5 ms·
I said this on the other HN thread about CapitalOne but I found it ridiculous that Aaron Swartz was facing a hefty sentence and the culprit behind this hack las
by giancarlostoro 7y ago
I said this on the other HN thread about CapitalOne but I found it ridiculous that Aaron Swartz was facing a hefty sentence and the culprit behind this hack last I checked is facing up to 5 years??? What the heck?
For every person exposed in this hack is a single victim to be added. Not to mention the numerous indirectly affected people part of small businesses. Aaron Swartz hacked some ebooks by comparison harming only a school.
Can the punishment for crimes stop being absurd. I am only reserving further outrage because those are the current charges against the hacker. We know more can pile up as they learn more.
Really though if that kind of PII can give you access to ruin someones financial life then it should be made harder to get credit cards. If you dont have a drivers license and other things to show you shouldnt get a credit card.
- ovi256 7y agoProsecutor discretion exists. Furthermore, AFAIK (IANAL, especially not a US criminal justice lawyer), US sentencing guidelines take into account first-party financial damages (low for CapitalOne) not diffuse third-party damages of the kind suffered that will be suffered by the 100M people whose PII was lost.
- eigenvalue 7y agoCapitalOne disclosed that this hack is going to cost them between $100mm and $150mm, which is a lot more than JSTOR would have lost from Aaron Swartz's "hack" of academic humanities papers.
- madaxe_again 7y agoRight, but it wouldn’t have happened if they hadn’t had such lax security, and I would argue that capital one are liable here for failing to adequately safeguard consumer data. If you properly secure your stack, you don’t get hacked. If they had fallen victim to some undisclosed zero-day, I’d feel bad for them - but in this case it appears to be misconfigured VPC SGs. Their error. Inadequate processes. We are also all labouring under the assumption that she was the only person to make off with this data. I’m willing to bet that she’s just the first one daft enough to talk about it.
- qaq 7y ago"If you properly secure your stack, you don’t get hacked." Thats absolutely not true. You do reduce the chances of being hacked and you might reduce time it takes for you to discover the breach and you will be able to contain it quicker.
- madaxe_again 7y agoYou vastly reduce the chances. It’s the difference between bothering to close the bank vault’s door when you go home at night or not.
- vageli 7y ago> Right, but it wouldn’t have happened if they hadn’t had such lax security, and I would argue that capital one are liable here for failing to adequately safeguard consumer data. If you properly secure your stack, you don’t get hacked. If the system was designed by humans, it can be hacked.
- bbunix 7y agoEspecially if the bad guy used to work for your vendor.
- nixgeek 7y agoIt seems likely that were the accused to be convicted, a fine will be part of the sentencing, and Capital One may opt to pursue separate civil legal remedy against the convicted person to seek damages given their cost is stated as being >$100M. Unclear to me if this somehow isn’t allowed under U.S. law because the federal prosecution may be where it all gets determined, and a civil case may be “double punishment”? So after coming out of prison and finding a job, which is likely to be hard for a felon, and may not be highly paid, what wages they make will be garnished to pay the criminal/civil financial judgements. For most people who’ve worked in technology, the potential punishment here would qualify as “destroying your life”. Enormous impact.
- mtgx 7y ago> Prosecutor discretion exists. Which means she should've been held personally responsible/impeached over what she did to Swartz. But instead Obama protected her, just like he did with all of his other government criminals, as well as Bush administration's criminals, too. "We need to move forward." and "No abuses were found." and other such BS needs to end when it comes to government criminals. No wonder more riots are popping up and the hatred towards authorities is increasing every year.
- mschuster91 7y ago> If you dont have a drivers license and other things to show you shouldnt get a credit card. In Europe everyone has to possess a personal ID card or a proper passport, and it is required to be presented to the bank agent (or a verification service). Yes, we do have some problems with faked ID cards and lately by fraudulent video identification, but still - not remotely comparable to the laughable "security" in the US.
- arethuza 7y agoThat's not the case in the UK - we don't have any single government issued identity document/card that everyone has to have.
- krageon 7y agoThe UK is a special case and will not be "Europe" for long besides. Homogenisation of rules can take a while, especially when there is a cultural aversion to them. In this case I'd say there simply has not been enough time for this to happen.
- jsty 7y agoBarring a rather spectacular feat of engineering, the UK won't be relocating itself from Europe any time soon (much to the chagrin of those who seem to want to plonk us next to Singapore ...)
- bin0 7y agoEngland will not be less a part of Europe just because she leaves the EU. The EU was never perfectly cohesive to start with [0], and is made up of extremely disparate nations and cultures. Plus, England never adopted the Euro (which is probably for good reason, seeing as interest rates are now even further down because the ECB can't properly conduct monetary policy). The EU was never comparable to, say, America in terms of unity. Europe had too much history for it to work perfectly - every one was on what had been at some point some one else's land. [0] https://europedirectemn.files.wordpress.com/2018/02/treaties-graph.png https://europedirectemn.files.wordpress.com/2018/02/treaties...
- nicoburns 7y agoI think that says a lot about how much vested interest powerful people have in enforcing copyright law.
- kd5bjo 7y ago> Can the punishment for crimes stop being absurd. The absurd punishment was Swartz’s, and was 8 years ago. Are you saying that, out of fairness, the punishment for all future computer crimes should scale up to make this one tragic event seem more reasonable?
- imoldtoo 7y agoThat a corporation worth multiple billions of dollars can't keep our information secure despite one individual. That is the message here. IMHO, the "punishment" trajectory should aim toward Capital One. After all they are the ones who ultimately fucked up. Frankly; Oh dear my ex-employee, or someone "trusted" who was pissed off because I/We didn't think I/We did anything to piss them off is not an admissible excuse. Why anyone should weep for a multi-billion dollar company while crowing "throw the bitch in jail" for exposing their lacking security practices is beyond me. Who is the criminal. A large mega-corp who could not keep their shit straight or an individual who proved their security perfectly invalid, and then told us! Cry me a river...
- vorpalhex 7y agoWe don't really know enough yet. My read is that Capital One was horrifically negligent, and none of the data was actually resold or used...
- jsymolon 7y ago> none of the data was actually resold or used... Yet.
- tzs 7y agoThat hefty sentence commonly mentioned for Swartz was using the whale sushi number [1], not a number he actually had even a remote chance of getting [2] [3]. [1] https://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentence-eleventy-million-years/ https://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentenc... [2] https://www.popehat.com/2013/03/24/three-things-you-may-not-get-about-the-aaron-swartz-case/ https://www.popehat.com/2013/03/24/three-things-you-may-not-... [3] http://volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aaron-swartz-part-2-prosecutorial-discretion/ http://volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aa...