3 ms·
>>Why would you design levels which makes it impossible to play in this style, if some people prefer it? Why would you design a level to force a specific play s
by gambiting 7y ago
>>Why would you design levels which makes it impossible to play in this style, if some people prefer it? Why would you design a level to force a specific play style, even though they might not enjoy it?
For the same reason someone designing a sports car will make the suspension super stiff - because they want to achieve a specific goal with their design. My grandmother would hate driving such a car as it would be uncomfortable for her, but it might be an acceptable trade-off for those looking for a specific type of experience. If you're not enjoying a specific type of game design then it simply means that the game isn't for you - and there's absolutely nothing wrong with that.
- atoav 7y agoExpensive modern cars have an adaptive suspension: you let the driver decide what kind of suspension they want and there is inherent value in that. The goal of a game usually is to entertain and give the players a great experience. This of course means also you design to avoid certain player strategies like repetitive grinding or things that are most certainly no fun, but for some reason work all the time (think of a fighting game where you can win by smashing the same attack all the time). However if you only allow for one playstyle without real reasons, you create a game that works well for one kind of player, while everybody else will feel that the game forces them into actions they don't really want to do that way. The game feels off for them. So if a game designer can allow multiple playstyles at once without big downsides to the main intended one, there is literally no reason not to do it. You can find ways to allow multiple playstyles without sacrificing anything in a game, just like there are films that work for multiple target audiences at once, because everybody sees something else in it they like. I think these dichotomies are way to present in many forms of design – we think we have to choose one or the other, while we could achieve both if we really tried.
- Cpoll 7y agoI think the suspension idea fails here, because in the case of run-and-gun vs. cautious, a player that prefers one style will always prefer that style, whereas a driver will sometimes want comfort and sometimes want performance. > So if a game designer can allow multiple playstyles at once without big downsides to the main intended one, there is literally no reason not to do it. There's always the downside of extra work, at the very least. Sometimes 'multiple playstyles' is a design decision, but that needs to be the case from the very beginning. And sometimes, the design decision is 'run-and-gun,' and everything follows from there. Games that try to do everything tend to do nothing well. There's another disadvantage of allowing cautious play: Even players who would be having more fun running-and-gunning may identify (or misidentify) cautious play as optimal play. As a result, you've designed a game that works against itself by incentivizing players to have less fun. Edit: kaoD said it better than me, in this same post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20663319 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20663319
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoDon't you find that just run-and-gun gets boring, you want a change of pace, to choose sometimes to do a section of a [FPS] game stealthily, sometimes dynamic, and sometimes just tank it? For me, it's good to force a certain style of play sometimes. One of the things I really liked about Deus Ex was that run-and-gun just left you overwhelmed at times, resources or floorplan could force stealth in some sections of the game.
- atoav 7y agoThis is in fact how most good games work: they force you to change strategies every now and then to avoid boring you to death with one scenario.
- Cpoll 7y agoTo quote myself: > Sometimes 'multiple playstyles' is a design decision That's Deus Ex. But it doesn't have to be Doom. A game forcing you to change tacks doesn't mean the same thing as it giving you options. And no, I don't necessarily think run-and-gun always gets boring, and you need to add stealth segments, or a car chase, or whatnot. You can keep it fresh without changing the premise, I don't think 'run-and-gun' is so narrow a definition that you need to change the pace entirely in order to keep it fresh. No-one ever levels this criticism at racing games, platformers, Tetris, etc. I get a bit frustrated when I'm forced to play a stealth section in an action game. They usually feel slow, forced, obviously scripted, and a lazy way of cleansing the player's palate. For it to feel any good, it needs to be a core design principle (see, for example, Metal Gear Solid), not a tedious half-level (before some inevitable scripted scene allows and forces you to exit stealth mode).
- tomc1985 7y agoWhat makes the designers intent so sacrosanct? The value of art is in how it is perceived, not the artists' intent. Often, the two are aren't in sync anyway I also enjoy this style of gameplay. Just because it is considered a cop-out to designers looking to nudge me to be more aggressive or something, doesn't mean its an illegitimate tactic. Or is this really about creating gameplay that looks exciting to that accursed YouTube crowd?
- pawelmurias 7y agoThe point is to ensure that style of game play isn't more effective. There are cover shooters that encourage potshots from behind cover that are built to make that style of play more fun.
- tomc1985 7y agoThose sorts of considerations should only come in to play with extreme examples... it's a very heavy-handed approach to designing gameplay. Unless you're trying to make an experience very specifically something -- which I think works only in cinematic situations -- the game should be designed in a way that accommodates multiple playstyles. A lot of people begrudge heavy-handed game-design; it ruins player freedom/agency
- gambiting 7y agoI disagree quite a lot - look at Doom 2016. It's a masterpiece of a game and its design does not allow multiple different playstyles. You cannot go and start sneaking around , the gameplay is extremely focused on always being 100% balls-to-the-wall, guns blazing and running around like a terminator from hell that you are. The levels allow different approaches to that style of gameplay, but fundamentally it cannot change. Does it feel like you have no agency over its dozen or so levels? No, of course not.
- teddyh 7y ago> look at Doom 2016 […] Does it feel like you have no agency over its dozen or so levels? No, of course not. My original comment which brought up Doom 2016 in the first place did in fact argue that yes, Doom 2016 gave me no choice in how to play. It continually forced me into arenas where enemies spawned in a circle around me. IIRC, there were no individual enemies to trigger, only arena triggers. It also forced me to melee each individual enemy up close in order to gain any health back, precluding any long-range tactics.