4 ms·
I've been at this a while and I think you touch on a few great points here (and generally agree with all of it) Security pros as counter culture cats has been a
by jcims 7y ago
I've been at this a while and I think you touch on a few great points here (and generally agree with all of it) Security pros as counter culture cats has been a thing from the beginning. It still exists of course, but I do believe it's getting better and even as a generally conservative old white incumbent male in the field I give most of the props to efforts to improve diversity and inclusivity in the ranks. With this I feel we'll start to attract (or at least not scare away) people that are comfortable operating at layers of abstraction themselves, able to communicate with the deep domain experts AND product management, project managers, leadership, etc. This might help to chip away at the professional impedance mismatch you're noting towards the middle.
That said I do think there's another part of this problem...security vendors have been selling garbage visualization products for at least 20 years now and over-promising greatly what they can do. Anybody that's been burned is going to be incredibly skeptical of something new...especially if it is billed as a way to visualize 'security' and not a laser-focused sub-domain with ample options for extending the visualization for corner cases not included in the tin.
- motohagiography 7y agoIndeed, there has been a lot of flashy useless stuff. Looking back at the days of products like silentrunner, intellitactics, and then the tyranny of radial diagrams and chart junk that followed, it's littered with failed dreams. Viz has a GIGO problem (garbage in, garbage out) and a big part it is the lack of methodology and general maturity of the field.
- rficcaglia 7y agoYou mean companies have been buying garbage visualization products...if IT spent money on things that actually move the needle on security (training and career paths for engineers, skilled managers, rewarding quality over velocity, long term thinking execs, investing in open source ... to name a few) then vendors wouldn’t be able to sell garbage. Instead IT depts settle for glitzy UIs that plaster over the real (deep and pervasive) culture, HR, and organizational issues.