7 ms·
Wow, that's shockingly low. The paper doesn't describe why -- do you have any idea what part(s) are failing so quickly? The rotors, the motors, the battery? Fo
by crazygringo 7y ago
Wow, that's shockingly low. The paper doesn't describe why -- do you have any idea what part(s) are failing so quickly? The rotors, the motors, the battery?
For commercial delivery service, it seems quite clear that we'll need either
1) "enterprise-grade" drones (like difference between consumer and enterprise SSD's),
2) reliable sensors to detect imminent failure before a flight,
and/or 3) easy replacement of failing parts.
I mean, for many hobbyists 100-200 hrs seems like a reasonable cost/benefit tradeoff... but not even close for commercial delivery services.
- sytelus 7y agoCommercial drones can push to 10^3 hrs but that's still far cry from aviation standards of 10^5 hrs. According to this nav system and fuel+actuators are two big failing components: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6165073/pdf/sensors-18-03171.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6165073/pdf/sen...
- crazygringo 7y agoThat article seems to be referring to winged UAV drones (e.g. Predator) not the quadcopter-type drones used for deliveries.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 7y agoGood catch. It is possible for quadcopter-type drones to come with four extra motors that sit opposite of the traditional four motors and props and face down with slightly different sized props and rotating the opposite way. In the case of failure of a prop in this configuration (the most common failure in my own experience with quads and octos), it is possible to program the n-copter to automatically change to flying in 7 prop mode or 6 prop mode or 5 prop mode, and so on and so forth as a redundancy feature. This could help with a not insignificant amount of crashes but obviously comes with increased costs.
- TylerE 7y agoAirplanes get regular (and quite extensive) maintenance though.
- jacquesm 7y ago> do you have any idea what part(s) are failing so quickly? The rotors, the motors, the battery? It doesn't really matter what fails, what matters is that there is no way to do a controlled descent once anything goes wrong on a loaded drone because there is no margin for error. A drone this heavy relies on the whole chain of components functioning perfectly. I'm surprised it is as good as it is given the number of parts. If it were a winged drone you'd at least have a chance to glide it to a safe spot, but a drone that is kept up by spinning props can only crash uncontrolled. There was a video of downing one in a more controlled way but the only fault it could cover was single rotor failure and even then the amount of control was very limited. These things have absolutely no business over areas occupied by people.
- hyperpallium 7y agoWhy not autorotation? https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation Is it less mass and therefore momentum in the rotor/drivechain?
- jacquesm 7y agoThat needs forward flight to work. A quad copter does not have a glide ratio high enough that it would be able to start up the rotors to spin fast enough to get some lift out of them. A quad copter is best modeled as a brick with a magic anti gravity device attached, if the anti gravity device fails it is a suspended brick and gravity will soon assert itself. A real helicopter (or an auto-gyro) is best modeled as a rotating wing, as long as the blades rotate you can control the craft to greater or lesser extent. It still won't be pretty in a proper helicopter but at least you have a chance.
- pr_nik 7y agoAdditionally, you need "collective pitch" control, i.e. the ability to angle the rotor blades for windmilling and then for hover flight right before touchdown. Multicopters just have fixed-pitch rotors and rely on differential torque/thrust for attitude control and ascend.
- donquichotte 7y ago> do you have any idea what part(s) are failing so quickly? The rotors, the motors, the battery? My bet is on the power electronic semiconductors, mostly MOSFETs, in the motor controllers. Life time of these components decreases exponentially with the temperature difference they see in the semiconductor junction, i.e. the difference between hot (current is flowing, heating the junction with a power of I^2 * R_ds_on) and cold. To make this deltaT_junction small, you need to choose big components, but at the same time you want to save weight, which is fundamentally at odds with overdimensioning everything.
- mikepurvis 7y agoThose are solid state components, though, and they exist (or can) in the downwash of the rotor, so it really shouldn't be that hard to keep them cool. I'd think the motor and rotor itself would be much more likely to be the problem.
- cr0sh 7y agoI don't know of any multi-rotor craft that incorporates the ESC (electronic speed controller) in such a way as to be cooled by the downwash of the props. Not saying there aren't any, but I haven't seen it. Most hobbyist multirotors use smaller controllers (which are essentially a PWM'd set of mosfets) zip-tied or otherwise affixed to the arms of the machine, with short connections to the motors and to the controller/and power-supply distribution board on the body. Consumer multi-rotor craft will generally have the ESCs integrated on a motherboard or daughterboard in the main body of the craft (cheaper to manufacture), well away from the prop wash and enclosed (not good for cooling). I'm not sure what commercial (or large-scale) multi-rotor craft use, but it is probably similar to the others. Again - I'm not saying it hasn't been done, or couldn't be done; in fact, it seems like a good idea. I can even envision how it could be integrated on the motor itself (board on the back with mosfets, with an extended shaft with fan for cooling the mosfets (inrunner motor), or with the fins of the mosfets in the wash of the prop, or something like that for an outrunner motor). It wouldn't surprise me if such motors don't come on the market (or maybe they already exist - I haven't looked)... Ok - well, apparently the idea isn't a new one: https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?1149319-brushless-motor-with-built-in-esc https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?1149319-brush... ...and it has been tried and sold to some success. So I imagine such motors are still available somewhere. TIL.
- taneq 7y ago> Wow, that's shockingly low. The paper doesn't describe why -- It's because many drones, even "commercial" ones, are built using hobby parts with poor QC. If you use high end components then the reliability will be up by a two orders of magnitude, as will the price. (Also as mentioned by others, multirotors and especially quadrotors have many single points of failure and so even with reliable parts the whole contraption isn't very reliable.)
- pps43 7y agoA helicopter can autorotate when its single engine quits, or continue flying when one of its multiple engines quit. Quadrocopter requires all four motors to work to remain in the air. This is a reasonable tradeoff for light hobby drones, but not for heavier drones for commercial delivery.
- mikepurvis 7y agoThis isn't quite true. Cheap drones may not have this capability, but controlled, safe landings of quadrotors with a single failed motor have been demonstrated, see this ETH Zurich video from 2014: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ek0FrCaogcs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ek0FrCaogcs Obviously there are still other single points of failure such as the battery or controller, but at this point there's no excuse for crash landing a commercial drone just because a single motor (or rotor) has failed.