9 ms·
Cancer patients are being denied drugs, even with prescriptions and insurance
- mnm1 7y agoThese PBMs need to be eliminated along with the insurance companies that deal with them. The blame is two fold and this can be seen as a conspiracy to commit murder. Maybe not legally, of course, as these companies (pharmacy and insurance) are clearly allowed to murder people without consequence. Insurance companies whole business plan is based around this notion of providing the absolute minimum care when a patient is really sick and needs it the most. Who'd have thought there is another way to die in America just so pharmacies save a few dollars? It's widely known about insurance companies. What other companies have such legal power of death, I wonder?
- devoply 7y ago> pharmacy benefit managers The qualifications to become a pharmacy benefit manager include a bachelor's degree, at least five years of experience as a pharmacist, and five years in health plan pharmaceutical management. So a bozo pharmacist can trump a doctor's judgment.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoA pharmacy benefit manager is not a person, it’s an organization. In this organization are usually doctors and pharmacists (who have doctorate degrees also), who review medicinal claims based on the policies set forth by the payer (sometimes an employer, sometimes an insurance company, sometimes the government). They also don’t “trump” a doctor’s judgment, they simply state whether or not the claim for medicine is covered under the plan rules.
- sjb554 7y agoHaha I was about to write this. Agree that a PBM is not an individual person.
- sorokod 7y ago>"They also don’t “trump” a doctor’s judgment, they simply state whether or not the claim for medicine is covered under the plan rules" Not how it is described in the article. Is the article incorrect in your opinion?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI can't read the article, since it doesn't work on Safari with content blocker enabled, but it's pretty clear that a doctor is free to prescribe whatever they want. The patient is free to obtain the prescription also. The third party payer is also free to object to paying for something it believes should not be paid for under the agreement between the patient and the payer.
- sorokod 7y ago> a doctor is free to prescribe whatever they want Presumably not "whatever they want", presumably it's a bit more structured then that. > The third party payer is also free to object Aren't the patients payers too? Read the article, it's nice.
- erentz 7y ago> They also don’t “trump” a doctor’s judgment, they simply state whether or not the claim for medicine is covered under the plan rules. I think it’s incorrect to say they don’t trump the prescribing doctors judgement just because they have a company policy they’re following. They also have the ability to override the policy. This means they are making a decision and when they default to what the policy says, if that goes against the doctors judgement then that is a decision they made to trump that doctors judgement. This kind of “just following orders” logic is used a lot by people who want to absolve themselves of the responsibilities of their choices.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>They also have the ability to override the policy. From my understanding, they do not. At least not outside of a certain margin of error, since the payer (for example a state government or employer) would then blame the PBM for approving payment something it wasn't supposed to approve payment for, and hence seek reimbursement from the PBM or cancel its contract and go with another PBM.
- erentz 7y agoI’ve had specialty medicine approved that very clearly goes against policy at different phases of the review process (including immediately) on different insurance plans. So they do seem to me to have this power.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI can't answer for why they would violate the policies they are supposed to be enforcing, but I do no know PBMs get audited by governments and penalized for improperly approving medications for Medicaid recipients.
- darkerside 7y agoWhat do you think is happening during the appeals process?
- dylz 7y agoFor almost everyone in the US, is it not true that "claim for medicine is covered under the plan rules" being denied is effectively "you are not getting this medication"?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI guess, but the nuance is that the PBM is only doing what the payer wants it to do. If a state tells the PBM to only approve payment for certain medications under certain circumstances, I don't see the purpose of blaming the PBM for this. Similary, if an employer chooses a formulary that results in a denial of payment, it's the employer who chose to not cover payment for the medicine. The state or the employer can choose to pay for the medicine, but that is not up to the PBM.
- maxerickson 7y agoAnd the payer can state that the PBM only offers a limited set of options, each hand washing the other.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe payer cannot state that, but they do have limited funds so they're not able to say "approve every prescription". Payers are not forced to use PBMs, they choose to to achieve their goals, such as staying within their budget. My whole point is that blaming PBMs is a waste of time. With or without PBMs, someone working at or for the payers (employers, insurers, governments) will be approving and denying claims, just like they have to for home and auto and any other insurance claim. The correct person to blame is us, the voters, for not voting for taxpayer funded healthcare for everyone. But even then, there will probably be some type of setup to ensure healthcare providers are not abusing and defrauding the system, hence someone to approve and deny payment from the government.
- sorokod 7y agoCan't wait for the US health system to make it to the UK.
