5 ms·
Given that Greg Brockman was the CTO of Stripe before OpenAI, that's a order of magnitude more technically/CS capable than the typical reader who might be looki
by minimaxir 7y ago
Given that Greg Brockman was the CTO of Stripe before OpenAI, that's a order of magnitude more technically/CS capable than the typical reader who might be looking into ML.
- copperx 7y agoStudying Math at Harvard/MIT certainly puts you in a different category than the average software engineer. And if ML was still challenging to Greg, it is honestly a bit discouraging.
- gdb 7y ago(I wrote the post.) If it's helpful, I dropped out of both schools — the vast majority of my knowledge is self taught!
- jcims 7y ago>I learn best when I have something specific in mind to build. This is so incredibly important for me and, based on my conversations, many others as well. The other thing I struggle with is the feeling that many of the problems I wish to solve are likely also solvable with simpler statistical methods and that I'm just being a poser by trying to pound them home with the ML hammer.
- applecrazy 7y agoQuestion: will the OpenAI fellows curriculum ever be released? I need a nice, structured intro to deep learning research and feel like the curriculum modules your company has developed would have the highest quality. (For reference, I’m an undergrad looking to get into this field)
- knbknb 7y agoHow often do you go "back to basics" (read introductory book chapters, or classic papers, etc)?
- streetcat1 7y agoMaybe if you want to write tensorflow, but not if you want to use it.
- eanzenberg 7y agoIf you want to write TF, then you are a ml engineer. If you want to use TF, then you are a scientist (data, research, whatever)
- omarhaneef 7y agoI think "doing" ML math is a little different than "doing" math math. With math, on paper say, it is hard to tell if you are doing it right or wrong. You can trick yourself quite easily. A compelling proof can have a huge hole. You can still trick yourself programming -- in a sense, that is what a bug is -- but it is much harder. The upshot is, I think it is easier to teach yourself math that is applied to a computer program than math on a piece of paper.
- dhairya 7y agoSo there is a difference between ML research and application. Being a practitioner doesn't require deep math knowledge that perhaps research would. Jeremy Howard's fastai course is a great example of how someone with a solid programming background can effectively transition into being a deep learning practitioner. Given that production ml and deep learning is still the wild west, as a practioner, you can contribute also to the research around effective training, scaling, and application of these models. The math and intuition required are definitely acquirable. I think when you shift into pure research, yes a deep probability, information theory, linear algebra, and calculus background are needed. But at the level, you're rarely writing code and more likely working at theoretical level.
- jph00 7y agoAlso, note that Greg's goal was to contribute to OpenAI's flagship project. That's a rather ambitious goal! Also, most folks I know that are making practical deep learning contributions are doing so by combining their pre-existing domain expertise with their new deep learning skills. E.g. a journalist analyzing a large corpus of text for a story, or an oil&gas analyst building models from well plots, etc.
- dhairya 7y agoas a side note, I love that you highlight regex in your new NLP course. There is an inherent tension between the probabilistic nature of models and the need for deterministic outputs in most production settings. Often if we can uncover linguistics rules or regex patterns that guarantee minimal precision (or as our VP puts it - don't look stupid), we'll eschew the model in the short term or use the model to augment the rules. Also I really appreciated that on of the training goals for ULMfit was to be trainable on a single gpu. With these large-capacity models, training is getting crazy expensive and out of hand. Any chance that your future work will still keep the single gpu training goal?
- sevensor 7y agoI recently got the assignment to "do ML" on some data. I hadn't done anything in the area before, and a couple of things surprised me: 1. Most of your time is spent transforming data. Very little is spent building models. 2. Most of the eye-grabbing stuff that makes headlines is inapplicable. My application involves decisions that are expensive and can be safety critical. The models themselves have to be simple enough to be reasoned about, or they're no use. You might argue that this means what I'm actually doing is statistics.
- dhairya 7y agoYes but the transition definitely doable and his advice is great. The key part of his advice is spending time experimenting, rapidly failing, and continuing to work on it with real world use case. Often the challenge is making the jump from the simple toy examples used in educational materials to the messiness of real-world data. I'm a senior data scientist at vc-back startup. I'm in a hybrid data scientist/ machine learning engineering role, where I build and train ml and deep learning models and also build the scaffolding them to support their production usage. But my previous roles included being a business analyst, project manager, and research analyst. My undergrad education was in Creative Writing and the social sciences. While I kind of accidentally transitioned into this career, how I got here is similar to most folks coming from a different background. Lot's of self-study and experimentation. I think one of the challenges to transitioning into ML and deep learning is that there are so many applications, domains, and input formats. It can be overwhelming to learn about vision, nlp, tabular, time-series and all other formats, applications and domains. Things solidified for me when I found a space I found compelling and I was able to dive deep into it. You kind of learn the fundamentals along the way through experimentations and reflection. My pattern was pick up a model or architecture. Learn to apply it first to get familiar with it, experiment with different data, and then go back to build it from scratch to learn the fundamentals. That and I read a lot of papers related to problems I was interested in. After a while, I started developing intuitions around classes of problems and how to engage them (in DS you rarely ever solve the problem, there's always room to improve the model ...)
- streetcat1 7y agoThanks for the info. I have a serious question (not for bashing) Can you please describe what part of your job CANNOT be automated?
- dhairya 7y agoNo worries, fair question. It worth noting that my job is not data analysis. So I do use data analysis to evaluate our metrics and model performance. Really none of it is really automatable. I'm working developing NLP features for our product (question answering, search, neural machine translation, dialog, etc). Our customer data is diverse, in different formats, and thier use cases are all distinct. So most of my work is novel applied research and development.
- sgt101 7y agoWe know that someone with a good CS degree can do this because.. Ph.D students....