5 ms·
>> If you want to read about the actual tech they were harping as bringing MUH SWINGULARITY, go read Norvig’s AIMA book. This was still the main AI textbook in
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> If you want to read about the actual tech they were harping as bringing MUH
SWINGULARITY, go read Norvig’s AIMA book.
This was still the main AI textbook in 2014 when I did my MSc in the subject.
It is what is rightly called a "seminal text" and there is not a single trace
of Singularitarianism in it. It's not just "Norvig's book". Its authors are
Peter Norvig and Stuart Russel. Is Stuart Russel ignored because he is not at
Google?
The article really needs to cool down on the hindsight triumphalism. A lot of
people were very optimistic about AI in the '80s (as earlier) because
significant and continued progress had been made. Scientific progress, the
continuation of the work of the Logicians in the '20s and Church and Turing's
work in the '30s. Sure, people in the industry just wanted to make a quick
buck, as they always do. But interesting science was being done and it is a
big loss that the AI winter disrupted its course. Not because it could have
led to autonomous vehicles and conversational agents. What we lost in the
winter was the opportunity to discover new knowledge. That is a tragedy.
So I really don't understand where all the schadenfreude comes from, in the
article. A big commercial project failed and took with it a whole branch of
computer science. Who, exactly, benefited from this?
- gumby 7y ago> So I really don't understand where all the schadenfreude comes from, in the article. A big commercial project failed and took with it a whole branch of computer science. Who, exactly, benefited from this? It wasn't a big commercial system; it was a big government system (you probably can't imagine the degree of shock and awe that greeted MITI people or even the mention of the minstry in the US). This was when Japan was going to destroy America and goodamnit, Something Must Be Done. Of course as happens with such projects it all comes tumbling down, but usually with a whimper. Apollo is another good example: they hit their goal and then what? 5Gen was the more common case: just wasted away. The schadenfreude comes not just from the central planning hubris but from the American freak-out response to what was really hype and a squib. The author says the same thing is happening today, with the hype-o-meter on 11, again in the AI field, and again with an "asian menace" on the horizon, this time China. 5Gen just rode a hype machine though; it didn't take the field out -- we could all see that coming anyway.
- foobiekr 7y agoI think people today have a very hard time understanding what things were like during the Japan bubble from about 1987 to 1990. Coming out of the 1970s Japan ended up dominating certain parts of the electronics - and especially personal electronics, like radios or portable cassette players. They had terribly failed in _information technology_ however, but most people didn't know that, what they saw was walkmen, MITI coordinating wiping out American DRAM and television producers using dumping (among other things) and so on. Another important event was that the US dollar was very high in the mid-1980s (Reagan deliberately de-valuing the dollar was frequent discussion on the morning news). A side effect of this was the transfer of investment to other shores, and Japan being the primary beneficiary. BOJ dropped interest rates a great deal and a speculative asset and property bubble was launched. This culminated in the purchase of many, many high-profile assets in the United States by the Japanese keiretsu and banks. The Japanese were in a mania, and a lot of investors world-wide were as well, and the Americans, in particular, were experiencing a kind of crisis of faith in US-style capitalism. Like most bubbles (try explaining the dotcom), it is very hard to make someone understand what happened. You can recount the facts but not the emotional context.
- selimthegrim 7y agoJames Burke had a climate special (After the Warming) in about 1989-90 where his ideal future was the Japanese running things in a world government. Seems to have captured the zeitgeist and the present (creepy to hear the bit in the beginning though about "full-scale evacuation of New Orleans"). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw
- foobiekr 7y agoWow. This is crazy.
- selimthegrim 7y agoHis optimism is touching. The bit about carbon trading struck me. Lately I've been questioning the dogma of one man, one vote. What if the only way to democratically resolve climate change is to inversely weight your vote by the amount of carbon you emit?
