4 ms·
> In the long run it's only dividends that matter. Strong disagree. I put my money into other companies because those companies create more money with that mo
by dragontamer 7y ago
> In the long run it's only dividends that matter.
Strong disagree. I put my money into other companies because those companies create more money with that money than I can.
I don't give money to companies for them to give it back to me. I give money to companies because their investment decisions are superior than my investment decisions.
Amazon can spend $5000 on new computers (and make more than $5000 back) in the long term. Better than anything I put $5000 in on. All shares are created from either the Initial Public Offering (which raised money for the company), or secondary offerings (an additional raising round after the IPO).
- H8crilA 7y agoI'm talking about data since 1870 till the present (courtesy of Robert Shiller). It shows very clearly that dividends > price action over periods of 20yrs or longer. You have an opinion against data.
- novaleaf 7y agoone could argue that the stock market of today is vastly different beast from that of 1870, or even comparing to 1970.
- H8crilA 7y agoMarkets have existed for a long time. The Dutch were trading stocks in 1600s already. It's actually more likely that it is still the same thing. http://bilalhafeez.com/the-oldest-book-ever-written-on-trading-stocks-its-330-years-old/ http://bilalhafeez.com/the-oldest-book-ever-written-on-tradi... They even had options, called "opsies".
- dragontamer 7y ago> You have an opinion against data. And when your data runs contrary to Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and tons of other points of data in today's market... I think its reasonable to question the data. Is data from 1870s still relevant today? The USA was still on gold + silver (silver standard!!), and the Fed didn't even exist yet. Case in point: maybe your data is only relevant during the times when the gold standard was still being followed (before the 70s, when Nixon finally ended the gold standard). The economy of today's market is grossly different than 1600s era Dutch traders.
- H8crilA 7y agoThere's nothing new in the markets. Tech is the new Nifty-Fifty: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nifty_Fifty https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nifty_Fifty Are those companies bad? Probably no. Will they plunge and be available at a steep discount? Quite likely.
- mcguire 7y agoSuppose you give money to a company in return for a share of stock. The company does spectacularly, becoming bigger than Amazon and Brazil, combined! (That was a joke.) The company, however, never pays a dividend. Eventually, the world changes and the company makes a few missteps, and then one day, bang! The company is bankrupt and your share is worthless. Now, you could argue that you made money when you sold the share, but the guy who bought it didn't. Without dividends, the stock market is a zero-sum game. In fact, it's the world's biggest Ponzi scheme, with money coming in from new investors being used only to pay out to past investors.
- dragontamer 7y ago> Eventually, the world changes and the company makes a few missteps, and then one day, bang! That's not how bankruptcy works. Kodak, Sears, K-Mart have proven that it (typically) takes years, maybe even decades, for a dying company to go bankrupt. > The company is bankrupt and your share is worthless. That's also not how bankruptcy works. Your factory equipment will be sold to the highest bidder, and your shareholders will be given the money that was left-over (after bondholders and suppliers are paid). > Without dividends, the stock market is a zero-sum game. Also a false assertion. The stock's price is most commonly tied to the equipment, land, and other resources a company holds. If the equipment, land, and resources "suddenly" become worthless, then yes, the company is worthless. But in practice, land, equipment, and resources have real value. And that real value, is often above-and-beyond the cash value of those resources. Tesla paid $5 Billion for the Gigafactory 1. I think it was a bad purchase, but the shareholders own the Gigafactory. I would never buy Tesla shares, because I think Tesla overpaid for their equipment, the land, and the workers at that site. Tesla was ONLY able to buy the Gigafactory 1 because a pool of investors brought together $2+ Billion in 2014 (a secondary offering). The bond market handled the rest of the debts needed to build the factory. As long as the Gigafactory 1 makes more than $5 billion over time, then Tesla will be a good buy for its shareholders and its managers. (Unfortunately, Gigafactory 1 was a bad buy for Tesla and Panasonic. But that's another topic....). Most importantly, Tesla shareholders own a stake in that factory (and every other piece of Tesla). If it weren't for Wall Street organizing things, the Gigafactory 1 would never exist. That's the power of the market: to conjure up $5 Billion out of nothing but the hopes-and-dreams of millions of investors, to hopefully make a factory that will hopefully make enough cars to be profitable. And guess what? If Tesla goes bankrupt, those investors are happy that Tesla tried. So the market is very far away from a "Zero Sum" game. Go and ask any Tesla investor if you don't believe me. The vast majority are bought into this "changing the world" story, and are willing to lose money over it.