4 ms·
Imagine you go to an online forum and that there is a 99.99% chance that a given message was written by a bot. Imagine further they are sufficiently well writte
by im3w1l 7y ago
Imagine you go to an online forum and that there is a 99.99% chance that a given message was written by a bot. Imagine further they are sufficiently well written you can't tell from the post itself whether it was made by a bot or not How would people respond to that?
Well the obvious consequence is that you have to stop paying attention to random posts. You have to depend on something outside of the forum itself to find a list of people to pay attention to. That will be your friends and your family. And then it will be whatever media tells you to pay attention to.
Getting out of your filter bubble will be impossible because as soon as you step out you are faced by an onslaught of bots.
Maybe you could travel around IRL and acquire a diverse list of voices that way. But realistically only the elite could afford that.
Actually lets be even more cynical. Say you go traveling, meet someone. You add them on a social network. But it's not them it's a bot. And they get a few bucks for selling your eyeballs.
But then we can even further imagine that you follow them with a fake account too, and so the eyeballs were actually worthless.
- GuiA 7y agoWhat you are describing is already ongoing. Many comments in eg widely shared Facebook political posts are likely to be posted by bots, or people paid to be representing a certain agenda (ie human bots). And in that light I disagree with your “obvious consequence” that people will stop paying attention to forum posts, because we know that people do engage with trolls/bots on Twitter/Facebook/etc. People are also fine watching cable TV for hours, which is content that is entirely designed by people whose intentions we do not know. What fundamental difference does it make whether candidate Doe’s agenda is pushed by bots on forums vs TV anchors paid to read off a teleprompter, when people are so eager to sit in front of it and engage with it? Human attention is the new commodity, and the average person just does not have the means to fight the billions of dollars collectively poured into exploiting their eyeballs.
- UnpossibleJim 7y agoThey have the means, they just don't have the discipline, I think. We don't really teach discipline, critical thinking or money management in public schools; all of which are necessary for adult life. The kaleidoscope of chaos is hard to turn your eyes from, but it's worth doing if you set your mind to it.
- rdiddly 7y agoKind of ironic that the means of fighting the billions spent is to do nothing, which is totally free and takes less effort than e.g. purchasing a TV, purchasing a subscription, starting a social media account and engaging with it, or even reading an article.
- GuiA 7y agoYes, but humans abhor doing nothing!
- a3n 7y agoThe strategy you describe is for someone who wants the truth. If you instead want your assumptions reinforced, you pay attention to whatever source does that.
- friendlybus 7y agoThere's still a distinction of quality for reinforcing your world view. Humans have more impact than bots. Bots all lead back a human anyway so taking some meaningless bot chat is still less valuable than a human's perspective.
- bitcurious 7y agoYou would enjoy reading Neal Stephenson's new novel "Fall; or, Dodge in Hell." The middle part imagines how America would change as a consequence of exactly that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall;_or,_Dodge_in_Hell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall;_or,_Dodge_in_Hell
- MarcScott 7y agoThis was the most interesting and realistically prescient part of the novel for me. Coastal elites have "editors" to curate their feed, while the rest of the population are awash with conspiracy theories, cults and extreme libertarianism. The story took the 2016 election shenanigans to its logical conclusion. Definitely worth a read.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoSomeone called Neal Stephenson imagined that to perfection in the first third of [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall;_or,_Dodge_in_Hell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall;_or,_Dodge_in_Hell Amusing to read.
- riffic 7y ago>Someone called Neal Stephenson This is such an interesting way to refer to an author.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoooops
- rmwaite 7y agoTo me, it sounds like the kind of phrase an author would use - the sort of playfulness you see sometimes to mix things up.
- whatshisface 7y agoHere's a hot take: you shouldn't be trusting intenet comments written by humans anyway. If a bot comment contains something you should actually listen to (sources, evidence) then you should listen to it, and if a human comment is just a Reddit-style popular opinion dogpile it is just as bad as a bot comment.
- cirgue 7y ago> Here's a hot take: you shouldn't be trusting intenet comments written by humans anyway. I remember an old New Yorker cartoon from the 90s that says 'On the internet, no one knows you're a dog'. Lying has been a fundamental feature of the medium since the beginning. Most of the history of the internet pre-smartphone is people trying to figure out how to combat trolls and spammers. It appears that we are having to learn the same lessons all over again. There seems to be a kind of collective amnesia about the fact that the majority of content on the internet is written by people that are trying to sell you something, trying to get your attention for their own amusement, or are batshit insane. Frequently it's more than one of these things.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoVernor Vinge's A Fire Upon the Deep (1992) depicts a galaxy of countless highly advanced civilizations in the far future - and describes its "net" as "the net of a million lies". However, it also depicts every message with an AI's best judgement of its reliability - for example: >From: Sandor Arbitration Intelligence at the Zoo [A known military corporation of the High Beyond. If this is a masquerade, somebody is living dangerously.] More examples here: https://hur.st/afutd.html https://hur.st/afutd.html (spoilers if you read more than the From lines)
- zxcmx 7y agoIt seems like the same argument could equally well justify reading the entire contents of your spam folder. FWIW I agree with your take, but practically speaking I use whatever “metadata” I can (is this a bot, is the writer a pseudoscientist, is this thread a flame war) to help deal with the fact that it’s so much cheaper to create bull%^*t than to critically evaluate an argument or idea.
- alexashka 7y agoYou've described human life since humans were around. Just replace 'bot' with 'human being'. We're all living in bubbles. It is why travelling is interesting - you get to be in a different bubble, come home and notice the peculiarities of your bubble that you never noticed before. It is why movies are interesting - we jump into a different bubble, for the same purposes. There is no problem here, because there is no 'truth' that gets obscured as a result. The human experience is not about uncovering truth, it's just an experience to be had and possibly enjoyed if the universe happens to align for you to do so :)
- throwaway94857 7y agoI believe the age of the anonymous internet is over. It's time for real world identity linked accounts for participating in online conversations. This is necessary for 2 reasons. First, it gives us confidence the people we are speaking to are (probably) not bots. Second, it reduces the need for online censorship beyond what is required by law. So much of the hateful garbage posted online is only posted in the first place because of anonymity. Remove that, we probably don't get that posting in the first place so we can avoid the messy issue of enforced top down censorship.
- GuiA 7y agoWhat about gay teenagers growing up in disapproving community, people in abusive relationships, etc who need advice and support?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- corndoge 7y agoIt is a slippery slope from regulating "hateful garbage" (to be explicit, I interpret this to include speech that is not necessarily hate speech) to censorship of whatever the state determines to be wrongthink. I'll take my anonymity where I can get it, thanks. And as an aside, it's somewhat ironic you post this on a throwaway.
- throwaway94857 7y agoI agree completely. I'm saying if we remove anonymity we won't need top down censorship.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- friendlybus 7y agoVoluntarily protecting your online identity so it is clearly not a bot, becomes valuable.
- alexanderdmitri 7y agoI can see Turing tests becoming ever more useful (and annoying) going forward.