11 ms·
This sounds too convenient. If this was a suicide and not anything more sinister, this is gross negligence by prison authorities. It was their solemn duty and
by mc32 7y ago
This sounds too convenient. If this was a suicide and not anything more sinister, this is gross negligence by prison authorities. It was their solemn duty and responsibility to see this person face trial.
This will only inflame conspiracy theory minded people to believe there is a vast conspiracy by the powerful to protect themselves.
This is depressing. I’m yet hopeful evidence will be used to bring guilty parties to justice. This wasn’t just mr Epstein.
- wtknn 7y ago>This will only inflame conspiracy theory minded people to believe there is a vast conspiracy by the powerful to protect themselves. How is that a conspiracy?
- mc32 7y agoWell people in that sphere were already predicting he’d “commit” suicide to avoid getting powerful people ensnared.
- wtknn 7y agoWhat I mean is that I don't think that's a conspiracy, it's reasonable to think that in the world elites they look after each other
- malloci 7y agoThat’s the very definition of conspiracy: “a secret plan by a group to do something unlawful or harmful.”
- calibas 7y agoIf you believe that when the elite "look after each other" they abuse their power in illegal and unethical ways, then technically you're a "conspiracy theorist" along with the vast majority of the population. Edit: And the story has been removed from the HN front page, despite being one of the most popular...
- wtknn 7y agoWell, it just happened.
- matt-attack 7y agoThat’s literally “conspiring together”. That’s all conspiracy means. It means some occurrence wasn’t just a fluke action of luck or even of just one guy. It was a group of people “conspiring” together. Think JFK. Did a group conspire? Or was it just Oswald?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deogeo 7y ago'Conspiracy' is not synonymous with 'untrue'. I'd advise everyone in the comments to keep that in mind, and state things unambiguously, to avoid arguing past each-other.
- gurkendoktor 7y agoI've been curious why "conspiracy theory" is used exclusively as a pejorative. Turns out that Wikipedia defines it as such: > A conspiracy theory is an explanation of an event or situation that invokes a conspiracy by sinister and powerful actors, often political in motivation, when other explanations are more probable. But who gets to define what is more probable? Why not just "when there is no proof (yet)"? But I guess that battle and term are lost.
- deogeo 7y agoWhich raises the question - how do you describe an explanation that justifiably (or at least plausibly) relies on conspiracy?
- NikkiA 7y agoYou generally refer to named actors as 'conspiring together'. The definition of a 'conspiracy theory' is almost dependant on the actors being unknown or unconfirmed, and thus isn't a provable act of conspiracy versus an implausible crazyness.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SHAKEDECADE 7y agoTo play devils advocate; who doesn’t want to protect themselves and that which they’ve worked for? From the poor who’ve worked hard for the past year to save up for engine for the late 70s truck. To the middle(ish) class who’ve worked hard for their first purchased two bedroom home. To the middle upperclass who’ve gone on a vacation to Branson Missouri. To pretty much everyone with children. To the ultra wealthy that are worth seven figures and up. Everyone wants to protect what they feel they’ve worked hard for. That includes the proposed ultra wealthy that have the means to insure they aren’t pulled into Epstein’s legal whirlpool. If it exists, it makes sense they would protect themselves.
- mc32 7y agoOk but by looking out for yourself it’s typically and socially accepted and expected you’re not going to do grievous direct harm to other parties.
- DennisP 7y agoThat's the ideal and the law, but in practice it's not that uncommon for people do grievous direct harm to other parties, when they think they can get away with it.
- buttcoinslol 7y agoTo the ultra-rich, "other parties" are other ultra-rich people. Everyone else is just an insect. I mean that in the most visceral way possible, the ultra-rich view us with contempt. edit: This is why Bernie Madoff went to prison and why basically no one went to jail over the 2008 GFC. Madoff stole from his own social class, which is a big no-no.
- goatinaboat 7y agoMadoff stole from his own social class, which is a big no-no. I don’t think that analysis tells the whole story. Elizabeth Holmes got away with a slapped wrist despite defrauding some very, very powerful people. Whereas Shkreli got jail despite returning every penny to his investors.
- koolba 7y agoThere’s more than one angle to conspiracy theories as well. Was it a “hit” by the powerful protecting themselves or, did he have a dead man’s switch on incriminating others and it’s a fake and he’s been broken out of prison? There’s so much to work with here that it’s going to go on for years.
- Grazester 7y agoIf this guy attempted suicide before, shouldn't there be a permanent camera affixed to his jail cell (beside having a guard watch him)? If that is the case then we should have the video footage of his suicide even if the guard slacked off?
- gumbo 7y agoThis NYT article hints at what it looks like to be under suicide watch: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/10/nyregion/jeffrey-epstein-suicide-watch.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/10/nyregion/jeffrey-epstein-...
- mistermann 7y agoOf course there should, it's common sense. That there is no such standard procedure seems unlikely to be accidental.
- ekianjo 7y agoIt could have been suicide, as in the parties who did not want him to talk may have arranged for everything he needed to end his life by himself. Of course, it is also possible it was not just suicide. Guess we will never know.