- brighter2morrow 7y ago>This was still the main AI textbook in 2014 when I did my MSc in the subject FYI seminal books don't rotate in and out over a five year timespan, it is still the seminal book and will likely continue to be given all the fuel being burned on neural networks that generate more heat than light.
- neilv 7y agoI had an intro AI class for which Leslie Kaelbling got use of a draft of Russell&Norvig (it was 2 thick stacks of photocopies, with comb bindings), before it became famous. Good call, LPK. Sadly, I donated&sold all my books when I did an extreme-minimalism housing move after grad school, or I'd still own this collector's item.
- brighter2morrow 7y agoWow that is cool, and I feel bad for you because that would be a cool collector's item! Though to be practical, I do prefer nicely bound and polished publications rather than the photocopied and combly bound.
- gumby 7y agoBy the way, though signifying nothing but apropos to this topic: Stuart worked with us at MCC, Peter did not.
- api 7y agoRagging on things that failed with the benefit of hindsight is a good way to sound smart. I have never liked that genre much. 5gen failed but Apollo, the Manhattan Project, DARPANet, the Bell Labs transistor project, and SpaceX reusable boosters (for a contemporary example) succeeded. This piece argues that the ambitious megaproject successes were more decomposable but I find this rationale to be an unconvincing post-hoc just-so story. The conclusion I draw when I look over the history of innovation is that it's like a rare animal that almost never mates in captivity or one of those exotic fungi we can barely culture. We know how to set up conditions where innovation can happen: get smart people, provide capital, give them an ambitious but not impossible goal. Beyond this it's serendipity. Sometimes the muse pays a visit and sometimes it doesn't. The dynamics seem almost identical to what you see in art and music, and I don't think that's coincidence. Science and engineering are perhaps more like the arts than we tend to think. 5gen probably would never have achieved all its goals, but it might have achieved something really notable had the muse chosen to pay a visit.
- lioeters 7y agoThis is my favorite comment in this whole thread. Looking back on big failures in history, it's too easy to point out the obvious mistakes or logical reasons why it failed, how unrealistic their dreams were. That narrative doesn't take into account that notable successes in history, major innovations, were born from basically the same ingredients in a shared cultural context. The difference was (at least seemingly) often just a slight chance variation in conditions, being in the right place at the right time, working on an idea that happened to be ready to blossom. I love the parallels you draw with exotic fungi, how sensitive these ambitious ideas are to its environment. There are so many ways it can fail, and the reason for success is often elusive and serendipitous. > Science and engineering are perhaps more like the arts than we tend to think This seems related to how great art and music are often born of a "cultural milieu", like the jazz scene, or Paris cafe culture in the 1920's that fostered poets, painters, musicians. I imagine Xerox PARC was like that, a vibrant intellectual subculture of creative people who worked in the medium of technology. Speaking of the muse, I like the popular expression, "The elves have left Middle Earth." There's a kind of indescribable "magic" that can inhabit a place and time, pulling everyone around under its spell. Then, as mysteriously as it appeared, it's gone - leaving behind relics of wonders, art works or artifacts, that reason alone cannot explain.
- Animats 7y agoOne of the hilarious things about 5th generation computers is how certain people were about all this. More like painful. I went through Stanford in the mid-1980s, about when it was clear that expert systems were only marginally useful and strong AI was not around the corner. Many faculty were in serious denial about this. You can write rules for an expert system, and what you get out is pretty much what you put in. Too many rules, and you're likely to have contradictions and the inference system gets confused. The logicians were trying hard to fix that, which generated a lot of papers with obscure notations. Eventually we did get massive parallelism, but it doesn't look anything like the Thinking Machines or LISP machine approach.
- kragen 7y agoI think Locklin is saying that AIMA is a good source for understanding GOFAI, and that GOFAI was touted as on the verge of achieving AGI, not that AIMA touted GOFAI as being on the verge of achieving AGI. I agree with your distaste for the self-congratulatory tone.