- gambiting 7y agoSeriously, if that happens I'm moving out of the UK. I've spent 9 years of my life here and even though it gives me weekly anxiety problems, I've plowed on through the whole brexit stuff, I've applied for the stupid right to stay the government implemented, I'm telling myself that the drop in the value of the pound is not that bad even though living here has been continuously and very visibly getting more expensive especially for the past 3 years......but if the NHS is dissolved or gutted enough that it stops being a public health service then me and my wife are selling the house, packing bags and just leaving for another EU country. I'm fucking terrified for the future. I really am. Cutting down on the news helps a bit but there is constant feeling of uncertainty.
- DanBC 7y agoSomething similar used to happen here with NICE guidance not recommending use of the meds, which is why the cancer drugs fund was set up. After spending a billion or so on meds we found out that they mostly don't increase length of life and also cause nasty side effects. https://www.bmj.com/content/357/bmj.j2097 https://www.bmj.com/content/357/bmj.j2097
- sorokod 7y agoCan you explain in a bit more detail how NICE guidelines are similar to what is described in the article?
- DanBC 7y agoFirstly I'm only speaking about England. I don't know what happens in Wales, Scotland, or Northern Ireland. Clinical Commissioning Groups should be following NICE guidance. If NICE looks at a medication and says it doesn't provide enough advantage for the cost they won't recommend it. That means CCGs won't always pay for it, and so hospitals can't use it. Sometimes when NICE recommends a treatment the patient has a legal right to it, and the patient can pursue treatment if their local CCG is trying to avoid paying for it. This cost:benefit calculation appears to be what's happening in the US. Except over here it's a public body making the decision and over there it's a private company. Here's the NICE page for Pomalyst: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta427 https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta427 > Pomalidomide, in combination with low‑dose dexamethasone, is recommended as an option for treating multiple myeloma in adults at third or subsequent relapse; that is, after 3 previous treatments including both lenalidomide and bortezomib, only when the company provides pomalidomide with the discount agreed in the patient access scheme. That seems similar to the US? Only to be used after other meds have been tried, and only if the company supplies it at a previously arranged discount. (I didn't do much searching for this so maybe I've misunderstood the NICE guidance). https://www.nice.org.uk/corporate/ecd4 https://www.nice.org.uk/corporate/ecd4 > If NICE recommends the use of a treatment, the NHS Constitution says that it is your legal right to have it if your doctor believes it is right for you. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-nhs-constitution-for-england/the-nhs-constitution-for-england#patients-and-the-public-your-rights-and-the-nhs-pledges-to-you https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-nhs-constitut... > You have the right to drugs and treatments that have been recommended by NICE for use in the NHS, if your doctor says they are clinically appropriate for you. And here's a list of those treatments: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/published?type=hst,ta https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/published?type=hst,ta
- pacaro 7y agoThis happens across the board. I have psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis. The barriers to getting a prescription for an effective (and expensive) biologic medication can be crazy. When I've been forced to use a "specialty pharmacy", they require that the medication be shipped overnight (it has to be refrigerated) which is clearly more expensive than picking it up at a neighborhood pharmacy, that shipment has to be arranged every month, which means a phone call, waiting on hold, passing a quiz on my condition, surviving attempts to upsell supplies I don't need. They also won't ship "too soon", which inevitably means that the monthly refills slightly more slowly than once a month I've also had insurance demand that I take ineffective but cheap medication for 3 months before I can get the stuff that works -- ostensibly they want to see if the cheap methotrexate (daily nausea, waves of fatigue) is effective. In the 11 years since my diagnosis I've managed to be regularly on an available effective medication about 60% of the time, mostly because of this nonsense. 40% of the time I'm in pain
- fromthestart 7y agoLook into Kratom for the in-between. Its cheap if you get it online, seems to be pretty safe, and works comparably to opoids for pain while being only minimally habit forming. Edit: people don't seem too happy with this comment but it's a chance at legitimate relief from chronic pain with millions of daily doses in the US and no documented fatalities, excluding a handful of reports where other illicit substances were consumed simultaneously.
- rhexs 7y agoBeware: “minimally habit forming” is anecdotal. There are many other anecdotes of it being quite addictive. See quitting kratom on reddit for more info.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoA patient was on Humira then went on medicare. Medicare would not cover Humira and this patient had to go on Remicade. The difference? Humira is able to be given by self at home. Remicade requires an infusion by a nurse.
- xvilka 7y agoIt would be very funny if the managers or their relatives who promote these policies will meet cancer themselves. Then they will feel the human price of their profits increase.
