13 ms·
LA getting serious about lifting parking requirements in downtown
- pkaye 7y agoIs it the case that most people living in the downtown area don't have a car?
- oomkiller 7y agoThere's quite a bit of capacity available for downtown residents, should they choose to own a car https://www.parkme.com/map#Downtown%20Los%20Angeles%2C%20Los%20Angeles%2C%20CA%2C%20USA https://www.parkme.com/map#Downtown%20Los%20Angeles%2C%20Los...
- pkaye 7y agoAnd how are the typical daily parking rates?
- kitotik 7y agoAround $30/day or $200/mo. DTLA is extremely walk/bike/train/bus friendly, most long term residents I knew did not own cars.
- 0xffff2 7y agoDo those people never leave downtown? DTLA might be walkable, but the greater LA area is famously car centric.
- kitotik 7y agoDTLA is around 50k population, so like any smallish town, you can do most of your life there. But like I said, there are train stations that can get you to most of the greater LA area - Pasadena, Santa Monica, HOLLYWOOD, Long Beach, Chinatown, etc etc.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoAnd Union Station will get you farther. Rideshare, rentals for the rest.
- jaredklewis 7y agoI think most probably have a car, but I'm not sure it matters. Developers will cater to what people want. Most people will probably still want apartments with parking, so most development projects will continue to have parking. Another portion of the population doesn't have cars or are otherwise uninterested in parking. This change would make it legal for there to be development projects that cater to this set of the population.
- DannyBee 7y agoFor the years i saw LA, everyone had a car, and used them religiously. Like, they would take their car to go around the corner. It's kind of ridiculous. Hopefully it's changing.
- mktmkr 7y agoLA has and has long had fewer cars per household than the national average (1.6 vs. 1.8 in the latest census). 12% of households have no car.
- DannyBee 7y ago1. I'm not sure why you think this is inconsistent with what I said. You seem to think it is? 2. I'm not sure what census blocks you are including in your definition? For a very long time, LA was also very famously anti-pedestrian, both in laws and enforcement. It's trying to change for sure, but I would not say it's there yet.
- clairity 7y agodoes removing parking minimums actually lower rents by the 17% of rent that's estimated to go toward parking? parking podiums eat up the most pedestrian-friendly ground floor square footage, but i can sympathize with people wanting parking in their building. i wish all parking would be built underground, but yes, that's even more expensive.
- rory096 7y ago>does removing parking minimums actually lower rents by the 17% of rent that's estimated to go toward parking? No, because removing parking minimums is not the same as removing parking. >parking podiums eat up the most pedestrian-friendly ground floor square footage, but i can sympathize with people wanting parking in their building. In-building parking is a widely available amenity amply provided by the market. Regulatory parking requirements don't change that, they just make it illegal to not want parking.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoIt's funny, in London new housing has been built with the explicit planning condition that residents aren't entitled to on street parking and no parking is included in the development.
- mktmkr 7y agoIn SF as well, but the local government has shown itself unable to resist calls to later add parking entitlements to structures after they are built. For example all "live-work" developments are forbidden by law from participating in residential parking permit zones, but the city council has repeatedly established RPP zones on blocks where the sole residential buildings are all live-work.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rory096 7y ago
- StringyBob 7y agoWhere I live (not in the US) we have parking maximums, not minimums. A new office development will not get planning approval if it has more than 2 parking spaces per 3 employees (based on some obscure measurement of building capacity). This is to reduce congestion and encourage more environmentally friendly methods of transportation.
- chc 7y agoI feel like this would be putting the cart before the horse in the US. Failing to put parking in a place with poor walkability and terrible public transportation doesn't seem like it would encourage much of anything.
- mktmkr 7y agoThe cars are the reason the buses are slow. 22% of LA workers travel to work without a car, which isn't great but it's not zero either. Metro LA added a dedicated bus lane on Flower and they are moving more than one bus per minute in that lane. As soon as you remove the cars everything else gets a lot better. https://twitter.com/metrolosangeles/status/1153807208229957632 https://twitter.com/metrolosangeles/status/11538072082299576...
- gowld 7y agoRemoving parking spaces puts more cars on the road -- circling for spots and parking illegally in traffic lanes. If you want faster buses, evict the cars from the bus travel lanes.
