3 ms·
And they’ll have to deal with the pesky fact that hydrogen gas from natural gas is cheaper than H2 from electricity. So it’s either: 1) more nuclear plants in
by Scoundreller 7y ago
And they’ll have to deal with the pesky fact that hydrogen gas from natural gas is cheaper than H2 from electricity.
So it’s either:
1) more nuclear plants in Germany (lol)
2) increased German dependence on Russian natural gas (lol)
- llampx 7y agoWhat happens to the carbon from natural gas once the hydrogen is extracted?
- Scoundreller 7y agoUltimately becomes CO2. Because it's produced centrally, you could collect it and do something with it or store it.
- pfdietz 7y agoIt's possible to just leave it as carbon. The energy needed to convert methane to carbon + H2 is much less (per unit H2) than that needed to convert water to O2 + H2.
- azernik 7y agoThere are experiments (currently underway in Germany) to extract hydrogen from natural gas without burning the resulting carbon, leaving behind graphite powder which can then be either buried or fed into carbon-composite manufacturing.
- the8472 7y agoIf you buy electricity on the spot market it can be extremely cheap or even negative-priced. But the downside of that strategy is that you can only operate your facility for some times of the day.
- ethbro 7y agoThat's an interesting point, in aggregate. As we move towards more intermittent renewables, assuming the market remains intermittent, there's an entire new class of demand that's feasible. Essentially anything that "only needs power sometime in the next week, can soak up a semi-arbitrary amount of power, and can start/stop quickly (ideally grid-controlled)."
- Scoundreller 7y agoI also think we haven't fully exploited interrmittent/responsive demand. I'd have no issues if a household or building's HVAC system, hot water system, electric car chargers ebbed and flowed their demand in response to supply. E.g. when I turn on my dishwasher, I don't care if it holds for 2 hours and then runs because the winds are calm now, but expected to pickup in 2 hours. I don't care if my hot water heater superheats water now because it's especially sunny or windy out. I don't care if my electric car chargers over the course of 8 hours in the evening, instead of charging quickly now. I don't care if my AC system makes the building a couple of degrees cooler now to thermal bank the excess supply before rates increase later.
- ethbro 7y agoThe issue seems to be that energy markets are a long way from achieving financial market levels of responsiveness. You're essentially increasing the number of market participants a couple orders of magnitude, and the system and existing players semi-understandably balk. On the other hand, without exposure to end users, the utility-driven pace of change is going to be glacial (by which I mean, we won't have glaciers anymore either).
- Scoundreller 7y agoWe already have "smart-meters" that enable time-of-day billing. They just need to monitor usage on a per 5-minute basis (and I suspect they do). They don't necessarily need to report it every 5 mins (otherwise how does the current system know how to respond to demand?). I do feel like we should start billing on per-5-minute increments, then the responsiveness will come. I think overnight we'll have a thousand startups selling devices that turn on/off your HVAC or car charger accordingly and save you money overall. Possibly even with a warmer home in winter or cooler home in summer, by being strategic.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIn the heating season, it would make sense if we could just have strategic resistive heating to soak it up the supply and offset natural gas use. I feel that electricity prices being cheap or negative is because very few actually get those prices (e.g. residential/commercial customers paying averaged rates when they shouldn't). Or transmission/distribution prices being averaged (which should also rise/lower with demand because capex upgrades are driven by peak users)
- jillesvangurp 7y agoIf you periodically have a lot of excess electricity because you installed a lot of wind/solar; using that to create hydrogen is not the strangest plan. Germany has a lot of clean energy capacity already and plans to install more seem popular.