13 ms·
There is no need to go from one extreme to the other. This is about eating "less" meat. People do not traditionally eat that much meat because meat used to be
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
There is no need to go from one extreme to the other. This is about eating "less" meat.
People do not traditionally eat that much meat because meat used to be expensive and its supply limited.
This is still the case in poor countries.
In developed countries, people started to eat more and more meat as they got richer because we naturally like meat and because of clever marketing.
We now eat too much meat, and also consume too much dairy (adults don't need to drink any milk and many don't digest it well, by the way). If people just stopped eating meat at every meal or every day, consumption would drastically drop without too much of a change in daily life.
One solution would be measures to increase prices but that is a political minefield.
- lol768 7y ago>adult don't need to drink any milk and many don't digest it well, by the way Never understood the obsession with drinking milk on its own (though I never liked the taste of it myself either). There's plenty of calcium to be found in other sources: kale, leafy greens, almonds, fortrified grains, beans/pulses etc.
- close04 7y agoYou're missing one solid reason to drink milk: some people like it. Most of the stuff we eat today is actually not about nutritional needs. And your argument can always be reshuffled. Swap milk with any one of the items you listed and one by one you can disqualify all of them from consumption. Variety is a good thing, meaning something should be eliminated because it's no good, not because there are alternatives. There's no requirement or recommendation to cover your daily needs with the least varied diet.
- markstos 7y agoOf people I know who have reduced animal consumption, drinking cow milk and having it on cereal is one of the first things to go. In the early days soy milk was about the only alternative. Now there are so many dairy-free milk alternatives to try. The proliferation of grocery shelves is a testament to their growing popularity.
- harimau777 7y agoThis is a very niche reason, but one of the classic diets for beginner weight lifters who want to gain weight is to add a gallon of whole milk a day to their existing diet. For people that are trying to consume more calories and protein, I don't know of an alternative that combines comparable calorie & protein density, low cost, ease of consumption, and zero preparation time. More generally, I think that one of the big challenges with plant based diets is a lack of easily available calorie and protein dense foods. (I'm not saying its impossible to get enough calories and protein as a vegan, even as a bodybuilder. Just that it is not nearly as easy.)
- growlist 7y agoI got a free sample of pea protein powder with some whey one time. It was truly disgusting!
- ppseafield 7y agoUnflavored pea protein is pretty bad, but there are a ton of delicious vegan protein powder options out there.
- gwm83 7y agoI haven't heard of this and I know a good number of weight trainers. Doesn't this give people massive squirts? Can anyone digest a whole gallon of milk in a day? Gross
- wreath 7y agoI think you are referring to Mark Rippetoe’s suggested diet in his book Starting Strength. In which case, it is worth mentioning that this is suggested for skinny, 18 year old males and to be followed for the duration of the training program (months)
- markstos 7y agoEven weight lifting is changing, with one of the top weight lifters being vegan: https://www.greatveganathletes.com/patrik-baboumian-vegan-strongman/ https://www.greatveganathletes.com/patrik-baboumian-vegan-st... Dairy in particular can be source of inflammation. One of the benefits of the vegan diets for athletes cited is a fast recovery time after workouts.
- academic_nimrod 7y agoPeople aren't obsessed with it, it's just good. You ever had a cold glass of whole milk with a slice of chocolate cake? It's good for your soul.
- lol768 7y agoI have, I wasn't much of a fan :P (Cow) milk just seems to have an unpleasant aftertaste to me. I get on well with oat milk, though.
- growlist 7y agoOne of the strangest things to me about lunch in the Netherlands: adult men drinking milk with their meal, this meal sometimes consisting of a chocolate hundreds and thousands sandwich O_o
- radicalbyte 7y agoAt least that's better than drinking buttermilk and a cheese sandwich :)
- mrep 7y agoThat is hilarious because I love to drink milk with sweet pastries and my girlfriend also thinks drinking straight milk is disgusting. It's hard to explain why, but I think the main reason is that I am not super into sweets and milk seems to counteract the sweetness. I also get heartburn frequently and milk tends to help my stomach not feel terrible like it would if I ate a sweet pastry by itself.
- dmux 7y ago>Never understood the obsession with drinking milk on its own It's something that's been consumed for millennia. There are societies based on pastoralism where milk is a huge part of the diet. I'd hardly classify it as being an obsession.
- lol768 7y ago>It's something that's been consumed for millennia. There are societies based on pastoralism where milk is a huge part of the diet. I'd hardly classify it as being an obsession. Obsession is probably the wrong word, but I'd still be curious as to the history behind it (and how long it continued into adulthood). Especially given its association with and place in a juvenile diet.
- bigato 7y agoGiven the extreme we are in yes, going to the other extreme would be a good thing. And even then, not enough. This is just one of the multiple changes that humanity need to bring about. I don't think people should be prohibited from eating animal products, but those who have the will to remove it completely from their diets would definitely be having a much higher positive impact on the environment.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt would be helpful, obviously, but it is not necessary and not realistic. Trying to go to an extreme is counter-productive because people won't follow. Convincing people not to eat meat at every meal or every day has a much higher chance of delivering significant results quickly.
