21 ms·
Slightly off topic - has anyone else noticed that in the last couple years Google results have just become....crap? Like, as a programmer I'm used to googling a
by gambiting 7y ago
Slightly off topic - has anyone else noticed that in the last couple years Google results have just become....crap? Like, as a programmer I'm used to googling all sorts of things, but lately it's almost useless. Like, my recent fail was searching for "<class name> C# programming" and......the entire first page had both the class name and C# crossed out and was showing me generic results for programming. Top result was some website offering courses in programming. What the shit Google. I personally think it's the rise of devices like Google Home that's to blame - Google tries to reduce every search query into something that can yield a short snippet that can be read back to you - so it's very aggressive towards highly technical queries that it used to be so good at.
- adjkant 7y agoAnecdotally 100% experiencing this almost what feels like daily.
- crummy 7y agoThat's my biggest frustration, when I search for "X Y" and they return me results without "Y" at all, and even call that out in the results. I end up having to put everything in double quotes just to get results that I'd expect.
- mort96 7y ago"I" "miss" "the" "times" "when" "I" "didn't" "have" "to" "type" "like" "this".
- DanBC 7y agoI also find that annoying. I wonder if it started because Google favour "fresh" content, and so people keep changing the content of their pages and Google keeps that page even when Y has been removed. Here's MattCutts from 10 years ago saying this is sometimes useful: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=902999#904784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=902999#904784 > Your "Red Room" query is hard in a couple ways. First, it looks like that root page used to have the words on the page: "The Red Room Doors open 6pm $18 Pre-Booked" And it's also tough because it looks like the name changed to the "2nd Degree Bar & Grill" at some point. The fact that you can type [red room] and get a suggestion for [red room st. lucia] is actually pretty helpful in my book because it leads you to the answer that the name changed.
- netsharc 7y agoCan't believe how dumb it is. Imagine a surgeon asking an assistant for a specific type of scalpel, and that assistant bringing an assortment of scalpels.. "I specifically specified X scalpel, god damn it!".
- Lammy 7y agoThe turning point for me was five years ago when they dropped the "Discussions" filter that would search mailing lists and forums. It was amazing for obscure technical and programming issues. Here's an article about it from the time: https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-filters-gone-17993.html https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-filters-gone-1799...
- arpa 7y agoIt has been becoming crap a long time now. In the past few years i just need to include, well, everything in quotes just to get somewhat relevant results instead of very generic ones. For me it began with their removal of the + search operator (to boost google+ organic traffic from google). Also removal of boolean operators. Also very, very aggressive typo fixing (i meant "Brose Wollis" not "Bruce Wills" god damn it). I think that google home is just the latest thing that furthers googles' exclusive catering to the lowest common denominator - the people who use google as DNS and fail to do even that. I guess there's not that much of ad revenue from power users.
- DanBC 7y ago> For me it began with their removal of the + search operator (to boost google+ organic traffic from google). Google say they removed it because most searches that included a plus operator were using it wrong. https://search.googleblog.com/2011/11/search-using-your-terms-verbatim.html https://search.googleblog.com/2011/11/search-using-your-term... > In most cases, Google’s algorithms make things better for our users - but in some rare cases, we don’t find what you were looking for. In the past, we provided users with the “+” operator to help you search for specific terms. However, we found that users typed the “+” operator in less than half a percent of all searches, and two thirds of the time, it was used incorrectly. A couple of weeks ago we removed the “+” operator, encouraging the use of the double quotes, which are more likely to be used correctly. I'd be intersted to know how often the "quotes" are used correctly.
- rightbyte 7y ago0,5% of the queries used "+" so they removed it? Feels like a dogmatic "data driven" UX change for the sake of change. The interesting number would be how much it was used when the first queries failed and gave to much answers.
- dTal 7y ago"We removed the seatbelts because we found they were used in less than 0.5% of car journeys."
