4 ms·
A lot of this advice is unrealistic. How many people are going to be able to live on one spouse's income alone? Of those who can, how many will want that secon
by lordnacho 7y ago
A lot of this advice is unrealistic.
How many people are going to be able to live on one spouse's income alone? Of those who can, how many will want that second income vs time with the kids?
About not getting into debt, how many people are can go to college ("invest in yourself") without?
IMO the only good piece of advice is "be smart about probabilities", which if you follow it to its logical conclusion basically just means be informed about the facts, a general piece of life advice that makes a lot of sense.
- ajuc 7y ago> About not getting into debt, how many people are can go to college ("invest in yourself") without? Like 95% of the rest of the developed world ;)
- fluffything 7y agoI only know a single "developed" country in which you have to indebt yourself to go to college, and that's the US. Are there any others?
- lordnacho 7y agoEven in Northern Europe where tuition is free, students often take out loans to support themselves during uni. Source: I grew up in one of those places, plenty of people will borrow from the government on top of what they are given.
- ajuc 7y agoWell in Poland university is free as it is in most post-communist EU, Scandinavia, and some other EU countries. Yeah you still have to have the money for food and place to live, but you'd need that anyway, and it's not that expansive. Most people get these money from their parents without loaning any money from banks.
- Henk0 7y agoJust want to point out that the nature of these loans (at least in Sweden) differs greatly from student loans in the US. Interest rates and downpayments are low, and if you can’t afford to pay off your loans for a period (due to no or low income), you can get a temporary reduction of the amount you have to pay off every month. I maxed out my loans when I studied, at about $26k, and the maximum I have to pay monthly is ~$55 a month
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fluffything 7y ago> Even in Northern Europe where tuition is free, students often take out loans to support themselves during uni. FWIW I wasn't suggesting that students in other countries don't take any loans, I was pointing out that they don't necessarily have to. In Germany, for example, there is a government loan system for studying, where you get enough per month, and only have to pay back ~20 months of it (which is a fraction of the time in college), and can pay it back under quite good conditions. In Spain, it is common for students to live with their families, work, or for their families to help them a bit. Many students don't take a loan, and ether work ~15h/week, or get money from parents, or both. Even poor families are able to push 2 children through college without accumulating debt. If tuition here were to cost, e.g, 3000 EUR/year, many families and students wouldn't be able to do that. If tuition were to cost 20k EUR or more / year, most families would need to indebt themselves.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe UK, £9000 per year plus living costs is the current floor. However it is more like a graduate tax than loan, if you don't earn much you don't pay it back and it gets written off after 25 years.
- Wildgoose 7y agoThe £9,250 annual tuition fee is for England only. Tuition fees imposed by the votes of Scottish MPs overriding the votes of English (& Welsh) MPs. But they knew their own kids would unaffected because tuition fees in Scotland are zero if you are Scottish (or an EU resident). There's a special fee applied if you are English though.
- ChrisRR 7y agoIt's 25 years for the £3k fees, 30 years for £9k
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- neap24 7y agoI don’t think it’s unrealistic at all. My wife and I have always lived on one income. Before we had kids, we used the other to pay off our college debt very quickly and build as much savings/retirement as possible. It also taught us to narrow the set of physical goods we valued in life. We are now living very comfortably on one (modest) income with 3 kids. As far as never going into debt, I think you should interpret that a bit more loosely. Obviously, going to college has huge payoffs in a few short years. That is more of an investment as long as one chose and affordable college. Taking out a loan on a new BMW or Tesla is debt.
- lordnacho 7y ago> I don’t think it’s unrealistic at all. My wife and I... Come on now. It's about what is generally achievable. Imagine living in London on £25K, which is roughly the median. If you find another median salary, are you gonna save it all? Unlikely.
- gambiting 7y agoSo you mention "generally achievable" and then bring up London in the same sentence? Really? Vast majority of British people don't live in London. It's like saying that home ownership is UK is unachievable because no one in London can afford to buy anymore. Which is true, but it has nothing to do with the rest of the country.
- lordnacho 7y agoWell unless you talk about city states, the vast majority of the population of any country is not living in any particular city in that state. Salaries in the rest of the country are lower, so you'd be making a similar comparison with let's say $20K in eg Sheffield. Obviously there's people living on that budget, but the point of the advice was to not break that budget, even if twice the amount were available. Which even if you're very frugal you are unlikely to do. You're gonna think of something to spend that extra 20K on, and it's not dumb to spend at least some of it. To me the advice sounds like "if you and your wife are partners in law firms, save half the money".
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI would say it's unusual but not unrealistic.