- aaron695 7y ago> One solution would be measures to increase prices but that is a political minefield. What's another solution? People will keep slaves if it's legal. Stopping the use of tax payer dollars to help people eat meat seems not that much of a minefield compared too?
- kpU8efre7r 7y agoExactly this. I will never go vegan or vegetarian but I mostly limit meat to only dinner and in smaller portions. My grocery bill is much smaller, it's healthier, and better for the environment overall. Pushing a full-blown switch to veganism as the only solution is not pragmatic.
- fpoling 7y agoMy grandmother told me that before the second world war for a typical peasant family in Belarus the meat meant a single chicken 2-4 times in a month for the whole family. Only on big celebrations few times in a year people could afford to slaughter a pig or a caw. Even eggs were considered expensive. Milk was more available as most families had a cow. The real staple food was potato and bread. In cities meat was more available as workers typically earned more. Option to eat meat each day was considered a luxury.
- loceng 7y agoI think we should be pointing to science - which to date it hasn't been adequately done relating to diet, to see what diet is optimal, and how that varies per group whether that's by blood type, DNA/ancestral data, or other - while taking in the particular sensitivities of each individual as part of the research vs. making the reference points based on a structure of scarcity of what was available based on what people could afford; also having an idea of a person's current health state, how healthy their GI tract is and overall system needs to be taken into account as to how they may or may not respond to different diets - including not limited to how we're only just beginning to understand how gut bacteria and within the whole GI tract can strongly impact outcome.
- diyseguy 7y agoIts interesting to hear anecdotal stories like these because they contradict the conventional wisdom nowadays that says you have to eat meat as protein every day - clearly that wasn't the case in prior centuries.
- LegitShady 7y agowhat was the life expectancy? what was the standard of living? trying to call back to 1930s belarus as an example to live from is crazy. It doesn't even logically follow that we should avoid meat because poor farmers in belarus didn't each much. Where's the logical argument?
- berdon 7y ago
- harimau777 7y agoA challenge that I could see with convincing people to adopt a more plant based diet is that there is a carbon cost associated with shipping food across the country, but in many parts of the US a plant based diet might be much less appetizing if it is restricted to local crops. For example, much of the country wouldn't have access to citrus fruits, bananas, pineapples, or avocados. Maybe a solution would be to tax food based on how long it was shipped but to exempt fruits and vegetables from the tax.
- jbob2000 7y agoNa, that's a red herring. We can reduce our meat consumption and not replace it with anything. Americans are over consuming food, we can definitely reduce meat intake without needing to replace it with foods shipped in from out of county. Also, most of the US population is around the coasts. Shipping a bit of food inland to the people there isn't that big of an impact.
- jnwatson 7y agoSo you’re just asking humans to consume fewer calories? Good luck with that.
- ben509 7y ago> Americans are over consuming food Overconsumption is generally less than 10% of their caloric needs, so they can't just drop a large source of nutrition.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoApparently, Americans throw away the equivalent of a third of the calories they consume, and interestingly a lot of fruits and veg. [1] Reducing waste would dramatically help the environment. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/apr/18/americans-waste-food-fruit-vegetables-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/apr/18/american...
- corodra 7y ago
- e12e 7y ago> There is no need to go from one extreme to the other. Global warming due to greenhouse gas is a reason to go to the "other" extreme?
- hanniabu 7y ago> One solution would be measures to increase price, but that is a political minefield. It's only a political minefield because of corporate influence (dictation?) in politics.
- magduf 7y ago>and also consume too much dairy (adults don't need to drink any milk and many don't digest it well, by the way) How much is "too much"? We don't need to drink tea or coffee either; do you propose getting rid of those too? For those of us who have no problems digesting it, what exactly is the problem with eating yogurt or drinking milk? Sure, consuming too much of those probably isn't good, but you can say that about literally any food. For people who don't digest it well, then of course I'd suggest not drinking it. The same goes for any other food: if you're allergic to peanuts, don't eat them. If you're allergic to shellfish, don't eat them. If you're allergic to bananas, don't eat them. If you're lactose-intolerant, don't drink milk unless you really like the taste and want to add lactase enzyme. I do agree that Americans in particular eat way too much red meat, but I think some people give dairy a hard time when I don't think it's that much of a problem compared to many other things. Most adults don't drink a lot of milk anyway; usually "dairy" for adults means eggs, cheese, yogurt, etc. I don't see the health problems with dairy the way I see with red meat either. For improving public health, we should instead be reducing how much red meat people eat, plus also reducing or eliminating stuff like HFCS, refined sugars, refined flour, alcohol, etc. >One solution would be measures to increase prices but that is a political minefield. What they should do is just eliminate the tax breaks that unhealthy industries enjoy.