- kristopolous 7y agoThey seemed to have abandoned the technical user fanbase around 2012 and are now just openly hostile towards them. Especially on mobile, making it challenging to edit URLs on their latest chrome browser. UX consistency has gone out the window for weird things like like swapping around the tab ordering for searches (check out chicago, chicagos and chicago's here: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cm0C1o8VYAgLv2O?format=png https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cm0C1o8VYAgLv2O?format=png) Other things like not providing custom date ranges on mobile search are just utterly baffling. Booleans are gone, ranges are gone, and it ignores most of the words I put in. I honestly think alta vista results circa 1997 were better than what I'm getting these days. In fact, they most certainly were. They've also abandoned their namesake "googol" ... they don't seem to care about http, newsgroups or many other things. They should probably rename themselves to "Around300orso" Google ceased providing functional tools for technical people a while ago. There's some decent open space for another firm to come along (like DDG or perhaps the Microsoft Renaissance) and just snatch the technical user, create compelling products for just that, and own it. I'd even pay probably $250/yr or so for such a no-bullshit resource stack - a high quality searchable answers-oriented quick-to-use, quick-to-read technical reference without a bunch of wrong information or concrete answers buried in pages of theory. Heck, I'd probably consider dropping $2,000, that sounds amazing.
- taneq 7y agoHave you tried just using DDG? I’ve been using it for years and it’s about as good now (for my searches) as Google used to be.
- kristopolous 7y agoI should do it more. Maybe exclusively for a week and see how it goes. I've actually run into Gabriel a few times online and had a bit of conversation with him. Nice guy. Can't really say I've chatted it up with Eric Schmidt...
- iforgotpassword 7y agoOnce I internalized "just add !g if the results suck" using ddg became practical for me. And I don't know if it's me or ddg actually improves over time but I feel like I'm doing it less and less. Sometimes Google seems to be better at guessing the context especially if you search for C and some other term that has a bunch of different meanings.
- kev009 7y agoI am an amateur computer historian, and I can confirm it went from good to shit. For instance, I run an archive at ps-2.kev009.com and there is an oldskool cgi search on my site (Xapian Omega). If you search IBM P/Ns or FRUs on G, versus on my site (for stuff my archive covers), you can see it first hand. My search is exhaustive and it is readily apparent G is not. I don't recall that always being the case, G started to penalize old content, http content, and all kinds of other stuff to the point of oblivion. This makes me sad, because I will often have very exact queries like a part number and there is content out there on the internet that I cannot locate with search.
- Avamander 7y agoI'd love Google to separate "fresh" and "old" into two different search engines. When using a new framework or a version of a language or when searching for news I don't want old results. However, when searching for a part number, old documentation, information about a person I do want old information. Right now it just seems google purges the old instead of building two indexes.
- cameronbrown 7y agoIt's better UX to make it a ranking signal from your query or the tools button.
- tus88 7y agoActually this is a well known change to significant term relevancy. You need to double quote words to force inclusion in results. I'm not saying it was a good change.
- Liron 7y agoIt’s on-topic for my other tweet: https://twitter.com/liron/status/1137729277359734786 https://twitter.com/liron/status/1137729277359734786
- larkeith 7y agoDon't forget about the massive amnesia Google has - try searching for anything over a few years old. And gods help you if you are looking for something both old and by keyword, because Google sure won't. Unfortunately, DDG has a lot of the same issues - which is a shame, as if they just used Google's algorithm of a decade ago I'd switch in a heartbeat.
- AmVess 7y agoI switched to DDG a while ago, and sometimes hit Google, usually with poor results. Aside from getting no results, I'm getting results that have little or nothing to do with what I was looking for. At first, I thought my search skills had evaporated, but I realized Google has become little more than a digital flea market. Even Yandex is better in many regards than Google.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- afandian 7y agoOne of the reasons I go to Google is I'm trying to answer a question where I know the subject area but not the answer to the specific question. So I'm asking for a combination of general concepts and a specific thing. Entirely fictional example: "hacker news comment bold" And seemingly every time, the specific thing is crossed out. At that point Google search is worse than useless. I have a few hypotheses: 1) They are trying to turn it into a general directory in their continued war on DNS. 2) The web has got so big that their technology just isn't good enough anymore. 3) The users they care about are no longer people (such as technical or, per sibling comment, academic) who are trying to find specific information. They prefer to focus on mass-market. Our strongest defence as consumers is to resist the further slide into monopoly.