- Johnny555 7y agoIf you want faster buses, evict the cars from the bus travel lanes. That's hard to do without BRT - we have plenty of dedicated bus lanes (the right lane) around here, but they all allow cars for right-hand turns, so buses still get stuck behind a line of cars. Without BRT and center-island boarding, it's harder to reserve anything but the far-right lane since the bus needs to get there to pickup/dropoff passengers.
- bahmboo 7y agoLost in this can be the specifics of "parking". Put in lots of 3-5 minute zones for ride hailing, add 10-15 minute spots for deliveries. Make sure there are enforced truck parking only for restaurant and business deliveries. Car share only parking. Scooter and bike parking. etc. And yes, if I want full time parking for my car I will pay for it. It's not that expensive if that's my priority. These are generally the kind of parking configs that most city people would benefit from.
- mktmkr 7y ago1 shared car is shown to replace between 7 and 20 private cars in various deployments. Building new housing with dedicated car-share parking is a great way to go.
- kbenson 7y agoHousing may be a little harder to accomplish usefully for the people that would live there for this idea, but business would likely work well. The problem with housing (if it encompasses a large area and not just small subsets of the available area) is that some people functionally need a car for their job or life. Cutting off large amounts of housing from those that commute or those that need to make semi-regular long trips for other reasons (maybe picking up children weekly for a custody agreement, or taking care of a relative that is semi-dependent). Maybe paid dedicated parking separate from the housing and only allowed to people that live in the area (with an increase in price for a second car for a household) would suffice, as long as it was planned well. But that's the problem, poor planning (or changes over time) could cause problems again.
- mktmkr 7y agoCar shares are definitely not for driving to work but I fail to see why you can't use them to pick up your kids. Car sharing solves the problem where people can easily journey to work without a car, but they want one for other purposes like shopping.
- 7y ago
- jjcm 7y agoIt's a good thought, but until public transportation is a 1st party citizen in LA, this will just cause more problems in the long run. Busses are still seen as a method of transport for impoverished people, not for the masses. Trains and light rail simply aren't a priority for either the city nor the population. For comparison, Sydney is similar to LA in terms of density and affluence, but has 7.7 times as many people riding their rail transport[1]. LA should be focusing on creating a positive draw to public transport by increasing service, availability, and quality, rather than creating a negative pressure by decreasing parking availability. [1] 359m annual ridership in Sydney with a 4.6m population, vs 108m annual ridership in LA with a 10.1m population.
- harmmonica 7y agoYour numbers may be apples to apples if that Sydney number is the greater metro, but just a note that the City of Los Angeles is "only" 4M or so.
- gamblor956 7y agoHowever, the city of LA entirely includes several other cities within its borders, and the LA Metro area population is roughly 10-12 million... Also with respect to the rail comparisons, most of LA Metro's ridership is on the bus system, which absolutely dwarfs Sydney's total public transit ridership, even after huge drops in ridership.
- andys627 7y agoThis is not a silver bullet, but a small step in the right direction. I think it causes problems in the short run, but helps strengthen public transit in the long run.
- mixmastamyk 7y ago> rather than creating a negative pressure by decreasing parking availability. Backwards, they are talking about ending a subsidy, not reducing parking directly.
- tempsy 7y agoIt’s frustrating how few cities in the US are liveable without a car. One of the best parts of SF is that it’s so small and easy to navigate without a car. And NYC’s subway system is complete disarray. Not sure what other cities are manageable without one.
- driverdan 7y agoWhile US public transit is not good most US cities are livable without a car. You need some other form of personal transportation instead like a bike.
- showerst 7y agoIf you live in the city proper or inner ring suburbs, DC is fine without a car, especially if you can afford the occasional uber. I can't think of any others besides the 3 you mentioned that I'd want to go carless in offhand.
- harmmonica 7y agoIf you're talking about livable within the city limits (i.e., you don't live in the suburbs) then I think you'd find locals in Boston, DC and Chicago would say they can live happily without a car. I think a pretty significant chunk of folks in Philly, Portland (OR) and Seattle would probably say the same, though not to the same extent as those other ones. Not disagreeing that there are few overall, but there are a few beyond NYC and SF.
- slg 7y agoAs a resident of LA, I don't see this actually accomplishing much due to the specific market of downtown LA. Like the article mentions, basically all the new construction in that area comes in at the top of the market. Almost everyone in that socioeconomic class in LA has a car and would want a nearby place to park it. Developers therefore aren't going to build a new luxury high-rise and not provide parking for its residents. That said, we might as well remove this regulation requiring parking if the market will dictate a similar level of parking anyway. I simply think this type of change would see a greater impact in neighborhoods in which car ownership levels are lower.
