9 ms·
TV networks vowed to cut back on commercials but stuffed in more
- Johnny555 7y agoToo many commercials probably isn’t the main reason people cancel their cable-TV service, he said. “But it’s definitely in the top five.” It's not the top reason I switched to Netflix (and now a couple other streaming services), but it's the top reason that keeps me from going back. When I travel and try to watch TV in a hotel, the commercials make it unbearable, I'll burn data from my cell phone before I'd try to watch anything on TV. I'm not sure if the commercials have really gotten worse or if I've just lost my tolerance for them. When I moved and signed up for cable internet (sadly comcast was my only choice) they offered a year of free basic cable, I declined since I knew I wouldn't watch it.
- rectang 7y ago> I'm not sure if the commercials have really gotten worse or if I've just lost my tolerance for them. In the same way that processed food has gotten tastier, commercials have gotten more attention grabbing. Whether that's "worse" or "better" depends on your perspective, but it's the result of a competitive marketplace.
- ghettoimp 7y agoYes. I'm definitely way less tolerant of them, now that I'm used to commercial-free TV.
- yial 7y agoI have Comcast now as well, as they are the only provider to offer (barely) functional speeds where I am. For my “promo” price I had to get cable. I simply convinced them to not send me the cable box.
- tantalor 7y agoGood luck reminding them of that when they ask for the box back later.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI hate that part of what I'm paying for in hotels is the damn TV. TVs in hotel rooms have become completely pointless, just like telephones did 20 years ago. Like you, if I want TV I'll use my cell connection or the hotel's wifi to watch Netflix. Hotel rooms without TVs don't seem to exist in the US, but if they did, I'd make it a point to stay there.
- losteric 7y agoPack an HDMI cable? I usually stream Netflix or play video games on those TVs
- yesco 7y agoA surprising amount of hotel TVs don't have a working HDMI port (disabled via firmware lock). Apparently it's intended to work as an anti-theft mechanism, but personally it just makes me hate the hotel.
- dannyw 7y agoI’d love a hotel TV if it has a Chromecast.
- wiseleo 7y agoNew TV deployments at Extended Stay America include Chromecast. I am deploying them now. :)
- scarface74 7y agoExtended stay hotels usually don’t have locked down HDMI ports. We stayed in one for months when we were in between our lease being up and waiting for our house to be built.
- AnssiH 7y agoSome do, e.g. I visited Omena Hotels (https://www.omenahotels.com/en/ https://www.omenahotels.com/en/) a couple of times last year and the rooms had a TV with Chromecast (and Miracast).
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s not just the commercials. Too many hotel TVs are horrible calibrated. Especially the LGs. They all have the soap opera effect and no way to turn it off without Googling trying to find the right Konami code. Luckily I have unlimited data on both my phone and iPad.
- mc32 7y agoI’d be okay if they created a cartel and governed max minutes per hour on ads. Say ten. Make up the difference with pricing. Or just let them implode upon themselves.
- mschuster91 7y agoThe EU actually has a directive limiting ad air time, however it was weakened 3 years ago: https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/it-medien/fernsehen-eu-erlaubt-mehr-werbung-im-tv/13621232.html?ticket=ST-1903397-EMQ97f2OvepsdSoC3DVF-ap6 https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/it-medien/fernsehen...
- seibelj 7y agoThe majority of people who still have cable like it because, 1) They are not capable or wanting to learn about streaming and the new tech, 2) Enjoy the passive background comfort of TV, which requires no additional effort to consume. Both of these will allow increased commercials with no reduction in viewership. If you were going to cut the cord you would have done it already.
- Finnucane 7y agoOr they DVR everything and fast forward through the commercials.
- MBCook 7y agoThat seems a rather insulting take on people.
- ghettoimp 7y agoHave you met many people? :)
- TylerE 7y ago3) Cable internet is the only option for high speed, and the way they price it, the TV is almost or actually "free" once you pay out the nose for internet.
- noitsnot 7y agoTake a look at AT&T subscriber losses last quarter if you think people have decided one way or the other and are done cutting the cord. The two points are a pretty odd choice and I would say increasing cost is at the top of the list.
- dredmorbius 7y agoSource?
- noitsnot 7y ago
- MRD85 7y agoWhen I was young I remember pay TV being marketed in Australia as "TV with no ads". It's slowly shifted to a premium content with ads model that I find hard to justify when I have access to ad free online services. As a parent this is doubly so. I know everything my children watch and I don't want them exposed to excessive advertising. I also don't let them watch content on YouTube that has excessive advertising in the show itself. I'll gladly pay money for ad free content that is designed to both entertain and educate.
