4 ms·
The main idea of "molecular Darwinism" is that the initial life for had a very short DNA [1]. While the species evolved, the short DNA evolves and got longer [2
by gus_massa 7y ago
The main idea of "molecular Darwinism" is that the initial life for had a very short DNA [1]. While the species evolved, the short DNA evolves and got longer [2].
* For example some genes are repeated, a bad copy may repeat a gene and the DNA get longer. Virus may cause some duplications too.
* Some genes are almost repeated,each copy has a slightly different function, so each one has a variant that is better for each function. The idea is that an error in the copy made two copies of the original gene and then each copy evolved slowly differently.
* Some parts of the DNA are repetitions of a same short pattern many many many times. IIRC these apear near the center and the extremes of the chromosomes, and are useful for structural reasons, not to encode information. The DNA can extend the extreme easily because it's just a repetition of the pattern.
* Some parte are just junk DNA that is not useful, but there is no mechanism to detect that it is junk and can be eliminated, so it is copy form individual to individual, and from specie to specie with random changes. (Some parts of these junk may be useful.)
So the idea is that the initial length was not 1000000000, but that the length increased with time.
Your calculation does not model the theory of "molecular Darwinism". Your calculation is about the probability that is a "human" miraculously apear out of thin air with a completely random genome, it will get the correct one [3].
[1] Or perhaps RNA, or perhaps a few independent strands of RNA that cooperate. The initial steps are far from settle.
[2] It's not strictly increasing, it may increase and decrease the length many times.
[3] Each person has a different genome, so there is not 1 perfect genome. The correct calculation is not 1/4^1000000000 but some-number/4^1000000000 . It's difficult to calculate the number of different genomes that are good enough to be human, but it's much much much smaller than 4^1000000000. So let's ignore this part.
- GregoryPerry 7y agoAgain and irrespective of how much genome information was there initially and what it eventually became, you are still talking about a final optimization problem of 4^1,000,000,000. Even one tenth of that amount of the human genome is an unfathomably large number to randomly iterate to given the generally accepted statistics cited above. The math behind stochastic molecular Darwinism doesn't work out at all.
- fourthark 7y agoI don't see where you are getting the idea that humans had to be pulled out of a hat of all possible genetic sequences. They, like, evolved, right? As the GP says, there was a short sequence that worked, a little got built on, a little more... There was never any time that any creature was generated by random choice.
- GregoryPerry 7y agoGot math?
- GregoryPerry 7y agoWhat in the world are you talking about? This thread of discussion is about the computationally intractable nature of 4^1,000,000,000 Got math? Maybe post a proof?
- fourthark 7y agoTell me why evolution would require all of those combinations to be tried? Edit: Microsoft Windows 10 is 9GB. It would be impossible to try 8^9000000000 different programs. Yet, Windows exists, and most of us believe it's contained in those 9GB.
- GregoryPerry 7y agoSo per your logic the Windows 10 operating system was created by random iteration of x86 opcodes over a lengthy period of time? Huh?
- fourthark 7y agoExactly the opposite. Just because there are so many possibilities doesn't mean that all of them have to be tried or make sense. You wouldn't code that way and nature doesn't either.