3 ms·
We were taught this in grad school- often simply doing little toy problems on the back of an envelope can convince you that some approach is unlikely to be frui
by dekhn 7y ago
We were taught this in grad school- often simply doing little toy problems on the back of an envelope can convince you that some approach is unlikely to be fruitful.
I thought this was a good idea, although after a while I noticed that a number of good ideas ended up getting rejected and decade+ later somebody else tried the same thing and managed to get a Science or Nature paper out of it.
- Anon84 7y agoWith this approach you’re minimizing false positives (wasting time on useless projects) not false negatives (ignoring useful ideas) so it’s not surprising that some ideas you discarded are then successfully explored by others.
- dekhn 7y agoif only we had a way to truly estimate the success of a project- many of the back-of-the-envelope calculations were based on poor assumptions (assume a spherical cow, etc)
- antisthenes 7y agoThere isn't much you can really do when it comes to exploring more useful and potentially successful ideas, because for you (doing the exploring) they will be unknown unknowns, unless you've somehow stumbled upon the domain area before.
- itronitron 7y agothat someone got a Science or Nature paper out of it doesn't necessarily make it a good, or novel, idea