5 ms·
“In April, when a story about Katie Bouman, an M.I.T. researcher who helped develop a technology that captured the first photo of a black hole, rose to the fron
by prepend 7y ago
“In April, when a story about Katie Bouman, an M.I.T. researcher who helped develop a technology that captured the first photo of a black hole, rose to the front page, users combed through her code on GitHub in an effort to undermine the weight of her contributions.”
This is an odd statement as it implies the purpose was to undermine. Reading code and critiquing isn’t meant to “undermine” but to identify truth and constantly look for better ways.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y ago...and here we go again. What was, or at least felt, obvious was that there was a double standard being applied. Not just in the sense that such a witch hunt would be unlikely to happen to a man being lauded. But also that if there's one point that Hacker News could probably agree on it's that lines-of-code is a bad metric for evaluating programmers, let alone scientists. There was also the pervasive sense of being on the side of the rest of the team, even though highlighting their contribution was the first thing Katie Bouman did. And at least Andrew Chael, who did write the plurality of the code in the GitHub repo, did come out strongly in favor of her and was horrified of the hate she got. Quote: "So apparently some (I hope very few) people online are using the fact that I am the primary developer of the eht-imaging software library to launch awful and sexist attacks on my colleague and friend Katie Bouman. Stop." (https://twitter.com/thisgreyspirit/status/1116518544961830918 https://twitter.com/thisgreyspirit/status/111651854496183091...) It's curious that, at least in my subjective impression, the tech community has a far larger problem with women than any of the other groups that have traditionally suffered discrimination: racism and especially homophobia really are extremely rare, at least overtly. But the uglyness Katie Bouman, or Ellen Pao, or Marissa Meyers brought out seems to be alive and well.
- nailer 7y agoIf a man received personal acclaim for a discovery, and someone looked at the repo and found that someone other than the man wrote most of the crunchier code, then yes I'd evaluate the acclaim for the man the same way. Note most of the acclaim aimed at the scientist, rather than the team, was from the media. Whom as usual, likes to omit their own role.
- moccachino 7y agoBut would you ever go and look at his repo? If it is the case that she didn't contribute the most complicated stuff, then I can assure you it is not the first time in history that the face of a project is not the one that did the hardest work. Also as has repeatedly been said, she always said it was a team effort. This is all said with the caveat that I didn't follow this 'controversy' and never cared to look at the contribution distribution of all the project members.
- nailer 7y ago> But would you ever go and look at his repo? No. But if someone else checked the repo, I'd be interested. That said the media would be less likely to publish 'this young man took a photo of a black hole'. > Also as has repeatedly been said, she always said it was a team effort. Yep. Also mentioned in my comment you're replying to. I think of this conflict as 'developers versus the media' - the media having pushed the narrative of 'a young woman who took a photo of a black hole'. The media (who like to remove their own influence from discussions) have turned it into 'sexist developers vs young female scientist'. They've been very successful at doing that, yet again, because, well, they're the media. It's easy to shape a story when you control all outlets deemed noteworthy enough to cite.
- pron 7y ago> because, well, they're the media. And because, well, it was true ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Every person I showed this to was disgusted, as was I. So even if you disagree with the characterization, it certainly wasn't just the media, but also your fellow developers. It was a shameful moment (one of many, most of a similar kind) for HN that reflected horribly on developers, and the media called it up on that, as they should.
- read_if_gay_ 7y ago> because, well, it was true [...] Every person I showed this to was disgusted, as was I What you’re saying here is: because the opinion of me and my friends is objectively correct and yours is not ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- cotelletta 7y agoThe only double standard is that when people are skeptical of a woman, a bunch of thirsty men jump to her defense, and turn it into a bigger issue. Not to mention the media's incessant need to profile women doing things and having a giant backpatting session for her and themselves. They are so sure women can do anything men do, they act like it's unprecedented everytime it happens. Here's a crazy idea. Maybe any of the numerous other people who worked on that project were pissed too that she was given all the attention, and they had every right to be. If someone pored over a guy's github, nobody would care, and certainly no random woman would jump to his defense. Somehow this is proof that men oppress women.
- raverbashing 7y agoCode critique has a time and a place: a PR (or equivalent) where you were solicited or it is your role to comment. Outside of it it's just mostly unwelcome noise. If you have a suggestion then do the PR and get your code reviewed in the same way.
- onion2k 7y agoThe reason people were trawling through her Github contributions and comparing them to other members of the team she worked with, and then posting about lines of code as if that's a measure of the value of someone's contribution to a project, was absolutely to undermine her work and show that she wasn't deserving of credit (despite the fact she was repeatedly quoted saying it wasn't all her and that it was a team effort). When that story was on the front page it was one of the few times I've thought about leaving HN. It was embarrassing.
- terminalhealth 7y agoIt was an overreaction which, however, was only enabled by absolutely lazy journalism. They basically took Bouman's Facebook post with a photo of her smiling next to the black hole claiming that she produced the picture, blowing her contributions way out of proportion. Some reports corrected this later that day, but by then, the shitstorm and investigation had already started. Perhaps understandably--she did not produce the picture. One could argue that Bouman's reaction was also way too delayed and she did not enough to clarify the situation, but this is perhaps understandable assuming she did not follow social media very closely. The entire fiasco was mainly caused by the obsession of the media to put women at the forefront.
- jlawson 7y agoShe was deserving of credit. She did great work, and so did dozens (hundreds?) of others on that project. She wasn't deserving of the level of credit that the media gave her when they cast her as the star, visionary, and quasi-leader of the whole enterprise. Nobody was ever against Katie. They were against the way the media handled the story - by slanting the story to advance a political agenda that had nothing to do with the discovery itself, and then calling everyone who had a problem with that sexist while entirely eliding their own role in the controversy. It was entirely a conflict between the media and the people calling out the media for obvious bias. As always, the media's response was to build a narrative where their critics were just trying to hurt [insert victim/victim group here].
- DanBC 7y ago
- hotz 7y agoI thought it was just the annoyance of having the lefty/media point of view pushed hard. Whenever someone that isn't a white male achieves something, there's this push to let the whole world know that a "minority" has accomplished something. It just comes off as a "In your face! Racist white people." I'm fairly certain that most sane folk could care less about the gender or colour of the person making progress for mankind.
- krapp 7y ago>It just comes off as a "In your face! Racist white people." It shouldn't, though. Mentioning gender in relation to a woman's accomplishment is not an implicitly anti-male statement, nor is mentioning race in relation to the accomplishment of a person of color an anti-white statement. Nothing in any article about Katie Bouman was disparaging of men or white people or anyone. >I'm fairly certain that most sane folk could care less about the gender or colour of the person making progress for mankind. Meaning no one who disagrees with your opinion on the matter is sane? Yet reacting defensively and interpreting any mention of gender or race as hostility doesn't seem particularly sane to me.