4 ms·
"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room
- vilhelm_s 16y agoHm, this also negates what I thought was Gary Taubes's most interesting point -- why is it that obese people eventually maintain their weight rather than keep gaining. But if the maintenance need increases with body weight, there is no need to postulate any interesting regulation mechanism: just eating a constant amount of food would do it.
- mike_organon 16y agoNo, in the graph, the green line is pulling the red line up - this is exactly what Taubes says is wrong because the delta is so small. The blue line is a red herring because that's no longer the maintenance weight. Taubes is saying that kind of precision in calorie counting is absurd, so can't be the explanation for other people that have constant weight over decades. How could a person on the blue line have eaten with such a small margin of error? It's incredibly difficult to eat a constant amount. People generally eat to satiety, and that changes with weight. The hypothesis Taubes puts forward in the book is that increased weight causes one to eat more, not the other way around (which is conventional wisdom). So the question is, what caused the weight gain (fat storage)? Taubes argues in the book, it's carbs and insulin, not dietary fat.
- jerf 16y agoThat doesn't counter his point at all. The difference between "obesity" and "maintaining weight" is still implausibly thin; what Gary was talking about in the first place was the delta in the top two lines, not the net total. He mentions that more obese people eventually do reach an energy balance, which obviously happens because they income and outflow eventually balance, which is a sign that he understands that. (Sixth paragraph, starts with "First, obese people tend to be weight stable for long periods of their life".) You didn't disprove his argument, you just reiterated bits of it, only with less comprehension and a math simulation disconnected from what actually happens (your simulation lacks the relative stability that people reach and simulates the clearly false scenario in which people become fatter without bound). ("relative stability" - there is a long-term weight gain over pretty much everybody's life but when people become obese they can do so much more rapidly than ~1lb/year) (Personally I'd break it down to the individual meals since that's where satiety occurs and now we're talking about a delta of 3 or 4 calories. It's an absurd argument. Nothing is that precise without a feedback loop. And if a feedback loop is involved, the idea that the feedback loop is what is broken is hardly that odd an idea.) I'm seeing a lot more people declare that Taubes is wrong or obviously a crank that there are people actually demonstrating a comprehension of his points, which I tend to consider a prerequisite for an actually-effective "debunking". Maybe he's wrong, but it's not because of people arguing against points he's not even making while blatently missing the ones he is.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago(your simulation lacks the stability that people reach and simulates the clearly false scenario in which people become fatter without bound) True. All I did was graph the exact scenario Taubes himself described. If it is unrealistic, take it up with him. The only difference is that I didn't "forget" to mention the 7 strips of bacon the obese person consumes in excess of the thin person.
- neild 16y agoWhat you appear to be aggressively declining to understand, despite two prior commenters clearly explaining it--including the one that you're responding to here--is that Taubes does not argue that 20 extra calories a day makes a person fat. He argues the precise opposite, in fact, at great length and in some detail.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhat you appear to be aggressively declining to understand is that I'm arguing that Taube's straw man is misleading. I'm not claiming his main thesis is wrong, I couldn't even figure out from the blog post what that thesis is. He used a misleading straw man: "Look, modern medical science says only 20 cals a day makes you obese! I'll repeat 20 cals/day many times, and tell you it's just a couple of gulps of beer. I'll never mention the other 100-350 cals/day (depending on year) once in 3000 words. Only 20 cals/day must be wrong, go read my book to learn the truth! Now for a made up dialogue between myself and a personified straw man!" Yes, technically he made no untrue claims. He just deliberately failed to mention that the straw man has a good point: 7.5 sticks of bacon/day will make you fat while 7.0 sticks of bacon will only keep you fat once you are already fat.
- billjings 16y agoAhh, if only I were at a real keyboard. I'll just say that 1) you make a fantastic point in the discussion, 2)there is evidence that even when the fat person fails to eat that additional bacon, metabolism and activity levels drop to compensate, and 3) you have failed to refute Taubes' primary point, which is that "we get fat because we eat more calories than we expend" does not satisfactorily explain why we maintain a calorie surplus in the first place.
- ajt 16y agoRearranging the Harris-Benedict Equation the author uses, and holding height, exercise and calorie intake constant, you get an expected increase in weight of a bit over a pound a year -- so just "eating like you're 30" alone would explain 20 of the 40 extra pounds the 50 years old in the original article is carrying...
- nkurz 16y agoThis is a brilliant graph, but I don't think you are reading Taubes' article correctly. He is not offering "straightforward calculations", rather he is setting up a "straw man" ("Aunt Sally") which he feels represents the "almost incomprehensibly naïve and wrong-headed" conventional wisdom. Like you, Taubes does not believe that 20 calories a day is a good way to represent the difference between an obese and non-obese individual. While it's obvious from the response here on HN that he fails to make this clear, he's setting up a contrafactual argument. He's lamenting that even the best science writers we have (like Jonah Lehrer) seem to offer only simplistic truisms like the 20 calories myth. You point out (correctly) that 20 calories is misleading by using a brilliant graph. Taubes attempts (and apparently fails) to bring it down with logic and rhetoric. Now, it's true that Taubes wouldn't fully agree with your graph. He believes that 'calories' themselves are a faulty way of viewing the world, and that the composition of the food matters more than the calculated calories. He believes it matters whether that 450 additional calories are corn syrup or lean steak. But at base, you are not disagreeing with him, and your (wonderful and to the point) graph is not contradicting anything he's saying. I'm just finding it now, but the blog post refers to a chapter in his book: http://books.google.com/books?id=Pm9ZcFYtLZ4C&pg=PT68&lpg=PT68 http://books.google.com/books?id=Pm9ZcFYtLZ4C&pg=PT68... Perhaps that will be a clearer exposition of his beliefs?
