5 ms·
Does Facebook allow it? Unless you have rights holders permissions then the social links at the bottom of that article look like copyright and probably tradema
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
Does Facebook allow it?
Unless you have rights holders permissions then the social links at the bottom of that article look like copyright and probably trademark infringements. (I'm not saying that's a good thing, just how it appears.)
- buboard 7y agoSure they allow it. The icons are also included in FontAwesome for easier use.
- kordlessagain 7y ago> Does Facebook allow it? Who cares? Facebook is a zero sum game at this point for advertisers/content creators. Facebook stacking the odds like a casino does chuck-a-luck. There's only them winning here, nobody else.
- hugi 7y agoBlocking facebook tracking, meaning comments/like buttons and the like has vastly improved my browsing experience.
- cat199 7y agoperhaps, but if so, they win more when they sue you and you lose...
- downandout 7y agoWho cares? The site owner that might be sued by Facebook for copyright infringement, for starters.
- Quenty 7y agoAren’t logos fair use? Maybe a like button might be sueable, but a logo should be fine, right?
- megous 7y agoAnd they will be suing for what? For attempting to send more people to facebook? What's the damage? Facebook has no right to have their arbitrary code on other people's websites. So they can't force any specific way to show their button. From the end user's perspective it's all the same.
- downandout 7y agoFacebook could reasonably argue that by bypassing their established use policies for the like button, you are depriving them of value - in this case the value of the data that their JavaScript collects and sends back to them, and that you (the site owner) are being unjustly enriched through the use of their copyrighted image(s) on your site. Except in cases of fair use, which isn’t nearly as broad as people think, the use of other parties’ images is subject to whatever licensing restrictions they choose to put on them. You can choose not to display their images if you do not accept those terms.
- saagarjha 7y agoI feel like trying to sue someone for linking to Facebook would go down extremely poorly.
- Mirioron 7y agoEspecially when it's done this way for privacy considerations.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThe reason sites want to have Like buttons is because they perceive value in that for the site. A C&D would be enough to bring anyone in to alignment that didn't have a wish for a very expensive day trip to court.
- downandout 7y agoAren’t logos fair use? That’s a very broad question. For one thing, fair use is a concept only in US law. Other countries may have their own versions of it, but all of them have their own unique limits. Even under the US version, it is not at all clear that it would fall under fair use. If I start making t-shirts with the Facebook logo on them, is that fair use? No, it isn’t. Is there much difference between that and putting it on a website that I make money from? The right jury would say no.
- jraph 7y agoI'd bet it falls under fair use: https://www.inta.org/TrademarkBasics/FactSheets/Pages/Fair-Use-of-TrademarksNL.aspx https://www.inta.org/TrademarkBasics/FactSheets/Pages/Fair-U... By the way, this website does exactly that.
- jhall1468 7y agoFair use is a defense. You, at best, get sued, have to pay a ton of money in attorneys fees, on the chance that you "bet" it's going to work. Tough sell.
- Zak 7y agoYes. https://en.facebookbrand.com/ https://en.facebookbrand.com/
- weinzierl 7y agoIt's against Facebook's terms: > 8. You must not use or make derivative use of Facebook icons, or use terms for Facebook features and functionality, if such use could confuse users into thinking that the reference is to Facebook features or functionality. We know that Facebook uses that paragraph against alternative like buttons. Many years ago German computer magazine publisher Heise created a version of the like button that works like this: The button is initially greyed out and has to be activated by a slide button to be used. Communication with Facebook's servers starts only when the button is activated. After threats from Facebook Heise had to change the look of the initial button so that is has none of the Facebook branding. Only the dynamically loaded original Facebook button looks like Facebook like button. [1] Link to the original alternative like button project in German is [2]. An fork with English documentation is [3]. EDIT: Their current branding guidelines for the "thumb icon" [4] say: > Do link the Thumb Icon directly to your Page on Facebook when using the Thumb Icon online. So a thumb icon linking to your page should be OK. EDIT 2: The branding guideline also says: > Don't use an outlined thumb with the cuff detached. So you can use the "Thumb Icon" but not in a way that replicates the current original Facebook like button because that one is outlined and has the cuff detached. BTW this is exactly what Privacy Badger does: It replaces the original Facebook Like Button (cuff detached) with the thumb icon from the official assets (cuff connected). [1] https://www.zdnet.com/article/german-website-creates-two-click-like-button-facebook-not-amused/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/german-website-creates-two-cli... [2] https://www.heise.de/extras/socialshareprivacy/ https://www.heise.de/extras/socialshareprivacy/ [3] https://github.com/panzi/SocialSharePrivacy https://github.com/panzi/SocialSharePrivacy [4] https://en.facebookbrand.com/assets/thumb-icon/?audience=landing https://en.facebookbrand.com/assets/thumb-icon/?audience=lan...
- thaumasiotes 7y ago>> 8. You must not use or make derivative use of Facebook icons, or use terms for Facebook features and functionality, if such use could confuse users into thinking that the reference is to Facebook features or functionality. > We know that Facebook uses that paragraph against alternative like buttons. Did you quote the wrong section? That term can't really apply to alternative "like us on Facebook" buttons, because such a button can't confuse users into thinking it refers to Facebook features or functionality, because it actually does refer to Facebook features and functionality.