5 ms·
Just like you have the "choice" between cheap veggies (sparkled with monsanto's health elixir that may or may not be damaging to you and the environment) vs loc
by lm28469 7y ago
Just like you have the "choice" between cheap veggies (sparkled with monsanto's health elixir that may or may not be damaging to you and the environment) vs local/bio veggies which cost a bit more, sure. Once you flood a market with cheap alternatives it becomes a race to the bottom and it's a losing battle for the customer. Plus it's not like you'll walk into a fast food / street restaurant and have the choice between cheap imported beef vs local beef either.
As far as I can tell it was the classic "Accept our deal or face consequences" type of US foreign policies. I can't be the only one thinking that importing meat from the other side of the world for a purely economical reason is insanity, especially when the local meat market is perfectly fine and of better quality.
Reminds me of all the meat scandals we had in the last decade in France, all of it coming from foreign countries, all of it due to companies trying to increase their margin at all cost: horse meat sold as beef, sick/old animals sold as healthy, minced meat made primarily skin, cartilage and other by-products, yummy...
- vorpalhex 7y ago> a race to the bottom and it's a losing battle for the customer How dare those customers get to have access to cheap food! They should only be able to buy organic, local approved veggies from their local overpriced grocery store! France didn't want to import US Beef (fair), the US threatened to not import French cheese in retaliation (seemingly also rather fair).
- coldtea 7y ago>How dare those customers get to have access to cheap food! How dare customers want to have access to healthy AND cheap food. They don't get to chose both! And what's with the wages "race to the bottom" ensuring everybody will only be able to get cheap food - if at all? >France didn't want to import US Beef (fair), the US threatened to not import French cheese in retaliation (seemingly also rather fair). Yes, fair as well. So? (Although one is a crappy, unhealthy beef grown in abhorrent conditions, the other is high quality cheese).
- vorpalhex 7y agoOne is a cheap high protein food wildly available produced by well paid workers, the other is a very expensive geographically protected cheese product. You may not like US beef, and you don't have to eat it, and you're probably well off enough that you get to make that choice. Protecting a domestic cheese production probably doesn't increase food availability for the poor - nor is that domestic cheese production some health food.
- coldtea 7y agoSorry, I don't want crappy "food for the poor" and healthy "food for the rich". I find this dystopian, and a false dichotomy. And those advocating are usually those "well enough" that don't have to suffer the "food for the poor" themselves. >Protecting a domestic cheese production probably doesn't increase food availability for the poor - nor is that domestic cheese production some health food. As part of the typical French diet, as is its use in France (and Europe), it's much healthier than the kind of crap passed for food to the poor in the US, or the fads peddled year after year as some "miracle food" to richer consumers (quinoa, chia, kale, and such).
- pixl97 7y agoYea, let's till under every square acre of land to produce massive amounts of corn that we turn into animal feed extremely inefficiently, oh and pump out gigatons of HFCS fattening up the world around us.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoLets understand why we're here. Corn was first to be hybridized and resulting seed marketed. As yields grew, farming became more stable and farmers less poor. Corn got cheap and many commercial applications (starch, syrup, protein, fibre) seized on it as a practical source for many products. Like VHS vs Betamax, sure there are better choices for food and commercial uses. But corn won, won early and won big. It'd cost trillions to switch to something else now. So complain all we like; still we find ourselves in the same place. Corn is king.
- bdauvergne 7y agoStrangely it did not happen in France[1], we do not use as much corn sub-products in our agriculture and food, I think it's mainly used for feeding our poultry; still a bad idea as corn is not really adapted to our climate (not enough tropical rain I suppose as corn is a tropical plant coming from Mexico), most of the farmers crying when there are water restrictions are corn farmers in France. Biggest french region cultivating corn is Les Landes which was a big swamp before the 18/19th century, maybe because it's more adapted to corn as it rains often (oceanic climate) but is hotter than Brittany. [1]: https://www.agro.basf.fr/fr/cultures/mais/basf_agro_et_la_filiere_mais/ https://www.agro.basf.fr/fr/cultures/mais/basf_agro_et_la_fi...
