9 ms·
Private Government: How Employers Rule Our Lives and Why We Don't Talk about It
- tomrod 7y agoIf you disagree with the thesis of this article, let me ask you: how many times have you or someone you know hesitated leaving a current employer due to benefits uncertainties? Or more to the point: how many startups never happen because the right people are unable to manage the personal risk of leaving defined employment? IMO this the consideration -- human ability is not really allocated all that well when you're bonded to an employer without cheaper switching costs.
- jbreiding 7y agoI've always thought this was really obvious. Benefits tied to employment will stifle entrepreneurs who aren't already well off. This tips the scales towards the largest employers for labor, how many low paid internships could be replaced by high risk startups? Before anyone has had a chance to accumulate to many obligations, that is the perfect time to grow by taking a risk and going after something disruptive. That also would be the time in which many have the energy and optimism to do good rather than for greed or meeting obligations such as feeding/housing a family of four.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoWasn't it the labor movement that tied many of these benefits to employers? Pretty sure at least employer paid (and now, semi-paid) health insurance was won due to organized labor demanding it. At the time it was likely the right thing to do but now it does seem to create an extra entanglement.
- pravda 7y ago>Wasn't it the labor movement that tied many of these benefits to employers? No, it was WWII that did it.
- malandrew 7y agoIt started during WWII due to government restrictions on what could be paid, but was extended to be an obligation under full-time employment via organized labor movement.
- heymijo 7y agoNot just organized labor. > This didn’t stop President Truman from considering and promoting a national health care system in 1945. This idea had a fair amount of public support, but business, in the form of the Chamber of Commerce, opposed it. So did the American Hospital Association and American Medical Association. Even many unions did, having spent so much political capital fighting for insurance benefits for their members. Confronted by such opposition from all sides, national health insurance failed — for not the first or last time. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-the-us-has-employer-sponsored-health-insurance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-th...
- astura 7y agoProbably because group plans are/were strictly better and cheaper than individual plans (especially pre-ACA).
- Data_Junkie 7y agoThat's why the healthcare system is what it is. You cannot do it your way without their doctors.
- landryraccoon 7y agoDepends on the sector. If you’re a software engineer or white collar worker, leaving your job for a prolonged period of time is a matter of planning and frugality. Speaking only for myself, I intentionally lived in a small apartment in order to make sure I had at least a year of income saved. I did this pretty early in my career in the bay area. I believe it’s still quite possible to do this if you are willing to forgo purchases that signal wealth (i.e, live in the smallest manageable apartment, keep driving your beater for a long time, cook instead of eating out).
- marcinzm 7y ago>Or more to the point: how many startups never happen because the right people are unable to manage the personal risk of leaving defined employment? I'd argue this has more to do with the low salaries expected of startup founders more than anything. Hard to stomach them unless you've got significant savings already or no dependents.
- skizm 7y agoMaybe in other countries, but in the US the only real consideration is health care. Most people who want to start a business are cool eating ramen, couch surfing, and sacrificing a big salary if they have to, but don’t want to risk going completely bankrupt because they fall and break an ankle, get in a car accident, or get diagnosed with something chronic. At least this is the only concern I or anyone I’ve talked to about doing a start up has risen. I work at a not quite FAANG company and we all have decent salaries and benefits. I’d give it up in a heart beat if I didn’t have to worry about health care costs.
- marcinzm 7y agoCOBRA allows for 18 months of coverage under your previous employer's plan. Cal-COBRA allows for 36 months of coverage. All you have to do is pay the full premiums (<$1k/month for a single person). That should be enough time to get a startup to a point where it can apply for it's own health insurance. If you have a spouse (or domestic partner in some states) then you can also go under their plan although that may have increased premiums for them. There's also the individual health plans out there which may be reasonably priced if you don't have any pre-existing conditions. When I left my job for a year of relaxing health insurance was nowhere near a concern since I just paid the COBRA premiums. edit: And if you're under 26 you can be on your parent's health plan. edit2: Also, talking about couch surfing pretty much highlights my point about dependents. I'm guessing neither you nor the people you talked to are old enough to have kids.
