8 ms·
I love the fact that the device most people think of as a "floppy" disk isn't even floppy -- by the time removable-spinning-media-in-a-sleeve became truly mains
by gumby 7y ago
I love the fact that the device most people think of as a "floppy" disk isn't even floppy -- by the time removable-spinning-media-in-a-sleeve became truly mainstream the drive itself had gone back to being rigid.
So the word "floppy" was itself vestigial.
- derefr 7y agoThe sleeves are rigid; but the disk (of ferrite-dusted plastic) is still floppy.
- pletnes 7y agoYou kids! It’s called a floppy drive. Back in the day, not even the drives were rigid.
- moron4hire 7y agoWhen working on the bleeding edge, it's necessary to be flexible, no matter the era.
- dscpls 7y agoThis is the best comment here
- dscpls 7y agoAlways amazes me that people find it necessary to downvote a comment like this
- moron4hire 7y agoFor what it's worth, I upvoted you. The points are free. Why be stingy?
- ad_hominem 7y agoIf you prefer a low effort / high noise comment environment that rewards puns, there's always Reddit
- moron4hire 7y agoHN is not immune to this phenomenon. It just has its own versions.
- sslayer 7y agothe 5 1/4" ones were all floppy!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- imglorp 7y agoAs were the 8" hard sectored diskettes. Don't forget the write-protect notch.
- PopeDotNinja 7y ago> Don't forget the write-protect notch. And don't forget you can notch each side for double the storage!
- tom_ 7y agoMay not be a great idea: https://stardot.org.uk/forums/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=15189#p204750 https://stardot.org.uk/forums/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=15189#p204... ```just a word of warning, copy everything off them [commercially-available flippable 5.25" BBC Micro disks] quick, as the 'side2' goes backwards to the cotton cloth cleaner inside the 5 1/4" case, so basically all the crap caught in it then end up coming out when playing other flip side :(''' (No idea how common this phenomenon might have been! - I've always had double-sided drives, so I've always used the other side of the disk in the normal fashion.)
- xxs 7y agoThe 1st thing you do on apple II diskettes (5.25") was using a scissors to allow the other side to be writable as well. No exceptions (alternatively you just break the plastic switch that tells if there is copy-write protection, on the floppy driver, itself) I have taken the floppy out of the sleeves to dry them out as the entirety of my collection fell in the aquarium.
- foolrush 7y ago
- cr0sh 7y agoIs that the right term, "sleeve"? I always thought of the "sleeve" on my 5.25" floppies as being the tyvek/paper thingie you stuck the floppy disk inside for safekeeping (ultimately putting both in a case/cabinet - which I still have several). Maybe the thing I thought of as a "sleeve" (analogous to a album "sleeve") is actually called something else (maybe an "envelope"?) - I never really gave it thought until now, honestly.
- Max-q 7y agoThe white stuff is the liner.
- orbitingpluto 7y agoI picked up a 5 1/4" floppy without the sleeve that was on the side of the road 20 years ago, sliced open another disc sleeve that had bad sectors and replaced it with the found disc. I still had a working XT at the time. It had The Black Cauldron, PC Jr bootable version on it.
- core-questions 7y agoNice. One time, I brought home a 3.5" disk from elementary school with a copy of Commander Keen 5 on it - the paid one that was so hard to get for a kid with no money and no modem. I somehow managed to leave it on the driveway near the car, overnight, inside of a faux leather wallets of sorts. It snowed. It was the winter break, so there was no going back to school to see the other kid who had made the copy for me, not for 2 weeks. This was supposed to be my fun game for the break.... So, I carefully opened the disk, set it to dry over the heating vent, put it back together, and with the help of Norton Utilities 5.0's Disk Doctor, I got a mostly playable copy out of it. Absolutely amazing.
- KibbutzDalia 7y agoInside a 3.5" floppy hard-shell is a floppy disk that's made of the same (or very similar) floppy material that a 5.25" and 8" floppy is made of. So I think the term is OK.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoIf I remember correctly, you used to be able to actually take the magnetic material out of the sleeve and it would run in the drive.
- MPSimmons 7y agoNot on the standard 3.5" but I believe I've seen some (very old very obscure) solutions like that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hyperman1 7y agoI did one day put a 5 1/4 floppy in the small gap between 2 drive bays. Plonk! Oh well, time to get the screwdriver. I heard it happened a lot at the time.
