4 ms·
I've always loved being on the water, but had a kind of instinctual revulsion at the gas usage, the fumes, the oil that leaks into the water, and the sheer nois
by crazygringo 7y ago
I've always loved being on the water, but had a kind of instinctual revulsion at the gas usage, the fumes, the oil that leaks into the water, and the sheer noise from the engine -- like boating is about being with nature, but the gasoline aspect just ruins it for me.
I tried sailing, but even then you need a backup motor and to get in/out of the oil-soaked harbor. (And sailing is a lot of work.)
The idea of electric boats makes me actually interested in the idea of boating for the first time again... does anyone know if they leak oil just as much though?
- dylan604 7y agoWhy would they even have oil to leak? Oil is a lubricant for the extreme heat conditions of a combustion engine. This is just an electric motor. If you think about it, you don't put oil in a ceiling fan that runs 24/7.
- crazygringo 7y agoI mean, the buyer doesn't, but the factory does. Ceiling fans function with ball bearings that are oiled, same as bicycles function with chains that are oiled. Obviously oil doesn't get into the air, but contact with water is a different matter. I have zero knowledge about boat motors but had always assumed the oil leakage had something to do with lubricating movement of the propeller that also prevented sea water from getting in and corroding internal elements. Is this wrong? Do electric boat motors function completely without oil?
- dylan604 7y agoYes, electric motors function without oil. They're mainly magnets and coils of wire and are mostly* friction-less. Boat engines are the same concept as your car. Air, fuel, spark, piston. In fact, the boat my family had when I was a kid had an inboard/outboard setup. The engine was a Chrysler V6. It was fascinating to me as a kid because when the cover was pulled off, the entire engine was exposed and very accessible compared to it being in a car. Instead of a transmission connected to a drive shaft, it was connected to some worm gears that turned the prop. The main difference is a car's leaking oil mainly falls onto the streets (and gets diluted before hitting the water sources) where the boat's goes directly into the water.
- gingabriska 7y agoIf electric motor is anything like PC fan, than it should have bearing? My fans have either double ball bearing or sleeve bearing and last I heard there are also some maglev type of fans but I don't know if they are really maglev or they also have some kind of bearing. Will check later.
- jabl 7y agoElectric motors need bearings, but the bearings need a minuscule amount of oil compared to an internal combustion engine. Boats have something called a "packing box" which is a seal around the propeller shaft so that water doesn't leak into the boat. Traditionally they use hemp fibers and tallow, nowadays PTFE or similar is a popular alternative.
- throwawayForMe2 7y agoI had a small sail boat with an electric inboard engine. The electric motor, through pulleys and a belt, turned a shaft to turn a prop. All of the machinery from the shaft to the prop would be the same whatever was used to drive the shaft. It was a joy to use. Absolutely quiet, always worked, instant power whenever wanted or needed. Basically zero motor maintenance, no pollution or oil anywhere. The shaft is effectively watertight through seals called packing glands. You get a drip but it is manageable and needed for lubrication.
- cle 7y agoI actually rode on a boat with one of their motors, and it was a very positive experience, having grown up with gas-powered boats. It felt much less invasive and more like I was enjoying nature and the water, rather than just enjoying the boat. Like being on a sailboat. And you look down and don’t see the rainbow swirls of gas/oil in the water. I don’t know how much oil they actually leak, probably very low/none.
- nradov 7y agoSailing isn't really that much work. With a little skill it's possible to sail in and out of most harbors without using a motor. My sailing instructor only allowed us to start the engine in emergencies.
- gmiller123456 7y agoTry kayaking. I've been doing it for 15 years, you get all the joy of being on the water, and can go more remote places than the bigger boats can.