- macspoofing 7y ago>how many times have you or someone you know hesitated leaving a current employer due to benefits uncertainties? Hopefully 0 times. Major changes in your life (like changing jobs, or moving cities, or making large purchases) always require some consideration. >human ability is not really allocated all that well when you're bonded to an employer without cheaper switching costs. You're overstating the case especially in market economies. If anything, the issue is more prevalent if your employer is the government, as the government tends to overpay for labour and is slow to adjust if conditions change (i.e. very hard to let people go for any reason). Having said that, there are problems with movement being too liquid. That is, you lose institutional knowledge if your company (or government department) has a too high of a turn-over rate, which leads to lower quality products/services. >how many startups never happen because the right people are unable to manage the personal risk of leaving defined employment? And rightly so. Startups are an incredibly risky endeavour and they always will be. This is why founders tend to be younger, rather than older. If you have dependents and responsibilities you have to think twice about making a high risk bet. I don't know if you want to actually incentivize people to make more high-risk bets.
- dahfizz 7y agoEven if we accept your premise - people have limited mobility due to benefits - that is nothing at all like being a government. Governments by definition have a monopoly on force. A government is a government because people with guns say so. You might want to argue that employees have power, but they are nothing like a government. They don't have force, they don't have jails, they can't enter your home and give you orders. The worst thing an employer can do is to stop employing you. That's hardly coercion IMO.
- CogitoCogito 7y ago> Governments by definition have a monopoly on force. I've never heard that definition of government. Also, at least in the US (and presumably everywhere else), private citizens have the right to use force under various circumstances.
- dahfizz 7y agoThis is literally the definition of government used in e.g. social science: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence > private citizens have the right to use force under various circumstances. Yup, as defined by the government. You can defend yourself in certain circumstances, but you are always subservient to the military and police. They are the ultimate power in the state. If there was a force stronger than the military or police, that power would then be the state.
- ObscureMind 7y agoIs the state's army economically funded by a contract established voluntarily? Can you start a private army to compete (not meaning fight it, but to provide the same services) with the state's army ? If you have to pay for it (you actually pay for the army to force you to pay for it...), and you can't compete with it for the services it provides, it's not only a monopoly, it's also a tyranny.
- ggg3 7y agonot really. you are just too poor. if you had the means to create the right connections, you could be paid by the army, like blackwater.
- paultopia 7y agoWe have some nice evidence for this from Obamacare---a number of people were freed to quit their jobs to do more valuable things. The one that will probably be most appealing to HN: Eddie Gonzalez-Novoa, 44, now living in Houston, last year left a full-time job in New York making $88,000 a year plus benefits to help his nephew, a cancer survivor, start a social media and video-gaming site for other teens with the disease. https://www.denverpost.com/2014/02/10/they-quit-their-jobs-thanks-to-health-care-law/ https://www.denverpost.com/2014/02/10/they-quit-their-jobs-t...
- Animats 7y agoThat's a paper on classic union issues written with no reference to labor history. There have been companies which really acted like governments to their employees. Ford.[1] Pullman.[2] The US labor movement arose partly as a counter to that. And, for a long time, from about 1930 to 1980, companies backed off on that out of fear of unions and government. That fear has been lost, and companies are more assertive in employee control. Abuse of non-compete agreements to make low-level workers indentured servants would never have been accepted prior to 1990 or so. US labor history has been erased from public dialogue in the US almost as thoroughly as Tienanmen Square has been erased from public dialogue in China. [1] https://www.autonews.com/article/20030602/SUB/306020843/the-rise-and-fall-of-harry-bennett https://www.autonews.com/article/20030602/SUB/306020843/the-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike
- Mikeb85 7y agoMore people need to challenge non-compete agreements. In the majority of cases (especially for non-management employees) they're illegal and don't hold up.
- vkou 7y agoNo, a majority of the time, they are not illegal outside of California. State legislatures have been doing a great job in preventing non-competes from being banned, because they aren't scared of organized political action by labour.
- Mikeb85 7y agoI said in a majority of cases. The legality doesn't have to do with whether or not they're allowed by the state (they're allowed everywhere, even in California), but whether or not they can apply to the person signing the agreement. Courts uphold non-competes against managers moving to a competitor, workers taking client lists, former equity stakeholders, etc..., but almost never against low-level employees.
- Nasrudith 7y ago
- lycidas 7y agoHas it always felt this way? I've been reading a lot of Chomsky lately and it seems at least for a few decades in the later 1900's workers had more power in the workplace.