- aussiegeek 7y agoWhen pay TV first came here, part of the deal was they weren't allowed to show ads for a certain amount of time. I remember 'ads' for other TV shows like the ABC does, but that was it. I have no idea why someone in Australia would have Foxtel now if they don't watch sport
- justinjlynn 7y agoIt's very uncommon.
- cameronbrown 7y agoA potential downside here is that kids may be less well equipped to deal with commercial manipulation when they grow up.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoLike believing esports are sports.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoOur DirecTV subscription in the late 90's was specifically catered to people who didn't want ads. Then some time later they started advertising and adding a bunch of nonsense channels. This was back when the history channel was actually about history, discovery was about animals and amc about Western movies.
- bradleyankrom 7y ago> AT&T, which bought Turner parent Time Warner Inc. last year, has said the $85-billion deal will ultimately lead to fewer commercials. The company expects to harvest valuable viewer data that leads to higher ad rates. Uh, no thanks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sizzzzlerz 7y agoToo many commercials is like over-prescribing anti-biotics. Pretty soon, they don't work anymore. In my watching habits (I don't have a DVR), when the show I'm watchings breaks, my finger is on the remote immediately to jump to the next channel. If that is in commercial, its on to the next. If everything is in commercial (a surprisingly common situation), I'm back on the original station with the auto muted and I'm browsing the net on my iPad or reading a page or two in the book or magazine I have next to me. Or I go take a pee. Or clean some dishes in the kitchen. Anything but watch the frickin' commercial.
- RandomTisk 7y agoHaven't had cable TV for at least 10 years now and I can't stand watching most shows at other people's houses who still sit through all the car/truck, pill and insurance commercials. I literally feel dumber having watched a few in a row. I really believe there is a science to be discovered there, like slight or temporary brain damage occurring because of commercials. They're so fake/plastic and I feel like I'm being manipulated through some kind of meme the advertiser is trying to push through repetition instead of on the product's merit. Edit: What I mean is, nobody acts in real life like they do in commercials. I feel dumber watching people behave that way. I get it's supposed to be persuasive but something about modern commercials just irks me to no end.
- robocat 7y agoFor a long time I only rarely saw TV with commercials, usually at friends. I actually enjoy seeing new commercials, and so long as I only watched TV at friends a couple of times a year, I found it enjoyable.
- jdironman 7y agoThat just proves his point that less is more. Which I believe to be true. It's about strategy and not saturation. But the problem I guess is that they cannot realistically follow each individual so saturating all networks / platforms is the only way they see viable.
- doh 7y agoBarry Diller said something along the lines, that similarly to smoking, increasingly, only poor people watch commercials. The rest pays premium to get rid of them. Considering how strongly Netflix fought against the analysts prediction that they will have to run ads, I'm quite curious where the advertisers will go once the cable is "gone".
- asdff 7y agoYoutube is getting absurd these days with ads.
- doh 7y agoI think it will get much worse. There is around $80B worth of advertisement locked in in the cable TV just in US. This all will come eventually to online and large portion to UGC platforms supporting video, so YouTube, FB, Twitter, ... Maybe more people will start paying for premium version if available (like YouTube Red).
- Ambele 7y agoYoutube is free though unlike Prime and Netflix.
- jedberg 7y agoImagine a world in which a TV station agreed not to show any commercials, but in exchange would not pay the show's creators, and in fact would charge them for distribution. The shows would then be able to run their own ads, at whatever interval they wanted, with whatever advertisers they wanted, or they could make all their money through "native advertising" (product placement). The networks could even facilitate the ad buys. This feels like a better and more workable model. It's like how websites work, where they get to chose how many ad boxes and where those ad boxes go, and then use a network to facilitate the transaction. And then a toy company could make a cartoon and show it ad free on Saturday morning as a marketing expense like back in the 80s!
- gresrun 7y agoSo, I’m pretty sure you just described YouTube’s model.
- jedberg 7y agoDoes YouTube let you choose how much monetization and when? I haven’t published there in a long time. But it seems like the creators don’t have a choice.
- grandmczeb 7y agoThe creator chooses whether to enable ads and what formats can run. If the video is longer than 10 minutes, they can also manually place mid-roll ads. https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/94522 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/94522 https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/ad-types#strategies-zippy-link-2 https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/ad-types#stra...
- jdietrich 7y agoAlso, many creators opt for sponsorship instead of (or in addition to) YouTube's own ads - you usually get higher CPMs and you're less subject to the whims of the algorithm.
- aftbit 7y ago>Turner’s commercial load rose 2.4% last quarter to more than 12 minutes per hour, according to Nathanson. A spokesman for the broadcaster said the increase reflected higher ad loads at the kids channel Boomerang, while TruTV cut its ad minutes by 8% and other networks were little changed. Great, more ads targeted at children... normalize ad viewership when they're young so the future customers won't demand fewer ads. Time for TNT et al to adapt to the new model or fade away.
