7 ms·
YouTube bans 14 year old for violating hate speech guidelines
- RappingBoomer 7y agoso benevolent
- gfosco 7y agoFollowed by Patreon banning her the following day. It's getting pretty crazy how little one has to do to get deplatformed, if you've attracted an audience.
- threeseed 7y agoPretty sure that her public record had a lot to do with it: https://twitter.com/sewernugget https://twitter.com/sewernugget
- rpiguy 7y agoIt is so easy to immediately take a side here, but I have never seen her content. It is true that people are being de-platformed unfairly and I am usually against deplatforming, but others do deserve it. Regardless, she's a kid. As much as I advocate for free speech, I believe we shouldn't encourage kids to be "shock-jocks" or used to promote political agendas. It is so easy for kids to be seduced into an ideology even if just for the attention.
- TylerE 7y agoThis isn't "a little".
- panarky 7y agoIt's easy to talk in broad generalities, but let's be specific. What, exactly, do you think people should have a platform to say, but are denied by YouTube and Patreon?
- spamizbad 7y agoCan't believe you're not allowed to threaten to murder people these days. Everyone's so sensitive!
- berbec 7y agoLiberal snowflakes getting the Deep State to censor Good People™ under orders from their military-industrial complex overlords.
- hannasanarion 7y agoYeah, seriously. People are so sensitive about murder threats these days, I mean come on. Back in my day, when you threatened to send a bomb to a tv station, they put you in a prime time slot!
- avip 7y agoThe girl is platformy-challenged, you shouldn't mock her for that.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoI was deservedly banned from chatting in World of Warcraft when I was 14 because I said some stupid shit, and the things I said weren't remotely comparable to this Soph kid. Sure, I'm glad my incident didn't get written about in The Hill, but do we really need to pretend that there is controversy every time a racist crossing over from 4chan gets an account banned on social media?
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoWhy do you feel a platform should allow someone to use it to threaten the life of someone else?
- Sohcahtoa82 7y agoSerious question here. Do you really think YouTube, Patreon, reddit, and whoever else should be required to allow people who make death threats to use their platform?
- cambalache 7y agoI know it was a rhetorical question but of course not. This a pretty clear cut case, if you break the law you while you are doing an activity, you deserve to be kicked out from any platform you use to promote your work. Threatening people should be taken very seriously.She should be thankful she embodies the right demographic so authorities were very lenient.
- Sohcahtoa82 7y agoIt really wasn't intended to be rhetorical question. I was hoping the parent commenter would answer the question, because the fact that he seems upset about Soph getting deplatformed indicates that he doesn't think that death threats should be grounds for deplatforming. I'm really hoping that what actually happened is that gfosco didn't read the article and is unaware about what Soph specifically said to get her kicked off YouTube and Patreon.
- rco8786 7y agoWait. What would one have to do to deserve being deplatformed, if death threats don’t meet the bar?
- threeseed 7y agoBe curious to understand US government's role here. When a 14 year old "threatened to murder YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki" surely it crossed the line into being a child welfare problem.
- youeseh 7y agoI'm sure it can be solved by a more local level CPS department.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mmastrac 7y ago> Soph threatened to murder YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki earlier this year, which resulted in the site temporarily suspending and demonetizing her account, according to BuzzFeed. Why is this controversial in any way? She was lucky to get back on.
- throwawaywego 7y agoNot a credible threat, according to police. Also, only after she was targeted by the media (a common pattern for Youtube to take action). > “Susan, I’ve known your address since last summer. I’ve got a Luger and a mitochondrial disease. I don’t care if I live. Why should I care if you live or your children? I just called an Uber. You’ve got about seven minutes to draft up a will. … I’m coming for you, and it ain’t gonna be pretty.”
- olliej 7y agoWell obviously the media got involved - Youtube's track record of responding to content reports is pretty much non-existent, the only time they take meaningful action is when the media draws attention to it.
- fortran77 7y agoReally? The Police don't consider _that_ a credible threat? Wow!
- henryfjordan 7y agoTo be credible, the person making the threat needs to be able to act on it. If I say "I am going to shoot you right now" but am not holding a gun, that's not a credible threat. I assume the police saw a 14yo who can't take an Uber by themselves and cannot buy a gun and said "yeah, no way he could follow this one through". Edit: I'm not saying the kid shouldn't be punished, or that the law shouldn't be something else. This is just answering how that particular tweet that was being discussed was interpreted by police to not constitute a "credible threat"
- fortran77 7y ago> Soph _threatened to murder_ YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki earlier this year, which resulted in the site temporarily suspending and demonetizing her account, according to BuzzFeed. [ emphasis mine ] This goes far beyond hate speech. They should call Child Protective Services and get her home investigated.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoYawn. Teenagers gonna teenage.
- happytoexplain 7y agoIt sounds like you're saying that anything a teenager says should be dismissed as "not serious" regardless of content or context, but you haven't given much to go on.
- arkades 7y agoRight? This is basic teenage crap, with the reach and ubiquity of the internet attached.