- jeremyjh 7y agoYes, blue collar workers used to vote in favor of their own interests. They've been lured away from doing that for a long time now.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoIt's in the interest of blue-collar workers to repeal all laws that empower unions by violating the contracting rights of employers because that will attract investment into the U.S. manufacturing sector. Outlawing all employment contracts except those that give enoemous power to the first crop of employees that votes to form an official union is a short-sighted strategy for improving worker welfare. Wage growth in the US and Western Europe has been very stagnant over the last 40 years. Meanwhile wages have tripled over the last 20 years in China. During the "Gilded Age", which unions and their activists regularly fearmonger about, wages grew at the fastest rate in US history. And unlike the post-war era, this wage growth didn't come at the expense of US industry, where unions extracted enormous unsustainable concessions that culminated in major US companies declining or going bankrupt. The wage growth in the late 19th and early 20th century accompanied massive US industrial growth. The best way to help workers is to embrace Capital. The worse thing you can do is embrace an anti-capitalist ideology.
- rocqua 7y agoSure, Chinese wages grow a lot faster than Western ones. At the same time, Western wages remain quite a bit higher than Chinese ones. Dropping wages in the West would bring a lot of extra work, at the same time, that work would be paying less. The core thing here is that cost of living, and hence a living wage in the West is higher than in e.g. China. Due to globalization, companies can now arbitrage that difference.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- debatem1 7y agoThere's an interesting discussion in this about how early market advocates assumed that in a free market almost everyone would be essentially self-employed, and how the industrial revolution broke that. It's especially interesting to think about that in terms of the gig economy.
- pmoriarty 7y agoCorporations and the government are not brightly distinguishable entities. Corporate execs frequently serve in government and oversee or give contracts to the very companies or industries they came from, and it's an open secret that when powerful government employees retire they get very well paid positions at those very same companies as rewards for the contracts they awarded or legislation they passed/opposed when they were in government. Considering the amount of back scratching that goes on between government and the private sector, it's a true wonder that there are any consumer protection or labor laws at all, or that powerful politicians or corporate execs ever have to face any consequences.
- a3n 7y ago> Considering the amount of back scratching that goes on between government and the private sector, it's a true wonder that there are any consumer protection or labor laws at all Well keep watching, because the landscape is getting less wonderful by the day.
- lioeters 7y agoBetween lobbying, revolving doors, bribery as "free speech", the two-party system, media and propaganda, regulatory capture, use of intelligence, military, and police in service of corporations (and vice versa).. In a sense, we do live under government owned by private interests.
- git-pull 7y agoTitle: please note this is a review of the book here: https://www.amazon.com/Private-Government-Employers-University-Center-ebook/dp/B06XKGWT56/ https://www.amazon.com/Private-Government-Employers-Universi... Aside: If you like to compare-contrast US<->EU, I found this paper interesting: Why Doesn’t The US Have A European-Style Welfare State? (2001) https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/glaeser/files/why_doesnt_the_u.s._have_a_european-style_welfare_state.pdf https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/glaeser/files/why_doesnt_t....
- Proven 7y agoWhat a misleading title! I can find it hard to believe that someone can be so ignorant so I can only guess the submitter deliberately did it due to their anti-capitalist mindset. There's nothing even close to "private government" in this case, because in none of these cases does the company have the monopoly on the use of physical force.
- curioussavage 7y agoLet’s just get it so my health care isn’t tied to my job anymore ok. Same for the whole 401k setup.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> Same for the whole 401k setup. I don't understand that one at all. A huge point of 401ks is you can leave your employer and you keep all the money, as opposed to things like a pension.
- astura 7y agoUnless you're self employed you can't just go an open a 401k yourself, your employer must offer one. You don't get to shop around for lower fees, better customer service, or better investment options - you must use the plan and investment options they give you. They may change it at any time. You can only do what you want with your money after you leave your job. You also can only contribute earned income to tax advantaged retirement accounts, not unearned income.
- krupan 7y agoSo the solution is to start your own business, and then your customers will rule tyour life.
- chroma 7y agoI'm not sure why anyone takes her argument seriously. Companies don't pull me over while I'm driving. Companies don't put me in prison. Companies don't extort me under threat of violence. Companies don't enslave me. Only criminal organizations and governments do those sorts of things. At worst, companies can use existing government frameworks to coerce me (and I can use the same frameworks to coerce them). Typically, all they can do is stop paying me. Most importantly, people can switch companies far easier than they can switch governments. Changing jobs is easier than moving between states, let alone countries. Switching costs could be lower (mostly related to health insurance), but overall companies are competing pretty hard for workers. That's why they advertise positions, hire recruiters, and go to colleges and job fairs. Could you imagine governments behaving similarly? The only thing that comes close is the military, and that's because their potential recruits can choose private sector jobs.