- jls11 16y agoI've heard this one before. "Taubes's argument is more complex than that. You need to spend more hours studying those pages, and read books x, y, and z." It's the same argument they give in college English classes for deconstructionism and all that other nonsense. Taubes is a journalist. The people on HN are several standard deviations ahead of his audience. If he's doing his job shouldn't we all be able to understand him without any trouble? Here's a simpler argument: Taubes is wrong, and that's where the problem is.
- nkurz 16y agoTaubes is a journalist. Well, sort of. He also has an undergrad degree in Physics from Harvard and masters in Engineering from Stanford. Which doesn't mean he's right, but it does make him better qualified as a science journalist than most. The people on HN are several standard deviations ahead of his audience. Yes, and this is what's making me want to cry. This is one of the few audiences that knows what 'reductio ad absurdum' means, and yet bright people (whom I respect) seem unable to grasp what to me seems to me a fairly obvious argument. Are contrafactuals truly so rare as to be unrecognizable? Ignoring the fact that his science is wrong. Sure, it might be, but the commentary so far has not been about "his science" but about his portrayal of conventional wisdom, which he also agrees is wrong. It's like pointing out that a mathematician is obviously a fool for saying "Let us assume momentarily that the square root of two is a rational number" as the preamble to a proof. It feels like a scene from Idiocracy. It's not that Taubes is wrong, it's that you are misreading his argument. I'm not arguing that "it's complex" --- although I'll happily stand up to defend deconstructionism --- rather I'm trying to tell you that you are in agreement with Taubes that the conventional wisdom is rubbish. Now, if you want to point out the flaws in his actual argument and say that there is no difference between calories from carbs and from proteins, please do! But insisting that he's wrong because it really takes more than 20 calories sounds an awful lot like chanting "Brawndo's got electrolytes". It's a new year. I want to regain my faith in the world. Please stop making me cry.
- watt 16y agoI don't understand how author reasons that in his graph the "calories/day" for fat guy will be increasing with age, and for "lean" guy they will be decreasing. OK, so if metabolic rate is slowing with age, I would guess the "fat" guy's graph would not be so steep, or actually would be a level line (eating the same amounts of food), while for "lean" guy the line will be somewhat downward sloping (eating less the older he gets).
- matwood 16y agoI don't know why Taubes gets so much play on HN. His science is bad and his studies are cherry picked [1] for whatever narrative he wants to sell. For a large group of people who usually are critical thinkers I'm surprised at what passes for real nutrition science on HN. IMHO, if you want to read good diet information from someone who not only knows what he is talking about, but also uses it in practice every day look up Alan Aragon [2]. I particularly like him because he is a research fanatic and understands the difference between high and low quality studies. BTW, I am in no way affiliated with him at all, but have read his stuff for years. [1] http://weightology.net/?p=265 http://weightology.net/?p=265 -great read with LOTS of links to studies that Taubes conveniently (purposely?) ignored [2] http://www.alanaragonblog.com/ http://www.alanaragonblog.com/
- msluyter 16y agoWhat I find odd about the level of debate on this topic is that Taubes' thesis is easily tested empirically. Give up grains & carbs for a couple of months and see what happens. If, like me, you lose 30 pounds and lower your cholesterol significantly, then all the better. But if not, at least you'll be arguing from something other than "this violates the conventional wisdom." (Remember when the conventional wisdom promoted margarine and said eggs were bad?)
- lukevdp 16y agoThat doesn't show anything empirically. You can lose the same weight on a twinkle diet. http://edition.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.profes...
- kscaldef 16y agoI think you need to look at outcomes over 5-10 years, not a couple of months. As far as I can tell, radical diets pretty much always work over the short term. I'd speculate this is some combination of: you're not actually replacing all the calories you removed, and your body needing some time to adjust to the right mix and quantities of enzymes to fully metabolize your new diet. (Also, I'm fairly skeptical that you're really losing 10 pounds of fat, or anything other than water, per month.)
- msluyter 16y agoThe 30 pounds is over a total period of 1 year, actually. In the first couple of months I lost around 3-4 lbs/month, without exercising.
- matwood 16y agoWhat do you think you have shown? Did you make sure to maintain the same caloric intake when you gave up carbs? You lost 30lbs so how do you know that your lower cholesterol was due to no carbs and not simply weight loss? Most people on low-carb diets end up eating less calories, thus weight loss occurs (pretty basic, but it doesn't sell pop science books very well). I agree that no-carb is a viable strategy to cutting calories in a not have to calorie count way [1], but I'm willing to bet if you simply cut your calories and kept the same macro (P/C/F) percentages as before your diet you would have lost the same amount of weight. [1] Going no-carb cuts out LOTS of the typical snack food that people eat and don't realize all the extra calories they are picking up.