4 ms·
Given a choice it's better for the author to pay for typesetting because once they have, it can be distributed to readers for free.
by whatshisface 7y ago
Given a choice it's better for the author to pay for typesetting because once they have, it can be distributed to readers for free.
- notyourday 7y agoYup. The right question to ask is "Why would the author not do it?"
- gbrown 7y agoBecause it's a big upfront cost.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago(Actual question:) How is a standard journal-style typesetting a big upfront cost? Surely the authors do all the hard parts, make the graphs, section, maths markup, footnotes. What's left that can't be automated in almost every situation?
- notyourday 7y agoYou are seriously giving authors too much credit. The vast majority of the journal papers require enormous amount of production editing -- that's exactly why the EICs and societies sold those journals to publishers. Things that I have seen : ( wife was a production editor, I briefly helped an EIC of a society journal that was sold to a publisher ) 1. Graphs do not fit the page or space allotment - journal is uses two column format, author decided it did not apply to them. Graphs do not fit the color scheme - the author decided that the graph will be blue and the legend would be green. This is a black and white journal. Graph is a photograph of a graph, not a graph. Photo was taken on an iphone. 2. Sections went out of order. Author did not use the numbering system and numbered them by hand. Author cross referenced sections by hand, changed the ordering and did not update all of them, referring to non-existent sections. 3. Footnotes referred to non-existent papers. 4. Author included someone else's figures. Author did not obtain a permission to use them. 5. Accepted paper is written in a monospace font in WordPerfect for DOS. In 2014.
- throwaway287391 7y agoI’m not sure about other fields, but in computer science (or more specifically AI/ML) conference papers are completely free of any “professional” editors — burden is entirely on authors to handle their own editing. But I have noticed 0 disparity between conference and journal papers in terms of copy-editing quality. And my one experience of submitting to a journal matches other descriptions — the “professional” editors introduced spelling, grammatical, and even factual errors that weren’t there in the first place. (Most egregiously, they edited a grad student’s bio to award him a PhD that he didn’t have yet. WTF.)
- dmitriz 7y agoFinally something useful they did -- helped the student :)
- gamedori 7y ago1 is mostly things that the publication team is asking authors to fix by email for modern journals. Most journals will have a template for these emails, or stick them at the back of the reviewer requests. 2 Is something that I have seen caught in peer review twice, and missed once. Again, it would usually go in a batch email to the authors of issues that need to be fixed before publication. 3 is definitely something that reviewers should be catching. I don't know of any journals (especially not open access) that check references for existence. Is the problem the use of footnotes? If so, I could see this legitimately requiring some manual labor / typesetting... But most journals forbid footnotes in their submission guidelines. 4 is quite rare in research articles, and again, would be handled by requesting the authors deal with it. 5. Would be grounds for paper rejection, as it breaks the submission guidelines for most journals. In addition, it seems like an exceptionally rare case. Overall, I don't think one can justify an average of 10 hours per paper in manual labor (open access fees are always more than 1000 usd) based on these formatting issues...which issues are mostly handled by requesting fixes from the authors. Then again, maybe your wife worked in the 1 percent of journals which actually print on paper, and carefully proofread for authors. My background is mostly in medical engineering with journals up to IF10, though.
- notyourday 7y agoCosts of publishing in a journal are a part of the grant proposal(s).
- dmitriz 7y agoWhich is more headache for the applicant, fewer grants to award and less funds going to science proper.
- dmitriz 7y agoHaving published over 50 research papers, I've never experienced any value from the journal's so-called typesetting. In fact, that "value" was typically strictly less than zero with all their newly introduced typos and misleading corrections by someone who has no idea about the subject. So why are forced to accept this kind of service and how does world science benefit from it?