- devoply 7y ago> Companies don't pull me over while I'm driving. They very well could pull you over, revoke your license, and forbid you from driving.... If you were driving on their land or driving their car. They have to provide no justification for these actions either. They can reassign you to do something else or simply lay you off with a short notice. > Companies don't put me in prison. Companies don't extort me under threat of violence. Companies don't enslave me. Companies can put you in prison using the state. Companies can and do extort workers on certain terms like withholding paychecks and so on. Companies absolutely enslave people by for instance telling them a myriad of ways in which they can and can not conduct their lives. Her argument is that companies are communist dictatorships and they are all communist dictatorships, so you can not escape their control no matter who you are working for. Considering that you spend most of your life under control of such governments either one or another, these governments determine most of your life. And I would say indoctrination to such governments starts with schooling which teaches you to obey and not question such governments. > Imagine a government that assigns almost everyone a superior whom they must obey. Although superiors give most inferiors a routine to follow, there is no rule of law. Orders may be arbitrary and can change any time, without prior notice or opportunity to appeal. Superiors are unaccountable to those they order around. They are neither elected nor removable by their inferiors. Inferiors have no right to complain in court . . . except in a few narrowly defined cases . . . The most highly ranked individual takes no orders but issues many. The lowest-ranked may have their bodily movements and speech minutely regulated for most of the day . . . This government does not recognize a personal or private sphere of autonomy free from sanction. It may prescribe a dress code and forbid certain hairstyles. Everyone lives under surveillance . . . Suspicious searches of their bodies and personal effects may be routine . . . The government may dictate the language spoken . . . It may forbid certain topics of discussion. People can be sanctioned for their consensual sexual activity or for their choice of spouse . . . They can be sanctioned for their political activity and required to engage in political activity they do not agree with. > The economic system of the society run by this government is communist. The government owns all the nonlabor means of production in the society it governs . . . The vast majority have no realistic option but to try to immigrate to another communist dictatorship . . . (37-38)
- esotericn 7y agoYou simply cannot spend all of your income. If you have a full time job, no savings, and are spending all of your income, or even close (say above 70%, 80%), you are in a full-blown crisis mode situation. It will manifest itself in all sorts of ways. If you have a limited supply of basically anything and use all of it the same issue would arise. If you had 50L of water to use per day, and all of your activities used 49.5L of it, then you would be in a water crisis, because if you ever e.g. needed to wash an extra shirt you simply couldn't, it would be impossible.
- marmaduke 7y agoThis is a good point. In France, your mortgage monthly amount usually can't exceed 35%, and the bank takes into account any other loans you have (eg car payments). This is super annoying if you're the thrifty sort, but in the end, they're taking away a foot gun, by limiting your 'debt rate' (taux d'endettement)
- Someone1234 7y ago> You simply cannot spend all of your income. So people making $7.20/hour should be living on $5/hour? People are spending all their income, but inflation adjusted income has been stagnant for the middle class and below[0]. Combine this with the costs of living (like healthcare) increasing and you've created a situation where a lot of households are struggling to have money left over (or are commonly indebted). [0] https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/updates/2018/10/16/u-s-household-incomes-a-51-year-perspective https://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/updates/2018/10/1...
- esotericn 7y agoPeople making $7.20 an hour in most places I can think of in the Western world are in crisis, yes. I don't know what they "should" do. It sounds like they're really in a pickle indeed and the solution (if one even exists) is going to be very dependent on individual circumstance.
- nitwit005 7y agoPeople in poorer circumstances save at a higher rate elsewhere in the world, and used to in the US a few decades ago. The main issue is perhaps what you hint at the end there. Credit has gotten far more available, so people are no longer used to saving to make purchases, and are in the habit of going into debt.
- musicale 7y agoThis seems fairly obvious: because many (most?) people can't afford to lose their jobs (along with health insurance and income that is required for basic necessities such as food and shelter, not to mention the loss of social status), company managers routinely rely on the implicit or explicit threat of unemployment to enable systematic and highly unethical coercion of employees (e.g. to accept harassment without complaint, to engage in unethical or illegal business practices, to accept a wide range of harmful and intrusive restrictions on communication, movement, work and association, to give up privacy and/or safety, to comply with arbitrary and abusive demands, etc..) As we have seen recently regarding issues from harassment to non-compete agreements, this kind of abusive behavior is widespread in spite of labor laws and public opinion to the contrary.