5 ms·
I really wish awareness of this reached a wider audience, third party advertising is a terrible blight on the web that has been allowed to grow and fester - it
by munk-a 7y ago
I really wish awareness of this reached a wider audience, third party advertising is a terrible blight on the web that has been allowed to grow and fester - it supplies no value and compromises both browser security and our peace of mind - being bombarded by these things constantly is training most of us to ignore a lot more and focus on short focused bursts of information...
IMO (and this is really deep into opinion) this has slowly been contributing to the lack of attention spans and un-inquisitive response most people have when things on facebook just straight out tell lies. Web-advertising has such a feeble value for the cost it's exacting.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoIf ads were just images / text links I wouldnt ever bother using an adblocker. But because pop ups and insane amounts of JS abuse, auto playing videos and browser exploits I just cant stand ads. At least ads in magazines flow with the content.
- panarky 7y agoIf you go to the Chase login page, it loads js from demdex.net. DemDex "captures behavioral data on behalf of Websites and advertisers and stores it in a 'behavioral data bank.'" uMatrix blocks it for me, but this shit could harvest banking credentials?? https://imgur.com/a/oTm09k2 https://imgur.com/a/oTm09k2
- type0 7y ago> this shit could harvest banking credentials?? It's not that it happens or could happen, the problem is that when credentials are leaked the user gets all the blame: "not our fault, you probably had a virus on your device", and most users will believe it.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoWe need a sort of GDPR law but not as... Broad or unclear as it is. The problem is big tech companies would never draft a bill that puts them in a bad spot. For the People has become For the Corporations and it really does suck.
- AstralStorm 7y agoGDPR is actually very narrow, specific and clear, as far as privacy laws go. The only unclear thing is the distinction between processor, manager and collection of data. That's because it's narrow in scope.
- danielhughes 7y agoDemdex is a DMP from Adobe that is used by companies to manage their first-party data so this particular example with Chase is very likely not an example of third-party ad serving abuse. Chase would have presumably put Adobe through a security review during an RFP process and would have no reason to harvest their own customers' login credentials. Their use case is probably something benign like wanting to segment customers for targeting based on their site usage patterns. Chase has different login pages but the one I'm looking at doesn't appear to have any third-party JS loading from advertisers.
- kpU8efre7r 7y agoIt does provide value though. As much as I hate it most people don't want to pay for shit. So here we are.
- docbrown 7y ago>most people don't want to pay for shit I’ve paid for news before and they still bloat their pages with ads to track me. It’s not a matter of people not wanting to pay. Customers are willing to pay for X and Y if and when it nets them a positive gain in their experience with a product. The problem is more about how these corporations are constantly making our experiences worse while also still tracking our every click.
- Quekid5 7y agoYeah, I'd actually be happy to pay... and I do for LWN, for example. The problem is that publishers apparently(!) cannot properly distinguish between ad-driven revenue streams and good/loyal-customer revenue streams. (I don't know why this is even an issue, but here we are.) Do NOT serve ads to your loyal revenue stream. Even if you can't make ends meet, do NOT do it. That will piss them off to no end, and they're your most loyal readers; they'll leave and never come back.
- hedora 7y agoI asked someone in ad tech why “pay to remove the ads” is unheard of. Think about it from the advertisers’ perspective: You have a user base with a bunch of people. The ones that paid you to remove ads are, at least on average, wealthier than those that don’t. They certainly have disposable income. In other words, the people that paid for a subscription are exactly the fraction of the audience the advertiser is paying for access to! Of course, this argument falls apart for per-user targeted ads when ad blockers are prevalent. However, it makes perfect sense for display ads that are targeted based on content, or audience demographics, such as traditional mass media: tv, radio and newspapers. In fact, the logic seems to extend to any website that is trying to charge an above-bottom-feeder premium for ad real estate.
- deleted 7y ago
- andrerm 7y ago> I really wish awareness of this reached a wider audience 1) it will not happen, not even Cambridge Analytica did and Facebook plans for more "privacy" took the media, Facebook did nothing or too little and now people think they are safer 2) People will not help making digital security and privacy any better, I can't explain why, but it must come from trully ethical developers Privacy must be set by default. Ad tech co. have an conflict of interest in this privacy matter and can't lead the way. Developers from ad tech will always truly believe they are doing what's better for users but they just can't for many reasons. Privacy by default is not a dream, it is not utopia, but it requires another business model. Ads will simple not allow privacy. My opinion anyway
- type0 7y ago> 2) People will not help making digital security and privacy any better The biggest majority of Web users do not even realize how this stuff works. I asked one no technical friend what he thought about Google business model, the answer surprised me: they positioned themselves as intermediary on the Web so that most traffic goes through them so that they could serve ads. That's probably not completely incorrect but what regular paps and moms don't know is that web site creators themselves agreed to this deal with the devil and their soul is now completely gone. When no-one, not even the most valuable or knowledgeable customers complain about the gazillions of tracking scripts on the page, there's no way this could get better. For regular people "Privacy" means a few setting that you could change on some conglomerate web site until they rebuild/reset the page so that you'll have to do this all over again.
- dorgo 7y ago>That's probably not completely incorrect Far from it: From https://revenuesandprofits.com/how-google-makes-money/ https://revenuesandprofits.com/how-google-makes-money/ : >68.3% of the total, from the advertising over the Google websites >21.2% of the total, from advertising over the Google Network Member’ websites I couldn't find a more up-to-date source, but judging from these numbers website creators are responsible for only around a fifth of google's revenue.
- jdavis703 7y agoHow can it be claimed ads supply no value when lots of readers on this site rant about paywalls? People clearly are getting some kind of value from "free" ad-supported media. I used to be editor-in-chief of my college newspaper. Most of our print ad revenue didn't actually come from direct sales. It came from national agencies that gave us insertion orders. I don't think we could have had a print edition based on our in-house ad sales. Now imagine this problem for all kinds of other niche websites that can't afford to have their own ad sales teams... Suddenly it becomes clear why outsourcing ads generates a lot of value for cheapskate media consumers and for cash-strapped media organizations.