- hestipod 7y agoYou are getting backlash because it seems mean to wish suffering on anyway, and never funny, but honestly I have learned this is the only way most people acquire empathy, though personal suffering. Even then a large number still find a way to blame others.
- hondo77 7y agoJust because they assume their Blue Cross policy is "the best" doesn't make it so. Multiple medical professionals during my current cancer journey (in the Fresno area, as it turns out) actually referred to Blue Cross as "the worst" for the reasons given in this article. My insurer, Cigna, has been great. Also, isn't it possible that the cCare doctor really was not following the right protocol and prescribing things improperly? I'm not going through cCare because I didn't like what I saw there.
- caymanjim 7y agoI'm absolutely not defending the PBMs or what happened in this case, but $500/mo for that age group is the junk end of the insurance market. It's unfortunate, but they certainly don't have good insurance.
- jcims 7y agoWife is on a similar journey. Medical Mutual in Ohio has been great as well. Just received two bottles of pills for her next therapy regimen and the cost on the packing list is $16K. $0 to us.
- iamleppert 7y agoInstead of fighting them like they did, why not just go along with them and order the medications, throw them out just to get escalated to the right one? When I had to deal with CVS Caremark I frequently had to order things I didn’t need because it was part of their “protocol”. Rather than fight them, I would just go along with them because I knew fighting a company like CVS is pointless. I just threw out the stuff I didn’t need so I could get what I needed out of them. When navigating systems like these you have to find ways of looking like the 90% even if you’re in the 10%. Any exceptions to their protocols will be met with resistance and delays as you have to make your way to some review board vs. dealing with the mindless lower level staff who have no decision making ability. It’s what happens when you have executive management with MBA’s that have come from running customer service, consumer finance and call centers running health care.
- alistairSH 7y agoThat means a gap in treatment while CVS waits for the stuff you threw away to work. That's not acceptable when the condition ruins QOL.
- yumraj 7y agoBut won't that cause a delay, even if you ignore the cost, since I'm sure they won't give the subsequent medications unless the time period in which you are supposed to do the previous treatments had passed? That delay is what can be the difference between life and death for some.
- imglorp 7y agoI'm having exactly these problems, with exactly these companies: CVS and BC Anthem. Doctor writes prescriptions; some are limited in doses, some delayed, some with no copay, some priced barbarically, and some flat out refused. Then the doctor's office has wizards that help advocate and sometimes that works, sometimes there's a delay, and sometimes never. In all cases, the patient suffers. They are already facing a medical condition, maybe serious, plus stress from missing work and home life, stress about the future, stress for paying for it all, and then along comes these sharks who will double it all with more stress and worry and anger. Then on top of that they don't get all the types and amounts of medicine their doctor actually wants, based on science and experience, so they will get inferior treatment in every way. Yes we need to cut the price gouging. Adding friction at this interface is not the way.
- Scoundreller 7y ago> Then on top of that they don't get all the types and amounts of medicine their doctor actually wants, based on science and experience It can also be the insurer saying "Nononono!" to treatments that are unnecessarily expensive. Treatments are often chosen because of marketing, and not because of clinical guidelines. E.g. Blindly trusting a sales rep's "education", or choosing something new out of sheer boredom. It gets dicey when the new treatment is a bit better, but a lot more expensive.
- sjg007 7y agoI am surprised that this hasn't started a class action lawsuit yet. The insurer through delays is causing harm. I'm guessing it's a contract thing though. One thing to do is if your plan is regulated by the state then immediately start an appeal with your state's department of insurance. There are also advocates at some hospitals and insurance companies. The other thing to do is go to a very large academic cancer center... presumably a tier 1 research hospital. Outcomes are also better. They usually have staff that know their way through each insurance company and PBM.
- erentz 7y agoBecause most people get their insurance through their employer they are usually self funded plans covered by ERISA. Your only recourse is that provided under ERISA which limits damages to the cost you paid for a treatment that wasn’t covered but should’ve been. It’s abhorrent. Congress in making this law 50ish years ago essentially took away people’s right to sue and get justice in this instance. It was a huge gift to insurance companies and it needs to be fixed but people only learn about it when they are exposed to it. I wish there were politicians willing to step up and change this particular law. When people talk about tort reform I think they’re really misunderstanding who such reforms benefit, as in this case it only serves the large companies and allows them to act in bad faith without proper repercussions.