- joshgel 7y agoI am not a lawyer, but @klasfeldreports on twitter quotes an unnamed legal source who says: "Background: An important note after Epstein's death: no one else will have standing to challenge the search warrant on his house. Everything will be admissible against any other defendant without possibility of a motion to suppress." So maybe this will be a net good for justice?
- mc32 7y agoMaybe. One hopes this can be salvaged. I guess we may never know who was behind it all pulling the levers. Mr Epstein can’t have been at the top.
- ironSkillet 7y agoWhat? The guy supposedly had $500 million to his name. That can buy quite a lot of levers.
- dragonwriter 7y agoEpstein was quite plausibly the chief procurer; he no doubt had a wife array of powerful clients, but there's not a lot of reason to think there was a higher-level mastermind behind Epstein in the procurement operation.
- ryacko 7y agoEpstein comes off as an unhinged individual. With a mansion full of sex art, a normal reaction would be “we should have known in retrospect”, not a sweetheart plea deal.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Epstein comes off as an unhinged individual. With a mansion full of sex art, a normal reaction would be “we should have known in retrospect”, not a sweetheart plea deal. That Epstein had politically powerful clients and friends is not in serious dispute (which were clients and which were merely friends unconnected to his child rape business is somewhat less clear), and explains the sweetheart plea deal without resort to some behind-Epstein mastermind. It's not impossible, but there is nothing that is explained more easily by such a mastermind than by the Epstein being the master of his own sex trade operation which garnered him influence (simply heading that operation means he has powerful blackmail material on powerful people.)
- willis936 7y agoThis was my first thought too. The story in the Deus Ex video game series is starting to seem less ridiculous and impromptu, and more like a piece of prophetic media.
- yodsanklai 7y agoCall me naive, but I would simply conclude the jailing facilities are underfunded and unable to prevent someone from committing suicide. I just can't imagine someone being able to order such a murder. There would be too many people involved and risks of getting caught.
- rolph 7y agoif someone is in prison for life they have little to lose, and plenty to gain by doing wetwork for corrupt officials.
- otakucode 7y agoWhitey Bulger recently got transferred for no stated reason to a prison in West Virginia and within hours of his arrival was beaten to death by an inmate with mafia ties.
- tfha 7y agoEpstein was supposed to be under 24/7 camera surveillance. But they are saying there was a camera malfunction. Dunno man it really doesn't add up to a suicide.
- mc32 7y agoMalfunction is BS. A proper system would alert of camera offline condition or storage offline, etc.
- cpr 7y agoDo you really think there isn't a vast conspiracy by the powerful to protect themselves? It's a bit too obvious to be called a conspiracy.
- pasquinelli 7y agoI've been thinking lately about what people will and won't be skeptical about. All the horrifying stories coming from escapees from north korea, for instance, are accepted without any real scrutany. But if there is a class of powerful people that publically executes people by steam roller, why is it so hard to believe there could be a network of child sex trafficing for a powerful class of people here? Or if a child sex ring is too outlandish, why believe in the stories about north korea? Is it down to diplomatic relations? Should that be a factor?
- Nasrudith 7y agoIt isn't the magnitude of evil but the remoteness - we know about life in the United States. We don't know many details about a secretive repressive nation. There are also flaws about 'requiring far too many people to keep a secret' and some major 'game theory'. Now it is a matter of fact that he was involved with sex trafficking and corruption but there were plenty of reasons to doubt. The story hit upon a number of other discredited conspiracy tropes and archetypes. A network of child sex traffickers resembles too much 'orderly world' conspiracy theorist family. Where there is some vast conspiracy to blame for everything wrong with the world but there is at least someone behind it and some concrete goal to 'fix it'. As opposed to a chaotic real world where there is nothing that can be done about it - sometimes some nut-job decides to do something really scary like kill the president or shoot up schools. Not to mention the anti-semetic tropes hit upon by it when there was a simpler explanation for his contact with high level people - he was rich. Being a donor would have explained it far easier than a sex trafficking conspiracy before concrete evidence. Frankly the 'believers' of the story did more to make less believable than any amount of spin-doctors with things like drawing tenuous connections to anyone who ever met the guy being a pedophile.
- BubRoss 7y agoNo one doubts that there people who would do it, it is more about how widespread criminal networks could be without blowing up.
- jgalt212 7y ago> This will only inflame conspiracy theory minded people to believe there is a vast conspiracy by the powerful to protect themselves. I'll do you one better. Is he really even dead, or did he pull a Ken Lay?
- 2_listerine_pls 7y agoWhy dismiss as conspiracy-minded those who raise the possibility of foul play?
- mistermann 7y agoPeople have been socially conditioned to do this - not necessarily intentionally, it may have just happened naturally, but this is how right thinking people are to behave.
- drukenemo 7y agoWe are basically presented with a potential conspiracy shoved in our faces and you are worried that people might see a conspiracy there. It’s not an absurd logic. Definition of the word: “an evil, unlawful, treacherous, or surreptitious plan formulated in secret by two or more persons; plot.”