5 ms·
You forgot car loans. A few years ago my wife was offered an 84 month loan when she was unemployed. Very few people keep a car for 84 months. I'm sure there
by jedberg 7y ago
You forgot car loans. A few years ago my wife was offered an 84 month loan when she was unemployed. Very few people keep a car for 84 months. I'm sure there will be a lot of people underwater on those loans pretty soon.
- lucas_membrane 7y agoEven 84 months ago around a third of those trading in a car for a new one were underwater on the trade-in.
- dylan604 7y agoAuto-loans are the only ones that I've ever heard of that allow you to take the balance of one note and just move it to a new note. Maybe credit card balance transfers, but those are just moving debt from one holder to another. Car loans are adding the balance of the existing note to the new loan.
- im3w1l 7y agoOh... given the people inside my little bubble I'm surprised to hear people don't. If the economy tightened up, presumably people would compensate by keeping the car longer though?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoAnd service the debt with what job?
- dylan604 7y agoare you not underwater immediately on any car loan? sure it's worse on 84 months, but the old saying about "once you drive it off the lot" would apply to any loan would it not?
- jedberg 7y agoMost normal car loans are for four or five years and leave you about even three years in so If you trade it in you don’t owe anything.
- fingerlocks 7y agoThis is only true in the short run for new vehicles. A well-maintained vehicle will hold a significant amount of value after 10+ years. And if you are fortunate or savvy enough to buy a car that will obtain “collector” status you may even make a nice profit. One extreme example is the 86’-91 Volkswagen Vanagon Syncro, which can be sold for up to $90k today. A more common example is the first generation Toyota Tacoma (00’-04’) that is currently going up in price, I’ve seen closing prices at $15k in the last year. Small trucks are now extinct and this particular model is proven to be absurdly reliable, but who would have predicted that 10 years ago when these were selling for $3k-$5k?
- londons_explore 7y agoThese are outliers though, and in macroeconomics will have near zero impact.
- fingerlocks 7y agoYes I’m aware, didn’t intend to imply otherwise
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoYour examples are trendy vehicles that have hordes of fools lining up to pay multiple grand for examples that can't even move under their own power. Nobody in their right mind would say that classic VW vans or any Toyota pickup is indicative of market patterns in general. They are what the "cool kids" drive and pricing reflects that. Diesel trucks used to be grossly overpriced too but now that most of the older stuff has aged out and the "new enough to still be kinda nice" market segment is full of emissions era diesels the crazy pricing has mostly gone away.
- fingerlocks 7y agoWow a little harsh, don’t you think? Maybe I should have used the Toyota Corolla instead? These weren’t trendy vehicles when they were new, that’s my point. Perhaps you missed the part of my comment where I prefaced with “If your fortunate...”? Because obviously this was an off-topic side comment countering GPs generalizing that all cars necessarily lose value, not a strong claim about the market as a whole.
- baby 7y agoIsn't the average 10 years?
- adventured 7y agoThe average new car loan is 5 years 9 months. The average used car loan is 5 years 5 months.