5 ms·
I installed encoder knobs to emulate potentiometers There's really no need to force this decision to go in either direction. Ever since I first heard of capac
by CamperBob2 7y ago
I installed encoder knobs to emulate potentiometers
There's really no need to force this decision to go in either direction. Ever since I first heard of capacitive multitouch, going back to the timeframe before the first iPhone announcement, I've been waiting for someone to build 'stick-on' encoder knobs that the touchscreen controller can read.
These would simply take the form of a knob with a metal leaf or other polygonal electrode in its base, whose rotation could be sensed by code similar to that used to implement crappy 'virtual potentiometers' on existing touchscreens. The fixed part of the knob base would be epoxied or otherwise bonded directly to the screen surface, or perhaps held in place with some sort of frame.
Doesn't seem to have happened yet despite being an incredibly obvious (and inexpensive!) thing to do. Seems like the MIDI community would be all over something like this, even if no one else considered it worthwhile.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eropple 7y agoThis reminds me of the Surface Dial. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/surface-dial/925r551sktgn https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/surface-dial/925r551sktgn Being able to set the dial on the screen and just turn it is a really good-feeling workflow, though likely not for something as mission-critical as the article is describing.
- CamperBob2 7y agoWhat I had in mind would cost closer to $0.99 than $99.00, though. (Well, OK, $9.99.) The Surface Dial was a relatively complex Bluetooth device; it didn't work through the touchscreen itself, except to the extent that the touchscreen somehow knew that a Surface Dial was resting on it.
- zaat 7y agoAccording to the spec it uses the touchscreen, or at least some touchscreens: >On-screen detection: Touch digitizer reports the onscreen location through a capacitive pattern (Studio only) https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/surface-dial/925r551sktgn?activetab=pivot%3aoverviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/surface-dial/925r551sktgn?...
- CamperBob2 7y agoRight, to sense location, not rotation. Rotation goes through Bluetooth, as with any number of existing knob controllers.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoWhat if the metal base of the rotatable knob has a certain rotationaly asymmetric pattern instead of being completely flat? We would then be able to receive that pattern and understand how the knob is rotated. What’s the resolution of todays touchscreen?
- ethbro 7y agoIt's an interesting thought. You'd want to use a full bandwidth data channel (e.g. Bluetooth) for anything complicated. But for simple things, if possible without affecting the other parts of the screen, it'd be amazing to have a broadly supported, low bandwidth standard.
- gugagore 7y agoI can't really make sense of the bandwidth (information rate) of a tactile interface. A measure in units of length would make more sense to me.
- namibj 7y agoIt's enough for knobs of 1 inch spacing or wider, no easy support for fancy geared knobs that coaxially have a rough setting and a fine adjustment.
- ethbro 7y agoAny digital control signal effectively has a minimum bandwidth. This might be as simple as "Here's my encoded position * frequency of sampling", but for a general interface you'd want something adaptable. What if there were two dials on the control? Two dials and three buttons? One dial, four buttons, and a joystick?
- gugagore 7y agoIt would require multi-touch displays. I have no idea how ubiquitous those are these days, but I know most touchscreens interfaces in my life have not supported it.
