3 ms·
>Many CISC machines (eg Intel's) are CISC in name only. The instructions are translated to micro-ops in the hardware. The micro-ops and the hardware itself, is
by imtringued 7y ago
>Many CISC machines (eg Intel's) are CISC in name only. The instructions are translated to micro-ops in the hardware. The micro-ops and the hardware itself, is RISC.
No, that's just a popular HN myth. First of all microops are not part of the public ISA which is what the entire RISK vs CISC debate is about. If the public ISA does not matter and you can always convert to whatever is best then RISC loses because it's raison d'etre is to enable optimizations through a betzer ISA. Second using microcoding (not the same as microops) to implement a huge number of instructions is an integral core of CISC, if you are saying microcode is RISC then CISC did RISC way before RISC even existed. RISC was all about removing microcoding to simplify CPU designs so clearly if your CPU has extensive microcode it is not RISC and definitively not "CISC in name only".
If CISC is RISC then why even bother with RISC? After all CISC does "RISC" better.