- refurb 7y agoThis is nothing new and is the process by which insurance companies reduce drug costs. Insurers come up with formularies that favor less expensive drugs first. If those don’t work, the patient can get the more expensive drugs. Manufacturers negotiate formulary agreements. They might offer a rebate to move their product to first line use. In therapeutic areas like psoriasis, the rebates can exceed 50% since it’s such a competitive class with more than a dozen products.
- techsupporter 7y agoThis absolutely is new, or at least the use of PBMs in this way has greatly expanded. When I was in the insurance business, formularies were very common, as I imagine they still are based on my experience as a customer of an insurance plan. Whether or not a drug was on the formulary list was both knowable in advance and negotiable. If your doctor wanted to prescribe something to you that wasn't on your plan's list and had a good reason and felt like having his or her staff spend an hour on the phone once a quarter, your insurance company would often permit it. Funny enough, Anthem--discussed in the article--was one of the better ones in the past about having flexible formulary rules. Even if your doctor wanted to go off-label with an unlisted drug, the majority of insurers would cover it in some way. This use of PBMs, where drugs are on the formulary list but the doctor is told "nope, you can't prescribe that right now or in this way or in this quantity" and being overruled by a pharmacist at the insurer, is relatively new and scary. (Incidentally, this is why the rhetoric of "death panels" during the debate around the Affordable Care Act was bullshit. We've always rationed care in this country and, in the private insurance market, how it is rationed is almost always completely opaque.)
- darkerside 7y agoWhat's new is the application of step therapy to cancer care. Per the article, this was introduced into Medicare by HHS under the Trump administration.
- refurb 7y agoThat’s true, cancer was generally unmanaged in the past. However, some control is needed. I was talking to an insurer once and he mentioned a doctor who had prescribed a drug for patient where there was no evidence it worked. When he asked the doctor why, he said “well I have to give them something”. This was a $10,000 per month drug.
- patientplatypus 7y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/PoliticalMemes/comments/cla50g/medical_bill_meme_this_is_why_im_voting_for/ https://www.reddit.com/r/PoliticalMemes/comments/cla50g/medi...
- tasty_freeze 7y agoOne entirely maddening thing is that the ACA was labeled as having "death panels" that would decide who lives and dies. That phrase was powerfully effective in making large group of Americans strongly oppose the ACA. Even if they knew nothing else about the ACA, they knew they didn't want death panels. But as this article demonstrates, if we care to use the inflammatory "death panels" label, we already have them. It makes me despondent that we can ever get to a place where our politicians can make rational, informed decisions about complex issues requiring multiple trade-offs. Cheap political rhetoric is not only easy to sell, stoking fear and tribalism is a winning strategy to getting reelected. 30 years ago most voters didn't bother to read a paper and were simply uninformed; now most voters are actively misinformed.
- taneq 7y agoThe rational, informed decision is that the government should run its own medical R&D. But no, we can't do that because muh freedums.
- surfmike 7y agoYou mean like the National Institutes of Health?
- taneq 7y agoYes, but more. You guys spend eleventy billion dollars on fighter jets with questionable hovering capability, can't you spend like four billion on nobody having cancer ever again?
- caseysoftware 7y agoWell hell, if you know it's going to be $4B to eradicate cancer, it should be easy to put the plan together and get funding. You'll save everyone billions forever. Why are you screwing around on Hacker News?
- dmoy 7y ago
- mirimir 7y agoThis is called "preauthorization" aka "preauth". Not only does it damage patients' health, but it increases physicians' non-reimbursed costs.
- mirimir 7y agoOops, I was brain dead. It's "prior authorization".
- mevile 7y agoIf you're an employer in California and want to choose a provider that will not have to deal with this you might want to consider offering Kaiser to your employees. There's benefits and drawbacks, but one of the big benefits is that they're vertically integrated and the doctors, labs, pharmacies are all part of the same organization. I would think that would help avoid this specific type of situation. The big drawback is that your employees would need to live near Kaiser facilities. In the Bay Area they are everywhere though and easy to get to. Making use of any doctor or service outside of the Kaiser network is probably not covered.
- threezero 7y agoKaiser’s system works better than a lot of others, but for me having to drive 40 minutes for a prescription is outrageous when I have 20 other pharmacies in a 15 minute radius.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIf the outcomes are better and it saves a lot back and forth, it may be worth it? At least they'll be encouraged to dispense more at a time (3mos vs 1month) to save their time and yours.
- c3534l 7y agoKP will just mail you drugs. That how I get mine.