- mmastrac 7y ago> normalize ad viewership when they're young so the future customers won't demand fewer ads I don't think that works - I grew up in the age of cartoons with ads and they are definitely not something I'll put up with.
- ohithereyou 7y agoI grew up when the Saturday morning cartoons were ads (Transformers, He-Man, GI Joe), and it didn't me refrain from wanting fewer ads in the shows that I watch now.
- temporaryvector 7y agoI don't think that's why you see more ads targeted at children. I don't have any data to back it up, but intuitively I think ads targeted at children are the most cost effective kinds of ads nowadays and as generations grow up this will become more true and true. Kids have a lot of influence over their parent's purchasing decisions when it comes to relatively cheap things (I'd guess that threshold is around $500 dollars since that is what video game consoles tend to cost) and children have not yet developed critical thinking to see through an ad's lies. It's a lot easier for an ad to convince a child that he wants something than to convince an adult or even a teenager, and usually you don't even have to bother with making a good product (think back to all the toy commercials that sold cheap plastic things that broke after a couple of uses), the child can then go on to convince their parent to purchase the thing. As more generations grow up getting used to ads, eventually only young children will be the only demographic not immune to ads, thus you will see more ads targeted at children just because they're the only direct ads that work, while ads for adults will move to different formats such as native advertising, paid reviews, product placement, etc.
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.is/80quF http://archive.is/80quF
- classicsnoot 7y agoOkay, I am tipsy enough to post this. I had an absolutely brilliant idea a few years ago and I'm going to share it, knowing it will probably be disregarded and certain it will never be realised. Commercials/ads should be patterned after a weather model. 9 months out of the year, consumers pay it no mind, and when it happens, it is a hard shock, meaning some people push through and others avoid it entirely. In the 3 "bad" weather months, there is a rise (1), a sustain (2), and a decline to normalcy (3). Month 2 is wall to wall commercials. Everyone knows August, for the sake of example, is just commercials.Everyone knows July and September are lousy with commercials. Consumers and producers adjust accordingly. In the 9 month normal, there are scattered showers of commercials, maybe the occasional thunderstorm (elections, sporting events, mass shootings, etc.). In the 3 month bad weather period, the paradigm is Superbowl. By scheduling the big ad push, companies and producers will be motivated to create content worth watching. I abhor sportsball of any type, but I watch Superbowl commercials religiously. They (we) spend ludicrous amounts for the Superbowl because of the guaranteed eyeballs. This model leverages that concept. Imagine ad campaigns with real story arcs. Good acting, exquisite props and locations, viral explosions of excellent ads. Of course some people will just check out, but most people will flock to a 1-3 month period of atraditional media.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoYou just described the PBS model. No commercials all year except during pledge week, when it becomes unwatchable.
- dredmorbius 7y agos/unwatchable/more &/ PBS is massive disappoint, the few times I've watched of late.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoThe word "pledge" has been ruined for me for good. Emotions of unpleasant kind are evoked when I hear it.
- jdietrich 7y agoAs a non-American who hasn't really watched over-the-air television for a decade, what strikes me most is how commercials affect the content. Mainstream American TV often has a weirdly fragmented quality - the writers seem acutely aware of the fact that they'll lose the attention of their viewers every seven minutes and have to fight to regain it. A lot of programmes (especially comedies) seem like a series of short vignettes, with an absolute minimum of context being carried across the commercial break. Even without the commercials, there's a palpable difference in the pacing compared to a Netflix, HBO or BBC programme.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIt's not just comedies. Every damn broadcast originated SF or drama has a cliff hanger every 5 minutes, including the strange and infuriating US innovation of right after the titles - now 5 minutes in! Then a scene break that's where the adverts would have been. Then the ones that affect all US output, including Netflix etc: The inevitable cliff hanger at the end of the episodes, and a big major cliff hanger at the end of the series - that has no guarantee of another yet. So when Netflix decide to kill yet another after the first series, there's no point watching it as there will be no closure. Whatever happened to stuff like Star Trek where each episode could be stand-alone, or a series was complete with closure? Crappy series cliff hangers never got me to tune into the next series - liking the progression of the story, the acting etc did. Ironically I gave up broadcast commercial TV about the same time ago as you - because it had got too much with the adverts, and American direction. That was long before product placement in the UK, and a couple of liberalisations of regulation. When I visit friends now I am struck how comically often and terrible ads are. My memory says they used to try a bit harder and managed to get them at least competently produced and directed.
