5 ms·
Uber emerged into the market as a disruptor in the absolute worst sense of the world - it was challenging an entrenched industry with low efficiency (cab compan
by munk-a 7y ago
Uber emerged into the market as a disruptor in the absolute worst sense of the world - it was challenging an entrenched industry with low efficiency (cab companies make ungodly amounts of money in some markets) but it did so by playing by a different set of rules - skirting both the disingenuous regulations put in to protect cab companies' profit and those in place for the safety of the general public. Even disregarding all of the legion HR issues at that company their business model depended on not playing fair and they're paying for it.
I like to compare them to the car sharing companies (like zipcar/car2go etc...) which managed to de-throne the entrenched rental agencies without going out of their way to break laws.
- paxys 7y ago> and those in place for the safety of the general public. What regulations are these? Is there any case where taking taxis was or is safer for an average customer than Uber?
- tekno45 7y agoTaxi drivers had background checks,
- dogma1138 7y agoThey also carry appropriate insurance and have stricter punishments over traffic violations including DUIs.
- xyzzyz 7y ago> have stricter punishments over traffic violations That certainly doesn't stop them from speeding, cutting you off, going straight from right turn lanes and generally driving very aggresively. Cab drivers are really one of the worst when it comes to following traffic rules, second only to urban bicyclists.
- munk-a 7y agoSoo... because they aren't being punished after registering with law enforcement, I shouldn't have to register at all?
- xyzzyz 7y agoNo, what I’m saying is if law is not being enforced, it’s useless, and so pointing at it as some kind of advantage of taxis over Uber is severely misguided.
- paxys 7y agoIndividual taxi companies are in charge of doing background checks on their drivers, same as Uber & Lyft
- darkwizard42 7y agoUber and Lyft have background checks across the board. They also had a higher insurance policy ($1M standard) than most cab companies ever did...
- svara 7y agoIn many places around the world, commercial or taxi driver's licenses require additional medical and background checks compared to a regular license, plus taxis require additional insurance. E.g., UK https://www.gov.uk/taxi-driver-licence/outside-london; https://www.gov.uk/taxi-driver-licence/outside-london; Germany https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/F%C3%BChrerschein_zur_Fahrgastbef%C3%B6rderung https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/F%C3%BChrerschein_zur_Fahrgast...
- lacker 7y agoYou are missing the part where Uber let you get a cab through an app rather than hoping a taxi was driving by and waving your hands at them. It really is a far, far better product when you can get a cab wherever you want, instead of just in a few areas.
- mpweiher 7y agoIs that really the case in the US? At least in Germany, my standard way of getting a cab (wherever I want) was calling one of the dispatch centres. Taxi-hailing apps made this slightly more convenient, and displaying the cab's route to you removed some stress, but it didn't fundamentally alter the service. And Uber really doesn't add any value except for undercutting prices by subsidising the rides via investors and shovelling risk etc. onto the drivers.
- davinic 7y agoIn my area of the US, calling dispatch would get you a ride only when things are not busy whatsoever. Once there is any level of demand, the service will send the call to the fleet but no one is required to fulfill it.
- mpweiher 7y agoWow! That makes Taxis largely useless, IMHO. I think about 99.9% of my taxi use has been call-ahead, often a day before ("I need a cab to the airport at 9am tomorrow").
- xyzzyz 7y agoDid you know that in most places where cab are operating, you could order a cab to pick you up at your house by calling a cab company and talking to the operator? Flagging down a cab as it drives by is a New York City thing.
- VintageLight 7y agoI recently spent a weekend in a major city without Uber/Lyft. Trying to call a cab company was terrible, relative to the user experience of Uber or Lyft. After making my request, a few cab companies simply answered "Ok" before hanging up. I called them back to get an ETA, and their dispatchers would give me answers like "30 to 40 minutes" or "I don't know". I wasn't out in the boonies or anything. I was downtown.
- ghaff 7y ago>I like to compare them to the car sharing companies (like zipcar/car2go etc...) which managed to de-throne the entrenched rental agencies without going out of their way to break laws. Except for the fact that Avis bought Zipcar. So not sure about the dethroning part. I know some folks who really depend on short-term rentals to support being carless but it's a relatively niche service--especially with current Uber/Lyft pricing.
- nearbuy 7y agoThe regulated taxi medallion system wasn't good for drivers either. It was good for medallion owners. Before Uber, taxi medallions in New York were selling for around $1 million. These pricey medallions tended to get bought up by large companies that could afford the investment. Your driver likely couldn't afford one, so instead, drivers would rent a cab and medallion for about $100 per 12-hour shift, on top of the dispatcher fees. This system was supposed to restrict the supply of cabs to ensure drivers earned a decent wage. Instead, all the value is extracted by the medallion holders.
- munk-a 7y agoOh yea, it was a terrible system - even the concept of limiting the number of cabs is sort of silly - but if the medallions get as expensive as they did then I think it's a clear indication that something in the market is broken. Still, that doesn't mean rainbows come out of Uber's bum - it was absolutely a market ripe for new competition, Uber just added that competition in a terrible manner.