8 ms·
Americans need to raze their healthcare system down to the ground. None of the bandaid fixes like getting the government to pay but still having private compani
by gambiting 7y ago
Americans need to raze their healthcare system down to the ground. None of the bandaid fixes like getting the government to pay but still having private companies dictating the prices. The whole system has to be torn down and rebuilt from scratch, with the state the main owner of hospitals and provider of healthcare. The kind of things that you read about the current system are just absurd, but it's past the financial absurdity at this point, reading about insurance companies literally deciding whether cancer treatment is "strictly necessary" for weeks without approving it is not a healthcare system, it's hell, it's barbarism.
- rsyring 7y ago> The whole system has to be torn down and rebuilt from scratch, with the state the main owner of hospitals and provider of healthcare. The kind of things that you read about the current system are just absurd, How involved are you with other US government organizations? Do they usually strike you as highly competent and efficient? Are you sure that if we did what you suggest we wouldn't have a whole different set of monstrous absurdities?
- rootusrootus 7y agoWe could choose to staff them with competent people instead of deliberately sabotaging it. There are viable alternatives to the GOP strategy.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoIf only someone had thought of that before
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 7y agoMaybe we could run it similarly to the government-run air traffic control system, which is superb. “Government” doesn’t have to mean “incompetent and inefficient.”
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoMaybe we could. Or maybe we'd run it like the VA. [Edit: enraged_camel said that the VA is pretty good. Is that accurate? I've heard otherwise, but I don't know firsthand. If the VA example isn't accurate, though, replace it with "California high speed rail" or "Amtrak" or "the Department of Education".] It doesn't have to mean incompetent and inefficient, but it seems that it often does.
- rootusrootus 7y agoPerhaps we could call it "Medicare" and it would be way more efficient than any of the private insurers.
- mattkrause 7y agoAlong the Northeast corridor, taking Amtrak downtown-to-downtown takes about as long as flying and is vastly more pleasant. The service out west is bad because it's a gongshow of interactions between Amtrak and a bunch of private companies, which seems...oddly reminiscent of something. My only direct experience with the Department of Education was college financial aid. The FAFSA wasn't particularly awful and I appreciate the help I got--the work study job not only paid for my books and food, but got me started in my career.
- mikeash 7y agoHow often? People love to act as though government can’t do anything right. Government does plenty of things right, those just don’t get much attention. I sit here next to my government road with government postal service, lights powered by a private utility heavily regulated by the government, and wish the government provided trash service to me like they do for my neighbor because I’m getting fed up with the shoddy trash service I get from the company I pay, and think, yeah, government health care could be pretty good, just like it is in so many other countries. The US is not uniquely incompetent here.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> Government does plenty of things right, those just don’t get much attention. Fair point.
- mattkrause 7y agoYes, actually. NOAA and NASA do a great job forecasting weather and tides. The CDC does a ton for public health: no recent pandemics I can recall. The NIH is one of the best biomedical research agencies in the world—-and the NSF, NASA, DoE, and DoD research divisions are no slouches either (GPS, internet, etc). The Library of Congress and Smithsonian make a lot of American heritage accessible to everyone—-and also do serious research of their own. The National Parks are awe-inspiring. The USPS can reliably get something to my family on the other side of the continent for $0.50. The USDA has kept our food supply wholesome, and the FAA/NTSB have made flying—an intrinsically crazy activity, absurdly safe. The SEC and FDIC have keep American markets aboveboard and attractive to investors from around the world. There’s more to the government than the DMV and taxes. In fact, if you’ve ever had to interact with the IRS, they are astonishingly pleasant—-I got a question answered and a (small) amount of money refunded in a ten minute phone call. It was vastly better than calling Comcast or the insurance company.
- enraged_camel 7y agoMedicare and VA, while not perfect, are both well-run and extremely popular. So yes, the US government is in fact capable of handling healthcare.
- refurb 7y agoMuch of the Medicare business is funded by the gov’t, but executed by private insurers (Part C and Part D). And based on the scandal around the VA a few years ago, no it wasn’t well run at all.
- enraged_camel 7y ago>>And based on the scandal around the VA a few years ago, no it wasn’t well run at all. Scandals aren't unique to government. The private sector has them all the time. In fact, sometimes private sector scandals are so massive they crash the entire economy.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI tell myself there are easily hundreds or thousands of Front Page NYT stories every day, but they never leak to the public.
- refurb 7y agoOf course, but the VA is the largest gov’t run healthcare system in the US and the scandal impacted tens of thousands of veterans. Doesn’t exactly engender confidence.
- bsder 7y ago> Are you sure that if we did what you suggest we wouldn't have a whole different set of monstrous absurdities? Most people on Medicare are generally quite happy with it. The idiocies generally start when the government let private companies get involved (Medicare Part D). In addition, the person who brought "socialized medicine" to Canada is regarded as as a hero. Talking points without citation are not data.
- rootusrootus 7y agoAt the rate we are going, whoever finally brings Medicare to everyone in the US will be regarded as a hero as well. I have what qualifies as pretty good coverage by US standards and I still won't shed a single tear when it gets replaced with single payer. In fact I look forward to having more flexibility to switch jobs or start my own business without having that consideration.
- rat87 7y ago> Do they usually strike you as highly competent and efficient Far from all but,a decent number of them yes
- clarkmoody 7y agoHealthcare has been a political football for decades, with massive interventions by government up and down the stack of services. Think about the market's provision of grocery stores: plenty of competition. Most places they don't enjoy geographic monopolies like car dealerships do. They manage to get one of the most vital goods to a huge population spread across a huge area on time and at a great price, with local variations anticipating the specific desires of local consumers. There is no central coordinator or Department of Grocery Services. The market figures it out. How can someone look at healthcare, with its absolutely absurd outcomes, and not understand that it is precisely because of government interference that nothing makes any sense? Costs keep rising unsustainably, which is the opposite of the way markets work. Paperwork and administrative staff balloons in proportion to patient care. Once the state gets involved, now it becomes political. Do you think the current political climate in the US should be further embedded into healthcare? If the state controlled everything, then you'd get outcomes like red/blue states losing/gaining funding depending on the results of the most recent election. One could imagine more dystopian outcomes quite easily.
- dahfizz 7y ago> they don't enjoy geographic monopolies like car dealerships do This is a bit of a tangent, but do car dealerships have geographic monopolies in some places? I don't think I've even seen just one dealership. They always cluster around each other where I'm from - you could car shop on foot and see at least 3-4 different dealerships.
- 7y ago
- bookofjoe 7y ago>Decent vision means less chance of falling and breaking bones, and yet new research reveals a heartbreaking state of affairs – the NHS is rationing routine operations that can restore sight, by categorising the procedure as “non-essential”. As a result of this misguided policy, hundreds of thousands of people are currently marooned at home with cataracts, their lives diminished by NHS pen-pushers callously deciding their condition isn’t life-threatening. Cataracts might not be “life-threatening” but they are most definitely “life-diminishing”. https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/scandal-nhs-eye-operations-non-essential-waiting-times-a8835556.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/scandal-nhs-eye-operati... >Thousands more patients made to 'beg for treatment' as NHS rations hip operations, investigation finds https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/nhs-rations-operations-hip-patients-beg-treatment-cuts-funding-a8453531.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/nhs-rations-operat...