3 ms·
The article isn't really making a prediction (though the headline spins it as if it might). It's pointing out a pretty obvious and easily understood conflict o
by ajross 7y ago
The article isn't really making a prediction (though the headline spins it as if it might). It's pointing out a pretty obvious and easily understood conflict of interest in the way the bond rating market works. When rating packaged debt, the rating companies are not being "hired" by the end investor who will bear the risk, but by a middle-man firm who are creating the security and trying to unload it. So the rating firm only gets hired if the packager thinks they'll rate the security highly.
That's a real problem, and needs to be solved. It's not by itself a trigger for a financial crisis, though it's not hard to imagine it becoming one.
- vanderZwan 7y agoExactly, and without taking anything away from the article: this is not a new insight. From the moment it became clear what were the main causes of the financial crisis, there have been plenty of people pointing out that practically nothing was done to actually address them.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoOf course not. Because up until the bottom falls out, a few people are going to continue to make tons of money.
- nradov 7y agoPotential bond buyers are free to pay an independent third-party service for an independent rating if they want it.
- pelario 7y agoDo you know if they do it?
- pas 7y agoBig investors do it. They contract independent firms to double-check their own traders' thinking and decisions. It's usually not proactive though. (PE firms get valuation checks before investment, but that's different than bonds.)
- mannykannot 7y agoThere is no practical way that I can make use of the availability of such ratings to protect myself (let alone others) from the damage to the economy that is being caused by the conflicts of interest being described here.
- oarsinsync 7y agoHow do I get my employer-provided-pension fund to do this, when they depend on these rating agencies to ensure they only invest in safe, AAA rated securities?
- gingabriska 7y agoIf that's the case, why market hasn't managed to solve it? Rating agency who's customers pay a subscription price for receiving rating, should solve it?
- mexicanandre 7y agoYour assuming markets are perfect - they aren’t
- billpg 7y agoThat sounds like communism. To the re-education camps with you!
- nabla9 7y agoMarkets only function well to some extent. Just having a market does not mean that you have a system that solves all pricing problems.
- mannykannot 7y agoAs ajross says, there is a conflict of interest here. Not everyone wants an unbiased rating. 2008 provided strong empirical evidence that the market does not have the motive to solve its own problems. Markets are not obliged to conform to theories about how markets should work.
- oarsinsync 7y agoFor each product needing to be rated, there's one seller and potentially many buyers. Sellers need to convince buyers to buy their product. Sellers need to get their product rated in order to appeal to buyers. It's a one time cost to the seller to appeal to a large amount of buyers, and the higher the rating, the larger the pool of potential buyers. Flip it around. How do you coordinate enough buyers together to pay for rating all the potential products out there to buy?
- gingabriska 7y agoYes, you are right. Also because rating can't be kept private, so there is no reason for any buyer to subscribe and then rating agency isn't viable.
- tareqak 7y agoWhy not have legislation similar to what enables the credit-rating agencies to report on people’s credit habits on the securities industry?
- lr4444lr 7y agoSounds like a problem with (this type of) bonds in general as a financial instrument if their pricing is not contingent on actual market forces but rather the word of an expert.
- anthonypasq 7y agothey are priced based on the market, but rated by an agency. bond pricing is easily understood math. People just trust the agencies when they rate bonds highly, even if they shouldnt be
- adaptiveValleys 7y ago> middle-man firm who are creating the security and trying to unload it. If the investment bank only facilitates the transaction, then the key incentive that could tilt the transaction toward having a sense of urgency, and as a result, indifference to the rating accuracy would be the personal gain of the individual/team attempting to process the transaction. If that assumption holds, would tying in a performance based return to the banker who sells the security, balance it? That way they also have incentive to make sure the rating is as accurate as possible? If so, then it seems that it would probably be resolved through legislation, because otherwise it appears to be an intractable coordination problem. Unless including a return for the seller based on the performance is something that occurs in the industry for other types of securities.