6 ms·
What do you think are the chances that the tanks roll in, all protestors are shot or arrested, marshal law is declared for a few months, and eventually Hong Kon
by londons_explore 7y ago
What do you think are the chances that the tanks roll in, all protestors are shot or arrested, marshal law is declared for a few months, and eventually Hong Kong becomes just another city in China without its own special governance or laws?
- xhruso00 7y agoKilling people in Hong Kong would put China into very difficult political position in the world. New sanctions would emerge and this is something China doesn't want. I think they will go with martial law & arrests.
- cattlefarmer 7y agoThe world stood around and did nothing as China put Uighurs into concentration camps. Why would this be any different?
- kenneth 7y agoI think we're still pretty far away from that. China has a lot to lose on the international stage if anything like that were to go down. They would much rather have the local police deal with it (since the local police is aligned with Beijing) and keep plausible deniability. If anything, I think the threats of involving the army are more about (1) deterring supporters and (2) planting the seeds of this idea that this is something they can do, to give themselves the option in the future. I could be wrong, but I certainly hope not. If the army rolls in, I'll probably seriously reconsider sticking around and might book a one-way out of here, because at that point it might well turn into a war zone.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoI'm not sure we can say that the police is "aligned with Beijing". Whatever one's opinion of what the protesters are demanding they are breaking the law and rioting (as per Hong Kong law that dates back from British rule), and many of their actions are simply not acceptable. They are really not helping themselves. The police will respond to that anywhere.
- PlasticTank 7y agoFunnily enough tyrants don't usually listen unless forced, this is what a fight for freedom looks like. Some things are more important than convenience and money.
- pimmen 7y agoThe reaction from a Westerner is ”wow, this is nothing compared to all the crazy shit we had to do to get democracy, and now with the democratic institutions and independent justice systems in place, definitely worth it”.
- culturestate 7y agoHaving lived in Hong Kong (and China) for a long time, I think you're wrong. I doubt very much that protesters will be shot in the streets or anything so drastic, but the city is very close to having the PLA openly deployed to "back up" the HKPF.
- loyukfai 7y agoFYI, some alleged that mainland policemen are already operating inside the HKPF. Personally I think the PLA option is a non-starter at the moment. HK for all its bads is still vitally important to the Chinese economy especially during the current trade war with the USA.
- culturestate 7y ago> FYI, some alleged that mainland policemen are already operating inside the HKPF. This is why I said "openly." Economically, Hong Kong is increasingly irrelevant to China - it's only like the fifth largest city by GDP, and there are 10 more catching up quickly. HK is far more important as a symbol, and if I were Xi Jinping headed into a turbulent global economy with flagging growth at home I wouldn't want it to look like I couldn't control my people. That said, it's a delicate balancing act. Too little response and you seem weak; too harsh and you draw international condemnation and confirm the worst fear of everyone who is counting on China to join the world order rather than try and upend it.
- loyukfai 7y agoPLA is different from PAP though although we may just be disagreeing on a technicality. BTW, HK while definitely not the economic powerhouse it once was, it still has a pretty special place as a truly international city for the PRC government, which is something intangible and cannot be expressed in pure GDP number.
- cmroanirgo 7y agoPretty high: https://twitter.com/AlexandreKrausz https://twitter.com/AlexandreKrausz (This is already another HN post "Chinese military entering Shenzen just across the boarder with HongKong": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20683940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20683940)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoThere's a third way; getting "Singapore-d". In the 1960s Singapore annoyed Malaysia so much they were essentially ejected from the federation against their will. It was a major shock at the time, but decades later the two countries are still mostly amicable. I sincerely hope China would consider this route.
- culturestate 7y agoThis will never happen under the current regime, if for no other reason than it would embolden Taiwan to "declare" independence and give the world cover to acknowledge it. Taiwan is far too strategically important to China to allow that.
- loyukfai 7y agoAgree. Don't count on PRC under the current leadership to think anything remotely like that.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoWhy would China even consider "ejecting" a part of its territory that they fought over for a long time to finally get back? Recovery of lost territories and reunification of the country is a core policy of the Chinese government(s) since 1912... And as noted in the replies, striving for national unity is an ancient theme of Chinese national psyche.
- loyukfai 7y agoFor some perspective, in 1912 the Communist Party of China wasn't even a thing.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYes, for Chinese these territorial issues are bigger that the Communist Party. In Western countries they would be called "bi-partisan" or "cross-parties" because there is a national consensus on them.
- ephemeralism 7y agoWhy would they do this and not just continue to use riot police and tire the protesters out, as has recently been done with success in France?
- adinobro 7y agoThat seems to be what they are doing. University starts again soon and it is expected that the protests will loose steam. That's a boring story so people don't talk about it.
- the-dude 7y agoDo you have any sources for the 'tire out' and 'with succes' in France? Because from my view, they are still going strong.
- majia 7y agoIt's more likely that the protest causes huge damage to HK economy, and HK people start to get tired of it. At some point people may decide to take economic incentives from Beijing and become another city in China with some superficial autonomy status.
- loyukfai 7y agoIf that's true the anti extradition bill amendment would have gone throught and the 2M people or however many wouldn't have turned out to the street on 16th of June. https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3014695/sea-black-hong-kong-will-march-against-suspended https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3014695...
- Nasrudith 7y agoWhat is the value of not being disappeared? I highly doubt they would have any takers.
- Accujack 7y agoOne small nitpick: Marshal Law = halfway decent comic book Martial Law = military dictatorship of an area