- tzs 7y agoIf the prescriptions are just for fairly routine drugs (diabetes, blood pressure, cholesterol, etc), I've found that most of them are cheaper paying the cash price at Walmart than the insured price at Kaiser, or paying the GoodRx price at Safeway. What I do now is have my Kaiser doctor give me an old-fashioned written prescription on paper, take it to the Kaiser pharmacy that is in the same building as the doctor's office, and ask them what my out of pocket cost will be. While they are figuring that out, I look up my non-Kaiser options in the GoodRx app on my phone. When I get the cost from the Kaiser pharmacy, I can then decide where to actually have it filled. It was similar before I had Kaiser. The Walmart cash price or the GoodRx price was often less than my copay with Premera or LifeWise if I used insurance.
- ElDji 7y agoCan we agree to flag all those sick health insurance stories with a [US] prefix in the title ?
- roberte3 7y agoI have a really rare cancer, and it didn't get detected until I hit stage IV and it started shattering my bones. Thankfully I lived 2 miles from a cancer research hospital that actually has a specialist in this type of organ cancer. My current treatment regime is based on a research paper. My insurance initially denied me treatment based on "an expert in the field" and stupidly listed the doctors name. I looked her up and she was a podiatrist... For the most part, my treatment is dialed in and mostly working. But I had a solid three months of fighting with the insurance company to get all of the medications, and I do the monthly phone calls to three different specialty pharmacies to get all of the various things that keep me able to walk. Its a crazy hard problem because one of my medications is a "failed" cancer drug. Tens of millions of dollars worth of R&D, several clinical trials, and it turns out it doesn't work on most common cancers. (And even on cancers it does work on, its usually used as a Hail Mary play, at EOL because it might give someone a few more weeks, maybe). It costs roughly 40k a month, and I might be stuck on it for the rest of my days.
- Scoundreller 7y agoAnecdotes are great and all, but we still don't know if the textbook treatment would have worked better or not. Certainly those that failed with the exotic treatment plans won't be around to complain about it.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoThe fact that you need a prescription at all for many of these drugs is crazy. I don't agree with drug laws related to addictive substances. But at least they make sense. Even laws related to antibiotics. There's potential for abuse, so the controllers at least have a logical (if not reasonable) argument. But what possible purpose does it serve to require a prescription for insulin? Or chemo drugs which have no pleasant effect? The blatant racket isn't even questioned when things like this happen. We should be lobbying to remove the need for prescriptions from most drugs and to remove liability for drug sales from pharmacies and other third parties. This way, they don't have a say. And they shouldn't. America is a place where the 0.1% probability there is a negative reaction means 25% of the population can't access medications. And they have the chutzpah to say it's for our own benefit. Legislative capture at it's worst.
- WalterBright 7y agoHaving a national health care system administered by the government is the ultimate monopoly. It necessitates a gigantic bureaucracy, which will decide what you get and what you don't get according to their standardized rules. Since it will be impossible to provide everyone with the best health care, it'll get allocated according to bureaucratic rules, not what you or your doctor want. These allocations will inevitably be done based on political decisions, and how politically connected you are.
- calgoo 7y agoAs someone who lives in a system with national healthcare I can say it’s not a problem like you state. We have both private and public healthcare, and You can use both or just the public one. If you have a life threatening illness then you get priority treatment over illnesses that are more of a inconvenience. It’s not perfect, but it’s a lot better then having admin people deny you treatment based on cost alone.
- WalterBright 7y agoLet's say you need surgery. No two surgeons are alike. Who gets the best one? Who gets the worst? Who gets neither when they're all booked up? In national healthcare, it isn't you who decides.
- charles_f 7y agoThe American health care system is a perfect system. Its product is perfect, the only alternative the customer really has is to live in discomfort or die. Its prices are fully unregulated. The care providers are fully utilized and can therefore practice pretty much the prices they want. The insurance companies are consolidating and can therefore practice the prices they want, while providing an ever dropping level of service. Consolidation with pharmacies even give them a way to control the distribution and a way to recover some of their disbursement. Pharmaceutical producers are protecting their markets through patents that give them monopolies, which combined with a total absence of governmental overlook lets them practice the prices they want. The more the patient needs the medicine, the pricier drugs can get. The incentive is then that the deadliest the disease is, the priciest the drug gets. The only balance that should exist with insurance weighing for lower treatment costs ends up being lower reimbursement and more borderline control on the patient. Truly this is a perfect system, ever more efficient at extracting money from people suffering. All the incentives are in, just not weighing in the favor of patients.