- wazoox 7y agoAlso on the Mac II, when the blank hiding the second floppy slot used to fall down. I remember a secretary calling in distress after having inserted 20 floppies or so inside the Mac to no effect: they were all piling up inside, behind the floppy 2 slot :)
- levelist_com 7y agoThats ok, anyone who has been a bench tech, field tech, especially in the later 90s to early 2000s, has a similar story to this. Ive had people manage to force CDs between two drive bays and wonder why their CD wasnt being detected. Have had people insert credit cards in floppy drives, etc.. [Edit] there used to be a website, similar to bash.org, that people would submit stories like this all the time of stupid shit they were running into as a tech. Dont recall what it was. There was also and admin site, they may have been the same.
- petjuh 7y agoThe first floppies we've had were the 5.25 inch kind which were truly floppy. I remember how strange it felt to hold the new ones which were in a hard case.
- muro 7y agoI think the 8 inch floppy predates the 5.25 one.
- twic 7y agoThe first time i saw an 8-inch disk, i thought it was some sort of wind-up. But no, there really were disks that big once; my dad had one from some ancient minicomputer he'd worked on at some point.
- DerekL 7y agoThe TRS-80 Model II used them. Some CP/M microcomputers did too.
- pacman128 7y agoI had an old Model II 8" drive I had pulled out of old machine that I used in the Intro to Computing class I taught in the 90's. It made a great prop to show how drives work. The read/write head was about the size of a matchbox.
- asplake 7y agoEarly in my career and after a field trip abroad commissioning an aircraft simulator I was stopped at customs with a box of them and was asked what they were worth. Said that we could send the data by modem and so effectively nothing. I was allowed to pass.
- zentiggr 7y agoFather worked at DEC; picked up a PDT-11/150 on discount as a home system. Intended by DEC as an industrial controller. Low-level LSI-11 processor variant, 128k RAM, (2) 8" floppy drives. The case was 75% floppy drive, 25 % processor boards on top. Came with RT-11 build floppies, I had to run the OS build in order to generate a boot disk and three language/utility disks. Took about 8 hours to do the full optioning and build from the 13 source floppies. Ahh, the old days. Wrote my first D&D game, ballistic path analysis, mandelbrot drawn to 80x24 greenscreen VT01...
- otabdeveloper2 7y agoYeah, the 3.5" disks are actually 'stiffies', not 'floppies'.
- markh 7y agoYes, that’s what they were known as in South Africa.
- VectorLock 7y agoComparatively speaking (to a hard drive) a 3.5" disc is still pretty "floppy."
- dwighttk 7y agoI remember being confused because all my 3.5” disks were High Density so they had a “HD” stamped on them. I was pretty sure they were hard disks and the old 5.25” were floppy.
- tres 7y agoI get that this is an ironic take on the semantic reference and the object it represented but I think there is merit in talking about why the obviously-not-floppy 3.5 disk was called "floppy." At the time, "hard disk" referred to the spinning disk inside the computer & so though "floppy" wasn't technically accurate when referring to the 3.5 inch floppy, it was a nomenclature referring its utility or type rather than a physical description actual object itself. "Floppies" were the things that you stuck in and removed... didn't matter their covering material, nor what size they were. It's interesting to think about how many of our words have the same kind of history; once having a widespread descriptive meaning associated with physical traits of the object itself which ultimately were divorced from the original meaning over time... I'm going to hazard a guess that most of our nouns have that kind of history... but the interesting thing here is that this morphing happened so quickly and it's because the object itself changed, not some generational loss of original meaning...
- mwfunk 7y agoThis kind of thing fascinates me. Another example is the various names we have for types of cars- coupes, sedans, even more obscure ones like 'shooting brake'. These were names for types of horse-drawn carriages, and cars inherited the names as models were released which mimicked some aspects of one type of carriage or another. Another example is when someone refers to recording something as "taping" it, even though tape as a recording medium is mostly long gone. In their conversations, the term "taping" made the leap from "recording on tape" to simply "recording", and lost its original meaning.
- djmips 7y agoI don't agree. The plastic spinning discs inside a 3.5 were still floppy and discs. We didn't call Bernoulli boxes or Zip drives floppies. Your clue is the word disc. The 3.5 inch disc was inside a rigid case but still a disc and yes floppy.