- alkonaut 7y agoRemoving parking requirements for office and commercial buildings seems like a better end to start in. If you work in the city and live outside, you should be discouraged from driving, and/or be encouraged to drive only to hubs closer to the city and ride in on public transport.
- slg 7y agoIt depends on the goal. If the only goal is to reduce car usage, sure. However, the area already has a problem with housing costs and a rule like this would just cause costs to skyrocket near transit hubs. You need a more robust public transit system for that type of proposal to work without those negative consequences and LA isn't there yet.
- andys627 7y agoProviding parking is expensive - perhaps developers will create units that are more affordable if they are not required to spend the extra money to provide parking.
- briandear 7y agoParking is hardly the driver of unaffordable housing. Requiring “affordable housing” as a condition of building “market housing” is what makes housing expensive — the market units have to be priced very high to cover the loss from the below market units. It’s essentially rent control on new construction.
- jameslk 7y agoI'm not familiar with downtown LA but I haven't heard great things about public transportation in LA. Are they just trying to encourage less driving without providing any alternatives?
- mixmastamyk 7y agoDowntown has the best transport access in the entire city. There are frequent trains in every direction and long-distance thru Union Station. While not Germany-level, it is quite good. Combined with the rise of rideshare and rentals etc, large parking garages are becoming obsolete.
- throwaway542134 7y ago>Downtown has the best transport access in the entire city The only problem is that most people don't have a reason to go there. The streets are usually empty aside from the homeless encampments. The only reasons I've ever had to go to DTLA was to attend a conference and some games at the Staples Center. It's a cultural and recreational wasteland compared to the rest of the city.
- jayd16 7y ago>The only problem is that most people don't have a reason to go there. This is out of date. There's a lot more to do downtown these days.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoIndeed, that response is seemingly from twenty years ago. 90% of LA history is in downtown also. What downtown looks like today: https://urbanize.la/post/perla-condo-tower-tops-out-4th-broadway https://urbanize.la/post/perla-condo-tower-tops-out-4th-broa... Still, skid row is as bad as it ever was.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoLos Angeles is less downtown-focused than other big cities but I still don't think that's a fair representation. You can go to a hockey game or a basketball game in DTLA, and you're near stadiums for baseball, football and soccer. If you'd rather see a symphony than a game of sportsball you can listen to the LA phil at Disney Hall (and if the architecture of Disney Hall is more modern than you prefer, there's plenty of older buildings worth checking out). There's a bunch of museums if you're into that kind of thing. On the grungier side, there's Santee Alley and the fashion district if you want to get that "third world bazaar" experience without having to travel. You can get food from dozens of different cultures, even without visiting enclaves like Chinatown or Little Tokyo.
- andys627 7y agoGov'ts can do 3 things - encourage something, do nothing, or discourage something. Parking minimums encourage people to drive cars. This is LA taking a small step towards picking winners (cars...) just little bit less.
- User23 7y agoAnd 4: act to accommodate the revealed preferences of its citizens.
- andys627 7y agoI'd argue that if we prefer it so much, the free market would take care of it.
- jayd16 7y agoYou have it backwards. Less than sufficient parking discourages travel to that area. If you want the area to proper and not simply feel pain, you can't just discourage cars without an alternative. If you want people to use public transit, encourage public transit.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoNever traveled, eh?
- andys627 7y agoNot encouraging driving is not the same as discouraging driving. Eliminated parking minimums neither discourages or encourages driving.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eesmith 7y agoThe point is to tone down the encouragement to get people to use cars, which is what the old policy did. You cannot both encourage people to use cars and encourage people to not use cars - it's a waste of money.
- exabrial 7y agoAs always, I have absolute faith the free market with arrive at the correct answer. It was government regulation that created the issues in the first place.
- calvinbhai 7y agoThis is a win for Uber and Lyft. (wasn't Uber lobbying for this in all big cities?) Once it becomes the norm, Uber/Lyft can continue jacking up prices.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoIt is the private cars that are currently being subsidized. Removing a subsidy shouldn't result in blaming of the victim. They have a while to reach profitability and taxi-prices in any case. I won't blame them when they do.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoThe parking requirement makes sense. LA is a city made for cars it's not SF or NYC.