7 ms·
Desalination is cheap in day to day terms, it’s the scale of water we use that’s the issue. Sure, we can get ~1,000 gallons of drinking water for 3$ via desali
by Retric 7y ago
Desalination is cheap in day to day terms, it’s the scale of water we use that’s the issue.
Sure, we can get ~1,000 gallons of drinking water for 3$ via desalination. That works out to a monthly water bill increase of ~45$ for a family of 5. Unfortunately, crops need incredible amounts of water. So, growing corn etc with desalination would case food prices to ~quadruple.
- riffraff 7y agoIs drip-based watering used at scale?
- BubRoss 7y agoAt what scale?
- riffraff 7y agoLarge commercial monocultures, rather than personal vegetable gardens
- JosephHatfield 7y agoDrip irrigation is heavily relied on by commercial farms in Israel
- mythrwy 7y agoIt is. t-tape for instance is widely used commercially for irrigation of high value horticultural crops like strawberries, tomatoes, peppers etc. also drip systems (with individual emitters, not t-tape) are used commercially in many tree crops (citrus etc). https://rivulis.com/product/drip-tapes-drip-lines/t-tape-drip-tape/ https://rivulis.com/product/drip-tapes-drip-lines/t-tape-dri... However for agronomic crops (like corn, wheat, soybeans, alfalfa etc), which occur in mass plantings I'm not aware of any drip applications. Certainly at minimum if drip is used for these crops, it is extremely rare and probably not practical.
- amluto 7y agoWhy do you think that the cost is an increase? I pay quite a bit more than $3/kgal, and a large fraction of that goes toward funding the SFPUC’s massive infrastructure for bringing Hetch Hetchy water to the Peninsula. A desalination plant would be located on the coast or on the bay and would not require this infrastructure. As far as I’m concerned, the problem is the capital cost of the plant and the plumbing to safely suck in saltwater and discharge brine and has essentially nothing to do with electricity. The situation isn’t helped by the fact that, in average and wet years, demand for desalinated water would be nil, since the Hetch Hetchy infrastructure already exists.
- Retric 7y agoSewage and distribution is not included in these costs. Current systems get water for almost nothing it’s mostly distribution and sewage systems that you’re currently paying for. As to why this is, a single pipe carrying 1,000x as much water costs no where near 1,000x much per foot. Each home might only need 1/10,000,000 the water, but it’s got to be built for peak demand not average useage. On top of this, people don’t live at sea level, so you need to pump that sea water up before you can use it. PS: Not to mention most distribution systems leak significantly, that 3$ assumes 100% efficiency at 50% it’s more like 6$.
- amluto 7y agoNone of this is at all relevant to my point. SFPUC charges over $4/ccf for wholesale water. This does not include distribution costs, and this is paid regardless of whether the water is sold, leaks, or is used for firefighting. If SFPUC’s wholesale customers purchased desalinated water and managed to escape their SFPUC contracts, they would eliminate this expense. edit: http://bawsca.org/water/rates/wholesale http://bawsca.org/water/rates/wholesale
- Retric 7y agoThat’s not exclusive price just per gallon of water. https://sfwater.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=7742 https://sfwater.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=774... Wholesale untreated water is 1.02$ per 1,000 gallons. Page 16: ( 0.76 per 748 Gallons delivered). Plus a fixed fee for the size of the pipe (22.67$ for a one inch pipe.)
- newyankee 7y agoAlso transportation costs wherein desalinated water will mostly have to be pumped upstream to places where crops are grown
- amelius 7y agoSince seaweed can grow on salt water, can we perhaps engineer other crops to do the same?
- inetknght 7y agoThat sounds like a recipe to completely destroy the land, for _any_ other crops, on which saltwater crops are farmed.
- tobr 7y agoAssuming you would use salt water on existing land, but wouldn’t it open up for growing crops in new places, on/close to seawater?
- inetknght 7y agoIf you want to grow crops on the sands of the beach, maybe. Otherwise you're poisoning whatever land you're using.
- jayventura 7y agoEven if we aren't irrigating crops directly with seawater, we may have to engineer crops to thrive on high saline irrigation anyways, as there is seawater leeching into aquifers in many agricultural centers around the world, including coastal California. As sea levels rise, we should expect this to be a larger problem and plan for it.
- Retric 7y agoThat’s not feasible over time. Evaporation increases the salt content of any irrigated soil over time. Directly using sea water would slowly cover your soil with a thick layer of salt. To get around this you would need to keep the area underwater and slowly replace your water with sea water. But, at that point you’re better off just farming the ocean which already covers the majority of the earth.
- lostlogin 7y ago> Unfortunately, crops need incredible amounts of water. So, growing corn etc with desalination would case food prices to ~quadruple. Raising crops and live stock on deserts or other marginal farmland is a huge part of this.
- jdavis703 7y agoIn California we grow water thirsty crops like rice and almonds. By substituting out for less water intense agriculture such price shocks could be reduced. There's also the whole issue of producing animal feed, which is inherently less efficient than just having humans eat the feed directly.
- megaremote 7y agoRice doesn't need much water. It is just easier to grow it like that.