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoUnless you drink Pepsi? Its 1/3 corn syrup.
- distances 7y agoI don't think it is in Europe? The recipes vary a bit according to tastes, so I'd assume sugar is from beet in European soft drinks. Wouldn't make much sense to import syrup for such a bulk product.
- lm28469 7y ago> France didn't want to import US Beef (fair), the US threatened to not import French cheese in retaliation (seemingly also rather fair). The local shop didn't want the mafia's "protection" (fair), the mafia killed the shop owner (seemingly also rather fair). More seriously I don't think allowing foreign entities to destroy your local means of productions brings any good in the long term. Once your local producers are out of business you're essentially relying on the goodwill of some for profit companies to not increase the price of their products, or you're at the mercy of "The Market™️". Especially for something as fundamental as food.
- vorpalhex 7y agoIf your local means of production means either forcing other people to buy it, or keeping the price of food artificially inflated, maybe your local means of production isn't real great. This isn't the mafia killing a shop owner for not buying them. This is your customer leaving because they don't like your prices. You don't get to force people to do business with you.
- lm28469 7y ago> keeping the price of food artificially inflated, maybe your local means of production isn't real great. Really makes you think about how Europe did for thousands of years before our great American saviors helped us. Local food wasn't expensive before globalisation, talk to your grandparents you'll see how different things were not so long ago. > This is your customer leaving because they don't like your prices. You do understand that when the market is not flooded with cheap subsidised alternatives that issue doesn't exist ? Fresh/local products were not a niche market a few decades ago, it was simply all that was available. You didn't have to buy cheap bananas from costa rica because you simply didn't have access to bananas, so you bought local apples &c. you couldn't buy cheap beef from the US because all the meat available was local and priced so that people could afford it. > You don't get to force people to do business with you. But apparently you get to say "Accept our subpar products or we will make you pay!", and I genuinely fail to see the difference in practice. If this isn't some form of abuse of authority I don't know what it is.
- kiliantics 7y agoThe solution to this problem is for consumers to organise and buy produce on their terms, by forming food co-operatives. Buy the food you collectively want in bulk from the wholesalers and then sell it back to yourselves as customers. This removes the overhead of profit (and often labour, the highest cost, if co-op members do shifts at the store) and in many cases marketing, packaging and other costs. It thus allows you to have access to healthy, fresh, local, sustainable, etc. food at a reasonable price.
- mcculley 7y agoI asked the same question of the tweet's author and I realize now he was trying to describe the EU's ban on hormones. I think every region/community should be allowed to decide what is banned. It was not clear to me from his wording what he meant by "demanding that Europe accept American beef stuffed with hormones".
- orwin 7y agoThe issue is not really hormones (they are the political reason, but not the technical one). The true issue is the antibotic abuse: this is a bio threat, especially for farmers and rural guys. Let's say you're walking your dog in the countryside. You fall somewhere, it gets infected, so you get some antibiotics. Those antibiotics do not work after 3 days because they were used in the next door farm, and bacteria is used to them. Now you have two solutions: * you are educated (or at least knowledgeable) and you know that if the antibiotics do not show any effect after 3 days, this is caused by resistance, so you go to the doctor again and he gives you type2 antibiotics. * You are not knowledgable and you let the infection get worse. You have two new solutions: * * You're young and in good enough shape: depending on the bacteria type, you will suffer for some time, probably have troubles walking and lasting scars. * * Are you old and/or in a bad shape? Tough luck. Depending on the bacteria type, you might die.
- pfdietz 7y agoAllowing countries to decide what to ban is just saying that ag goods are exempt from free trade. Why should the US put up with this? We have a natural advantage in agriculture, with very high productivity. If you're against free trade, ok, but that's going to apply to European exports of all kinds. And if the trade motivation for links with Europe goes away, so does the motivation for defending Europe via NATO. NATOxit (NATOff? NATOut?) would cost Europe enormously.
- ahartmetz 7y agoThe US are also banning some food that isn't banned in EU. Now what - should European countries leave NATO about it?