- iforgotpassword 7y ago> 3) The users they care about are no longer people (such as technical or, per sibling comment, academic) who are trying to find specific information. They prefer to focus on mass-market. This is the only explanation that makes sense. The vast majority of people probably enter questions and queries in natural language so a purely keyword based search is out the window. Why a list of stop words wouldn't cover that I don't know, but let's just assume it doesn't. The second point is that most people also probably hardly ever look for precise information but ask ambiguous stuff that's just hard to properly answer with traditional approaches. So my guess is that at some point they realized that most queries are of that kind, then shortly discussed keeping two search engines in parallel and finally went with "screw those stupid devs, we're freaking Google!"
- Mauricio_ 7y agoCan you put a comment in bold in hacker news?
- afandian 7y agoIn the fictitious story, I never found out!
- KeithBrink 7y agoHave you tried using verbatim mode? I have that as my default search mode in Firefox, and it always searches for your exact phrase, spelling mistakes and all. Still has its problems, but better than the default search mode.
- gambiting 7y agoNo, I had no idea this was a thing. Will have to try it out.
- lostlogin 7y agoI particularly love it when the results are terrible, and then you notice that below them it say something like “include <search term>?”. Why not just search for what I typed? It has gone backwards.
- msclrhd 7y agoI get this a lot when searching for exception messages, or for information on how to implement something. It is getting increasingly harder to find the signal in the noise.
- fxtentacle 7y agoTo me, it looks like they introduced bloom filters to pre-filter their indexing. Basically, they run an offline job to create a list of the top 1 mio search keywords and hash them into a compact bitfield. That one is sent to all the crawlers, who will then only index the keywords that have hashes matching the bitfield. It's a standard way to reduce the amount of data that you need to process, and since search keyword revenue is likely exponentially distributed, they would lose almost no revenue by cutting off the 1mio +1th keyword, but greatly reduce their costs. As for the sentence search, it appears to me that they are using stemmed shingles. For that, you reduce words to their base form (houses -> house) and then you chop the page down into every 3-pair of words and hash those. The hashed number for 3 words is then called one shingle. Again, that's a common technique for content similarity detection, so Google kind of has to do that anyway to spot verbatim copycats. One can then also use this for sentence search by searching for all the shingles in the search query, but that introduces ambiguity. For example "cats singing in front of the house" would likely have the same shingles as "cat sang about front before houses", as only "cat sing front house" are being indexed. The issue here is that "front" can be used both in a positional way, as well as for a military formation. To me, both of these look like side-effects of them reducing operational costs. I mean, who would bid marketing dollars on "ISpatialAudioClient::GetMaxDynamicObjectCount" ? Given that you will likely tolerate 2-3 complete search failures before trying Bing, the business value of completing such a query correctly is very close to 0. Microsoft, on the other hand, has a stronger interest in people finding MS APIs, which is why you will find this result on Bing https://audiophilestyle.com/forums/topic/55776-software-to-show-the-details-of-the-audio-being-played/ https://audiophilestyle.com/forums/topic/55776-software-to-s... but not on Google.
- mda 7y agoYour link is the 3rd result in Google.
- mda 7y agoI tried your search, all results are about C# classes, generics etc.
- gambiting 7y agoThat's the other thing - I've seen it being completely useless for me and then my coworker does the same search and it's fine for him, or vice versa. I imagine Google builds a profile of what it thinks you'd like to see and modifies your search query accordingly.
- mda 7y agoFor this example in incognito mode without me logged in, results are similar, no problems. It is normal that it for changes results depending on user profile. Do you have other examples?
- stereolambda 7y agoIt would seem obvious to me that when I search for "<general term> <specific term>", I'm more strongly interested in the <specific term> (crudely measured in page count where it appears). Modern search engines seem to jump on an opportunity to show me top mass market results for the <general term> ("programming" in the parent's case) and often throw away the <specific term> altogether. I genuinely wonder who would want that.
- jasonvorhe 7y agoNo, the results have been consistently great. Whenever I see someone using DDG as a default they always turn to Google for more complex queries. It might be that Google hat lost focus of a few search niches where results used to be better.
- brynjolf 7y agoI have to put everything in quotation makes now or it gives me a result loosely related to the specific thing I wanted. It takes me like four searches to actually get the result I wanted. Drives me nuts.