- foobarian 7y agoThe worst are the various documentary murder shows. There is not much to the story, so not only do they have cliff-hangers before commercial breaks, but they also recap the previous segment for like half the next segment. It's comical. It's like they heard the common talk-giving advice "tell them what you're gonna tell them, tell them, then tell them what you told them."
- ddingus 7y agoOf course they did. I rarely watch live TV. On some programs it is pretty much a 50/50 split. No thanks. Got way better to do with my time.
- bestnameever 7y agoI guess I'm the minority but commercials don't bother me. I use it as a time to do other stuff.
- tzs 7y agoI have two approaches to deal with commercials on major network TV. 1. If I'm watching live, I work on the New York Times crossword puzzle on my iPad during the commercials. The puzzle comes out at 10 PM New York Time for the following day (6 PM for the Sunday and Monday puzzles). I'm 3 hours behind, so I get them at 7 PM, which fits in nicely with evening TV watching. 2. If I'm watching on DVR, I use one of two convenient features of the Comcast X1 DVR for skipping. 2a. If it is a top HD program on NBC, ABC, CBS, FOX, CW, Bravo, HGTV, Discovery, MTV or TLC, and it is more than something like a couple hours after the broadcast ended, there is a good chance "Smart Resume" is enabled for it. If that is indeed enabled, the timeline display shows commercials marked in yellow, and starting FF (or FFx2, FFx3, etc) while in the yellow area automatically switches back to normal play at the end of the commercial segment. So, as soon as I see the break start, I hit the FF button a few times to get to the fastest FF speed, and it then takes just a few seconds to skip the commercials and resume the program. If you have not heard of "Smart Resume", join the club. I too was surprised when it showed up suddenly. Apparently it has been available as an experimental feature in a few markets for a while, but you had to specifically enable it. Sometime in the last few months, they apparently promoted it to a standard feature and enabled it. 2b. If "Smart Resume" is not available for the recording, I hit the microphone enable button on the remote and say "skip 3 minutes" (or whatever my best guess at the length of the break is--it's pretty consistent for a given break position in a given show). If I still see commercial after that, I'll skip a little more. Most shows do the promos for other shows on their network at the end of commercial blocks, and those are usually shorter than outside commercials, so it is usually easy to tell if I should do another minute skip, or just 20 or 30 seconds. The X1 voice interface is pretty good and responsive, so this works well. It does occasionally mess up and take "skip 3 minutes" or "fast forward 3 minutes" as a search term instead of a command, but not often enough to be annoying.
- nitrogen 7y agoIf you have not heard of "Smart Resume", join the club. It's interesting that ad skipping has finally made its way into the cable companies' own DVRs. It used to be that they got sued just for having a "skip 30s" button, while users of MythTV had automatic ad skipping without even having to use FF and watch them on high speed. Vertical integration has killed so many interesting things.
- thebeerholder 7y agoI'm wondering if this is exclusive to TV. There were four 90 second ads in a 12 minute episode of Eric Andre on Hulu.
- jrnichols 7y agoI watched a show on the NBC app and the first ad break played eleven unskippable advertisements. Eleven. That is just ridiculous. I didn't even finish the show.
- thebeerholder 7y agoI wonder if this is exclusive to TV networks. I was served four 90 second ads, in a twelve minute episode of the Eric Andre show on Hulu.
- hn23 7y agoI am not watching TV nor do I have time/waste time for streaming services. But if something would convince me to watch it would be good content. The simple option would be fewer commercials and good content. They would not even have to produce it. Go to some archive and show stuff from 20-30years ago.
- sureaboutthis 7y agoI think one should notice who is in the commercials to then realize what over the air TV has lost and who their now target audience is. You find a lopsided amount of ads for seniors for pain medication and other drugs along with incontinence. And ads targeting women and blacks--often interracial couplings. So this says TV has lost mainstream viewers who are now on cable and the internet.
- pdimitar 7y agoIn Bulgaria, the several big TV networks average 20 or even 25 minutes of ads an hour, and that has been going on for a decade at least. It's an insanity. They don't even attempt to make their programs more appealing in order to ensure bigger advertisement exposure. They just stuff everything with ads and apparently the advertisers are desperate -- or stupid -- enough to eat the deal every time. There is real value in some the ads. Useful household items or cleaning agents or personal hygiene products are changing periodically and it is good to be somewhat informed. But they take it too far. Furthermore, most grocery store clerks will be very happy to recommend you good products because they don't make money through affiliation; the have fixed wages. So you can not watch TV like I do and still mostly never miss out on anything. This became too long but I guess my overall point was that the TV networks seem to try and milk one last cow before dying as opposed to investing their current profits in better products outside TV. They are accelerating their own end, they know it but attempt to squeeze as much money as possible regardless. It's ugly.