7 ms·
This is the subtle truth that I've seen a few folks on Twitter talking about for the past year or so: That Google has slowly but steadily reduced both the outbo
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
This is the subtle truth that I've seen a few folks on Twitter talking about for the past year or so: That Google has slowly but steadily reduced both the outbound clicks to other websites, but also the portion of their revenue that's based on ads hosted by other websites, while bringing both the "results" and the ad placements in-house, where they no longer have to pay out a share to site owners.
Whereas Google was previously a way for sites to be discovered and for sites to generate revenue, it is increasingly becoming the sole source system where data is scraped and imported into Google, and Google keeps all of the revenue to itself.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoHonestly, the second google started owning and promoting their own properties on search results, anti-trust regulators should have jumped on it. I'm really not sure how Google can be protected by Section 230 and at the same time control and publish so much directly. Last time I read an article on the topic, google controls 23% of the top 100 sites.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoI've heard a decent amount of wrong takes on Section 230. But this is the most bizarre, yet. Neither the CDA, nor section 230 specifically, create the sort of publisher/platform dichotomy people seem to be hung up on. And Section 230 does exactly the opposite of what people commonly think it does. It's actually right there, in the text: No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be held liable on account of (a) any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material that the provider or user considers to be obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable [...] That seems really easy to understand: you can delete nazi propaganda, porn, bad jokes, or just random user content from your platform without running the risk of thereby assuming liability for the rest.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoBut the inherently problem is that they need to be held liable for the rest. Because the rest is often criminal activity of which those platforms are making a profit. Perhaps removing Section 230 isn't enough, by your definition, because we need a law that explicitly holds platforms liable for profits generated from illegal activity.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat is a curious definition of need. Are landlords liable in your world for renting apartments to people who run ponzi schemes?
- martin_a 7y agoWhen they get to know about that fact and do not take steps to end this behaviour, although it would be in their possibilities, they might be held liable, too. So ocdtrekkies point stands, imho. Google is directly profiting from shady activities through their services and therefore has no incentive to control or stop that behaviour. That's a tricky thing.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoNot in my world; planet earth is a large place. But in the country I live in, the USA, landlords are liable for many things their tenants do. A friend of mine is a landlord and he almost lost a house he owns because his tenant was cooking meth in it. I don't remember the exact details, but the liability was no joke. P.S. I don't agree with this liability issue, I'm simply describing reality as it is.
- icebraining 7y agoSection 230 didn't prevent Google from being fined $500M for publishing ads for Canadian pharmacies selling drugs to US citizens. What kind of illegal activities are you talking about, exactly?
- ocdtrekkie 7y ago
- buboard 7y agoAnecdotally, i am noticing a steady decline in adsense RPMs for the exact same audience over past 2 years, and adsense is now most of the time not filling the ad slot. Also, it has gotten very hard to rank in google for new sites. SEO blackhat tactics rule, and even local businesses use them. Google went from win win to win-get lost. Sadly, now that webmasters need it the most, investments in alternatives to search and advertising have dried up. There is almost nothing except G.
- ALittleLight 7y agoI feel the same way about ranking new websites. In high school, friends and I made a website for which we did zero search engine optimization (nor were we even aware of search engine optimization). We still ranked in relevant queries and easily got an audience of about ten thousand uniques a month. Today, I struggle to get sites I make to show up on Google at all. For my most recent website, even searching for phrases that are unique to my website doesn't cause it to rank. This is more frustrating to me, because I have a Google ad for my website, which drives all of my traffic - so I know Google knows about my website and what keywords are relevant to it.
- ummonk 7y agoTo your last sentence specifically though, I wouldn’t want Google to use ads data to influence non-ads rankings.
- anotheracc 7y agoGoogle has turned an Ocean into a pond - I think we'll all be the better for it once they're gone. Regularly cannot turn up results that I know exist - a modest change that has no relation to the query meaning and the results often turn up. This is not the Google Search Engine I remember.
- avip 7y agoI had to google turn an ocean into a pond as I was not sure what the phrase entails. I got few images of small cars and your comment. QED
- luckylion 7y ago> Whereas Google was previously a way for sites to be discovered and for sites to generate revenue, it is increasingly becoming the sole source system where data is scraped and imported into Google, and Google keeps all of the revenue to itself. I wondered yesterday: if you provide microdata, Google scrapes it, and you later decide to remove your sites from Google - is Google allowed to keep the microdata and continue to publish it?
- lonelappde 7y agoRemoval is irrelevant because Google doesn't rely on a license for its index. robots.txt is a courtesy, not a legal obligation.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIf you once communicated the fact that 2+2 is 4 and Joe makes very good spaghetti you own the copyright to the text you published but neither the fact nor the opinion belongs to you in any meaningful way nor should it.
- luckylion 7y agoThat's true, but a collection of facts ("a database") falls under copyright.
- TheSoftwareGuy 7y agoIANAL, but as long as google is only distributing the individual facts (not the database of facts) they would be in the clear, legally
- michaelmrose 7y agohttps://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/database.html#data https://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/database.html#data This doesn't provide any protection for the underlying facts.
- 7y ago
- iClaudiusX 7y agoThe increasing sprawl of non-search widgets invading the search result page reminds me of the AOL years where "the web" was funneled through a narrow portal controlled by one entity. Having to scroll down past ads, unrelated news, unrelated youtube videos, and ever more of these info boxes has pushed the actual content I'm looking for out to the second page. It's made it much easier to use ddg as default and use the !g flag only when absolutely necessary.
- judge2020 7y agoAnd the downfall of AOL was Google because Google had a better product. In order for google to fall, you need a product that's better (or more of what people want; you need to give them a reason to change their search engine).
- anotheracc 7y agoI have no trouble believing Google is going to fall. Their results have gone into the toilet - I ragequit Google search about once a day and do something else like forum searches.
- kryogen1c 7y agoSame. I cant tell if my questions are just getting more specific and technical, but Google search results have been getting pretty useless in the past year or so
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoSame here. It seems the websites that show up top are become more and more spammy and less relevant to my query. I keep seeing all sorts of one sentence hipster 2.0 sites that want me to believe they are a credible source of information.
- x0 7y agoI love how google likes to completely ignore what I'm trying to search for. I wish I could think of an example because it happens to me often, but I can't so I'll make one up. Imagine you're searching for tail lights for your car or something, but you don't know the size, so you search "Astra tail light size". This might bring up headlights. Wrong but no matter, you'd go on to google "Astra tail light size -headlight -head" or something. What Google seems to have been doing to me recently is ignoring those negated terms, ignoring quotes, and just giving me the same results again and again. It's really getting annoying. Google seems to assume it knows what I'm looking for, and that my search query is just completely wrong and not what I want. Note that the car stuff is just an example, I'd expect Google to not give you headlights the second time. It generally but not exclusively happens to me when searching things that are more technical. ESPECIALLY when it's a consumer level thing I'm trying to get info on, Google likes to assume it's giving you errors and you're trying to fix it. Which makes sense for most users, but god it's frustrating when every combination of advanced search parameters you try does nothing! Google search needs a checkbox or something to turn off it's cleverness and just do an actual search.
- Iv 7y agoI think most of my zero-click search are a quick question on something you can find at wikipedia. Well, I don't see the problem at google providing a cache to save WP's bandwidth. I block ads anyway...