- lytedev 7y agoI think it's foolish to attribute this kind of awful behavior to being a teenager. We can expect more from children and teenagers than the world tends to credit them.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoI don't. I remember being a teenager. There was no shortage of 14 year olds making spurious death threats and generally being all-around pricks. And here we've got somebody that wants to get CPS involved of all things. Talk about making things worse.
- AmVess 7y agoBack in my day, this type of thing would land you in juvenile detention. You wouldn't be released until you passed a psychiatric evaluation, which was no simple task. Perhaps we need to return to the days of removing very clearly troubled people from circulation until they aren't a danger to others.
- cousin_it 7y agoVideo in question https://www.bitchute.com/video/FNqiV8kL4cc/ https://www.bitchute.com/video/FNqiV8kL4cc/ I've never seen a 14 year old talking like that. Possible explanations: 1) she's a young-looking adult 2) she's a teenager with an adult scriptwriter 3) she's a deepfake/filter with a teenager's face and voice. I want to believe it's (3) because that would be the most Black Mirror thing.
- whatshisface 7y agoThe 14 year olds with popular YouTube channels are several standard deviations away from anybody you have ever met, simply because the number of teenagers striving for internet popularity dwarfs the number that anyone has met personally.
- sedeki 7y agoI think it is genuinely her too, and I honestly feel a bit scared... Society is so damn polarized today. Does there exist two different demographic groups that actually are in harmony today?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- antidaily 7y ago0.0% it's just her. It's too clever and referential to adult themes to be a kid.
- izzydata 7y agoIs it relevant who someone is if they break rules? Being 14 shouldn't exempt someone from the consequences of "violating hate speech guidelines".
- leftyted 7y agoA pole shift has occurred in the US. In the past, transgressive comedy almost exclusively came out of the left (I'm thinking Lenny Bruce, Hunter S. Thompson, John Waters, etc). The right, by comparison, was straight-laced. These days, more and more, transgressive voices are coming from the right. Soph is pretty extreme but I do see the humor in her videos. You're not obligated to laugh, but if you don't see the humor, take a step back and consider that conservatives rarely saw the humor in Bruce, Thompson, or Waters.
- happytoexplain 7y agoEven assuming for academic reasons that the situation is identical in every way, except with left-right political nouns swapped - why is the inverse version bad, requiring that people "take a step back"?
- leftyted 7y ago"Identical in every way" is strong wording that I didn't use. > why is the inverse version bad, requiring that people "take a step back"? What I'm saying is that if you don't see the humor, you're missing something. You don't have to think it's funny. You can think it's "going too far" or "in poor taste". But there is a strange brand of transgressive humor there.
- CyanBird 7y ago>What I'm saying is that if you don't see the humor, you're missing something. There's quite literally no humor on this, the Youtube headquarters have in the past already been targeted by mentally unstable people in a shooting.
- leftyted 7y ago> There's quite literally no humor on this I'm sure more than one person said this about Lenny Bruce, probably during his obscenity trial.
- aaron695 7y agoHere's the video https://www.bitchute.com/video/FNqiV8kL4cc/ https://www.bitchute.com/video/FNqiV8kL4cc/ It's very well written. Would have to be a teams work, or she's very gifted, possibly both and has enough cynicism to be seen as a parady. But if I was Russia I'd be her patreon, the cynicism is funny, but it bleeds heavily into reality. It's propaganda of some sort, or part of its machinery. (And it's clearly written to get her booted from YouTube, mission accomplished)
- avip 7y agoI, for one, am interested in what the little girl has to say
- traderjane 7y agoShe talks about how homosexuals are dangerous because of pedophilia, and that having an aversion towards homosexuals isn't the same thing homophobia; you can think something is immoral without fearing it.
- dragonwriter 7y ago“Homophobia” is a term adopted for bigotry against homosexuals, not fear of homosexuals (“-phobia” in general does not mean exclusively fear, though that's the most common single-word interpretation.) Homophobia and transphobia denote the same attitude toward gay and trans people, respectively, that misogyny denotes toward women, despite the fact that th prefix “mis-” and the suffix “-phobia” aren't exactly equivalent in range of meaning. But, yeah, that's been an argument by homophobes to argue that their homophobia isn't homophobia for decades, and even if it wasn't ignorant of the general use of tg suffix, it would still only be an argument that the word “homophobia” was a sui generis idiom rather than an obvious combination of it's etymological components (which it arguably is anyway, since “homo-” is short for “homosexual” rather than being a normal use of the prefix), rather than an actual argument against what they exhibit actually being what is denoted by the term.
- zebrahead 7y agoTheHill describes this video as "attacking LGBTQ people", but the claims made in the video are well sourced. Is stating uncomfortable facts now an "attack"? If someone made a similar video against white people (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1SrN2mBWD8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1SrN2mBWD8), would it also be framed as an "attack", or would that fall under "speaking truth to power"?
- iron0013 7y agoAm I supposed to be outraged by this ban? It sounds like it was well deserved.