6 ms·
I'm of the opinion that if we suppress it, it doesn't go away. When it comes back, it's much harder to control. I also firmly believe that everyone has biases
by gwbas1c 7y ago
I'm of the opinion that if we suppress it, it doesn't go away. When it comes back, it's much harder to control.
I also firmly believe that everyone has biases and inclinations that are morally wrong. The sooner we learn how to deal with the "good guys" unfair biases, the sooner we can figure out how to deal with the "bad guys" too.
- ZoidbergWill 7y agoThe already radicalised don't go away, but de-platforming does help. Sure, there are some alternatives that are harder to restrict and monitor, like if all the radicals move to private Telegram groups or the dark web or something. However all the vulnerable people at risk of being radicalised are less likely to be radicalised if they're using a similar forum to 8chan but without all the white supremacist and other hateful memes and "jokes", that obviously have radicalised a lot of people. Even if most people just scroll past them.
- shdh 7y ago> The already radicalised don't go away, but de-platforming does help. It helps prevent the on-boarding of people who can be potentially radicalized. There is also plenty of astroturfing also going on in this message boards by entities that want to cause chaos.
- hashmap 7y ago> I'm of the opinion that if we suppress it, it doesn't go away. When it comes back, it's much harder to control. The available evidence says the opposite is true. http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf The way to deal with the "bad guys" is for private businesses to not give them a platform to spew their hate from. And it's up to us to pressure these private businesses to do that.
- davesmith1983 7y agoThe "bad guys" just went somewhere else. This doesn't fix the problem it just pushed the problem away from reddit. > And it's up to us to pressure these private businesses to do that. No it isn't. I am fed up of something I like being ruined by moral busy bodies such as yourself. My friend and I like the "edgy" jokes because we work in environments where you have to be political correct and I need to let off some steam. 8chan isn't the problem. The problem is that large portions of the population aren't engaged in society at large. The is a huge problem with loneliness, suicide and general lack of meaning to life. Censorship and harassing companies that run image board won't fix the problem. All you will do it hide it.
- jredwards 7y ago> The problem is that large portions of the population aren't engaged in society at large. The is a huge problem with loneliness, suicide and general lack of meaning to life. Do you think that this is the root cause of violent islamic extremists as well?
- davesmith1983 7y agoWith extremists that grew up in the west, possibly. I did work with some Somali guys (they weren't extremists) but a few of them said they didn't feel British and they didn't feel Somalian. So there is a schism there, I've felt the same schism as someone that is essentially a nomad these days I don't belong anywhere. Extremists that grow up in the Middle-East. No idea I haven't spent a lot of time in the Middle-East (only Israel).
- gwbas1c 7y ago> Censorship and harassing companies that run image board won't fix the problem. All you will do it hide it. And it will come back much worse, and you won't know how to recognize it or fight it. > My friend and I like the "edgy" jokes Liberals like to make off-color jokes too, they're just in denial about it.
- davesmith1983 7y ago
- piti166 7y agoThe study explicitly states, that the problem went away for reddit, but this does not proof that the hate went away, it maybe just left reddit for another platform.
- gwbas1c 7y agoThat's not suppression. That's reddit taking care of its own platform. There's a difference between policing your own corner of the internet; versus policing the entire internet.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoSure but I interpreted the claim being made to be about hate existing anywhere. Reddit can do what they want, but we can argue whether it's good for society or not, even if it's clearly good for reddit.
- yters 7y agoIt won't go away, but censorship will probably reduce the incidence to violence.
- RandomTisk 7y agoAll that does is ensure racists and violent people only get to speak in echo chambers.
- yters 7y agoThen at least they isolate themselves, and have less ability to radicalize anyone besides the true believers. A number of isolated extremist cells are probably also easier to deal with for law enforcement, and these weird beliefs will stand out more to others in a social setting if they become rare. Also, it seems like the group egging them on motivates these shooters. Tragically seems related to internet likes. So, by deflating the social network surrounding these ideas, there will be less social motivation to carry out such horrible actions. And, finally, people have a social concept of truth, and if such ideas are considered to only be fringe crazy ideas instead of consistent with mainstream Darwinian theory, then people will be less likely to believe such ideas are true and less likely to act on them. As it is, social Darwinism seems to be one of those unpleasant truths due to the social weight given to the idea. Such social weight needs to be eradicated.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago> A number of isolated extremist cells are probably also easier to deal with for law enforcement, // I'd expect stuff done in the open on 'chan sites to be much easier to monitor than stuff done in private encrypted channels elsewhere. >Also, it seems like the group egging them on motivates these shooters. // In private where all the voices coalesce around a single ideology then the effect (Echo Chamber) makes it appear that _everyone_ [who matters] shares that ideal. Moreover, it's easier to "other" the out group, make them in to a caricature; dehumanise them. (See 2-party political systems!) Cults don't operate in the open, forcing people underground creates a sort of cultist environment. Contact with genuine people who are considered part of the out-group appears to be highly effective in breaking down these sorts of barriers .. that can happen on generalist sites but will never happen in closed ideology-bad groups. It seems to me that shutting down places like 8chan is going to lead to _more_ radicalised groups (that are more extremely radicalised), though they may be smaller groups and a smaller overall population. I think bigger, less cohesive, in-the-open groups are easier to monitor and take action against when necessary. I wonder if there are any useful models that can give actionable input to this question.
- jklinger410 7y agoMany of these outlets are just honeypots, anyway. Which is why they are so readily available. TOR and 8ch are both good examples of this.
- shdh 7y ago> honeypots Assuming this is true, plenty of people still slip through the cracks