- chrismorgan 7y agoVery strongly related to what you describe is fiducial markers. They were a big thing in the small pond that was projected touch surfaces some years ago, though I haven’t heard anything much about it in recent years as the industry has headed in a different direction. It’s harder to find info on them now, but it’s still out there. A quick search yielded https://www.christianholz.net/fiberio.html https://www.christianholz.net/fiberio.html which contains an image of the concept at the bottom.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoAlso see Reactable https://reactable.com/ https://reactable.com/
- DonHopkins 7y agoIn Michael Naimark's series of articles about "VR and AR Fundamentals" [1], the chapter on "Other Senses (Touch, Smell, Taste, Mind)" [2] discusses haptic feedback, and even mentions Hiroo Iwata's delicious "Food Simulator" [3]. [1] VR and AR Fundamentals: https://medium.com/@michaelnaimark/vr-ar-fundamentals-prologue-b7aa3d119087 https://medium.com/@michaelnaimark/vr-ar-fundamentals-prolog... [2] Other Senses (Touch, Smell, Taste, Mind): https://medium.com/@michaelnaimark/vr-ar-fundamentals-3-other-senses-haptic-smell-taste-mind-e6d101d752da https://medium.com/@michaelnaimark/vr-ar-fundamentals-3-othe... [3] Food Simulator: https://www.wired.com/2003/08/slideshow-wonders-aplenty-at-siggraph/ https://www.wired.com/2003/08/slideshow-wonders-aplenty-at-s... https://ars.electronica.art/center/en/food-simulator/ https://ars.electronica.art/center/en/food-simulator/ http://icat.vrsj.org/papers/2003/00876_00000.pdf http://icat.vrsj.org/papers/2003/00876_00000.pdf Hiroo Iwata is a brilliant mad scientist [4], and in a previous HN discussion about pie menus and haptic multitouch interfaces [5], I linked to his wonderful work on 3DOF Multitouch Haptic Interface with Movable Touchscreen. [6] [7] [4] Professor Hiroo IWATA: http://www.frontier.kyoto-u.ac.jp/te03/member/iwata/index.html http://www.frontier.kyoto-u.ac.jp/te03/member/iwata/index.ht... [5] HN discussion of pie menus and haptic multitouch interfaces: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17105984 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17105984 [6] 3DOF Multitouch Haptic Interface with Movable Touchscreen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCZPmj7NtSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCZPmj7NtSQ [7] 3DOF Multitouch Haptic Interface with Movable Touchscreen: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-10-4157-0_9 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-10-4157-0_... >Shun Takanaka, Hiroaki Yano, Hiroo Iwata, Presented at AsiaHaptics2016. This paper reports on the development of a multitouch haptic interface equipped with a movable touchscreen. When the relative position of two of a user’s fingertips is fixed on a touchscreen, the fingers can be considered a hand-shaped rigid object. In such situations, a reaction force can be exerted on each finger using a three degrees of freedom (3DOF) haptic interface. In this study, a prototype 3DOF haptic interface system comprising a touchscreen, a 6-axis force sensor, an X-Y stage, and a capstan drive system was developed. The developed system estimates the input force from fingers using sensor data and each finger’s position. Further, the system generates reaction forces from virtual objects to the user’s fingertips by controlling the static frictional force between each of the user’s fingertips and the screen. The system enables users to perceive the shape of two-dimensional virtual objects displayed on the screen and translate/rotate them with their fingers. Moreover, users can deform elastic virtual objects, and feel their rigidity. There are some other really bizarre examples of haptic interfaces in the AsiaHaptics2016 conference videos! (Not all safe for work, depending on your chosen profession, predilection for palpation, and assessment of sphincter tone.) [8] [8] AsiaHaptics2016: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8qMmIgmWhnQBeABjGlzGbg/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8qMmIgmWhnQBeABjGlzGbg/vid...
- Const-me 7y agoI’m not sure touch screens have sufficient resolution. Check this: http://huyle.de/2019/02/12/accessing-capacitive-images/ http://huyle.de/2019/02/12/accessing-capacitive-images/ As you see, the sensor elements are huge, 4×4mm each, i.e. there’re only 15×27 sensors for the complete touch screen. On top of that, there’s high amount of noise in the signal of each sensor. The reasons why it works OK in practice, fingers have very predictable shape, also a lot of software involved on all levels of the stack. Touch screen firmware filters out sensor noise and generates touch points. Higher level GUI frameworks “snap“ touches to virtual buttons, some platforms go as far as making virtual keyboard buttons different sizes, depending on which virtual keys are expected to be clicked next, according to predictive input software i.e. dictionaries. What you propose probably can be done, by using a finger-like object, but I don’t expect the resolution will be great. At least not in comparison with hardware turning knobs, even cheap ones can be make extremely precise. See this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_encoder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_encoder and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incremental_encoder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incremental_encoder for more info, both are used a lot in wide variety of applications. Old mice with a ball had 2 of them, the reason why ball mice sucked was not sensor precision, it was dirt accumulation, a minor issue for a knob.