?
- ses1984 7y agoI would like to know what the measurement of the loudness when you are 1/2 mile away from the road.
- downtide 7y agoThe quotes around 'loud' here, is an emphasis on relativeness. There is a flyover down the valley and sound flies off that. You only recognise silence in the event of road closure. Then momentary bliss is attained through someone elses misery.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoIt severely restricts the potential market if you do this (only travels from one skyscraper to another are supported). For instance you can just completely forget about Washington DC, London and Paris, and many more cities. And even in cities with skyscrapers, they tend to be clustered in one or two districts, so you can only travel within a very small part of the city. My feeling about the current push for flying cars and autonomous transport, is that when our grandchildren ask us about it, it will be in the same way as children today ask why they were still playing violins when the Titanic went down.
- pilsetnieks 7y agoWell, skyscraper to skyscraper (or helipad, or other permitted areas) would be a start. Eventually the tech could catch up - for example, with materials like these - https://phys.org/news/2019-03-acoustic-metamaterial-cancels.html https://phys.org/news/2019-03-acoustic-metamaterial-cancels.... - being developed.
- imhoguy 7y agoSkyscraper cable cars would be less expensive/noisy/power hungry and with more capacity. https://arstechnica.com/science/2013/02/envisioning-the-urban-skyscraper-of-2050/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2013/02/envisioning-the-urba...
- vidarh 7y agoSkyscraper cable cars require them to be near enough to each other, which would limit them to far fewer city centres. London for example has very few skyscrapers, but several parts of town have some and quite a few more have a bunch of 20+ story buildings, but only two areas (City and Docklands) have many buildings like that clustered close enough for cable cars to seem potentially viable by far enough for it to possibly be interesting.
- xvilka 7y agoIt reminds me of Canopy from the Alastair Reynolds' Revelation Space book series.
- vkou 7y agoHelicopters are much louder than street noise. You may barely hear the street at the 30th floor, but a helicopter flying 300 feet above the ground is going to be incredibly loud.
- taneq 7y agoWe could solve the skyscraper-to-skyscraper problem much more effectively with a series of ziplines.
- benj111 7y agoI would guess that would be the pivot for Zipcar.
- nradov 7y agoMost skyscrapers don't have a safe space to land on the roof due to weight restrictions, antennas, HVAC equipment, etc. Modifications to allow flight operations would be expensive. Only a few existing skyscrapers have helipads.
- leoedin 7y agoThe Pan Am building in NYC used to have a helipad, but there was a crash [1] and it was removed. Today most western cities have helipads tucked out the way - on the river in London and NYC for instance - for safety. Every time a helicopter falls out the sky and lands on an unfortunate pedestrian, the rules tighten. That's not going to change with drones. [1]: https://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/05/16/may-16-1977-helicopter-accident-on-top-of-pan-am-building-kills-five/ https://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/05/16/may-16-1977-he...
- smacktoward 7y agoForget helicopters, the top of the Empire State Building has a Zeppelin dock: https://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/26/realestate/26scapes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/26/realestate/26scapes.html
- inflatableDodo 7y agoI think the major physics problem that is very hard to fiddle, if you want to achieve the popular sci-fi version of VTOL flying cars aerodynamically, is the requirement that the cross sectional area of downthrust air fits roughly inside something approaching a car's plan view while still having room for occupants and luggage. Purely to hover such a thing, never mind ascend at a reasonable rate, requires airjets that will blow pedestrians cheerfully across a street.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoNever mind the energy needed to consume to do so. I'm curmudgeony, I say the future is powered bicycles.
- hanniabu 7y agoHell yeah, bicycles with nice thrusters and wings that automatically extend out from drag at certain so that you can glide and coast a bit!
- benj111 7y agoMotorbikes? Or electric bikes? I must say I'm not that bullish (on bikes and electric bikes). Shopping, hills, rain, children all combine to mean they can't really do 100% of journeys. And human nature will ensure that that big expensive chunk of metal gets used as much as possible to make it worth the cost. Of course our car powered present doesn't involve 100% car transport so you could still be right, and it's still worth aiming for. Ps, if that counts as curmudgeonly I certainly have no hope, now get of my lawn.
- kerng 7y agoUber's concept showed car ports up on buildings, so flying cars wouldn't be on the ground I guess. In that sense not very different to helicopters and dedicated heliports.