6 ms·
In what sense are these not smartphones? They run a flavour of Linux, they have internet access, they're programmable and have an app store. They sound just as
by taneq 7y ago
In what sense are these not smartphones? They run a flavour of Linux, they have internet access, they're programmable and have an app store. They sound just as capable as flagship phones from a few years ago, except that they're not primarily touchscreen based and they don't use the Apple App Store or Google Play Store.
- colordrops 7y agoBy that definition my old Nokia brick from 2005 with a black and white screen was a smart phone. The boundary is fuzzy, sure, but the term usually means a phone where the app usage is front and center and phone usage is secondary. Now these new phones might be somewhere in-between.
- jamesrcole 7y agoI don't see anything in the article that suggests phone use would be greater with these 'smart feature phones'. The only reference it has to how they're used talks about app usage "Now he listens to Bollywood music on the job, using Google’s built in voice assistant to search for Hindi-language tunes on YouTube. At night his family crowds around the device to watch movies."
- ollie87 7y agoIt isn't of course, Nokia smartphones from that period had colour screens and ran Symbian. They had 3G, Video calling, MP3/Video playback, fairly okay web browsers (I used to use Opera), and okay-ish photo/video capabilities. You could even edit documents on them if you hated yourself that much. They just lacked CPU power and RAM capacity compared to what came when the iPhone launched. Models would be: 6600 6630 6680 N70 N73 I actually had another Symbian powered Smartphone when the iPhone launched, the Motorola Rizr Z8 which made the Nokia powered Symbian's at the time look really slow. I sort of miss that phone and it's form-factor, it even came with a pair of Stereo Bluetooth Headphones. Massively ahead of it's time, of course not as slick as the iPhone and AirPod combo I have now, but great in it's own way.
- vardump 7y ago> It isn't of course, Nokia smartphones from that period had colour screens and ran Symbian. They had 3G, Video calling, MP3/Video playback, fairly okay web browsers (I used to use Opera), and okay-ish photo/video capabilities. You could even edit documents on them if you hated yourself that much. Those Symbian S60 Nokia phones you listed could install and run apps written in "C++". Emphasis on those quotes! But regardless, your very own native code, doing your bidding. Been there, done that. It worked, but writing those apps was very tedious and hard. Everything was async to save power. No standard libraries, etc. I'm very happy there's no need for "leave stack" and "cleanup stack" etc. in the modern world. But damn, that architecture was really helping the battery to last for a long time. Your code simply would not be running until some async thing did a callback.
- Scoundreller 7y agoDon't forget native SIP!
- nabla9 7y agoThey are feature phones. >Feature phone is a term typically used to describe a class of mobile phones that are still technically otherwise smartphones, besides their lack of highly advanced hardware and capabilities of modern ones. Feature phones tend to use an embedded operating system or real-time operating system with graphical user interface which are small and simple, unlike large and complex general-purpose mobile operating systems like Android or iOS, they typically provide voice calling and text messaging functionality in addition to basic multimedia and Internet capabilities and other services offered by the user's wireless service provider. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_phone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_phone
- taneq 7y agoOK, so from that, they are smartphones, just low-end ones which probably isn't software-compatible with higher end smartphones.
- iainmerrick 7y agoYes, unless I completely misrecall, these were called “smartphones” before the iPhone launched. After that, the iPhone was clearly something qualitatively different, so people (or rather, journalists, phone stores and the like) started calling the old style “feature phones”. I’d say it’s now misleading and even incorrect to call something a “smartphone” if it doesn’t have a full-size touchscreen.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoCan't agree with that - many early androids, the original and current android Blackberry (key2?) are all smartphones, but have or had a keyboard. There's also a selection of crazy expensive Far East smart flip phones with Motorola Razr form factor. All deserve to be called smart phones.
- dragonwriter 7y agoThey were called smartphones even after the iPhone launch until the iOS v. Android duopoly was established.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 7y agoAlmost a 15 years ago, there was a very popular OEM design called Inventec E29. It was one of very first real working Linux based phones. It did not make a big splash even among Linux enthusiasts, and vanished tracelessly as Android took over. Only now, the type of a device you can call "an Internet pager" is truly finding its use again. The irony is as the Internet becoming near ubiquitous, the less is the marginal value in having the latest and greatest device for using it. Most of what people use them now are IMs and digital wallets. A lot of my coworkers are now settling with something even dumber for phone use, and use 7-8 inch tablet as the main mobile device: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32824383761.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.0.0.56dd5676zlURF0&algo_pvid=bdf44975-5eee-4094-a665-99eba74222de&algo_expid=bdf44975-5eee-4094-a665-99eba74222de-0&btsid=8fb4e52d-044c-478a-a8cc-48d275cee208&ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_7,searchweb201603_52 https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32824383761.html?spm=a2g0o.p... Or some go for things like this, a bluetooth remote for the main device that can access your address book and act as handsfree: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32839686717.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.0.0.2f8848cdYgMwQS&algo_pvid=842fd69e-27f9-46ff-b18d-5e255b75f7a9&algo_expid=842fd69e-27f9-46ff-b18d-5e255b75f7a9-17&btsid=77b1ebe3-a244-4745-a5aa-0920b8e68a1a&ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_7,searchweb201603_52 https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32839686717.html?spm=a2g0o.p...
- skocznymroczny 7y agoFor me the definition of smartphone vs feature phone or whatever is that smartphone is primarily to be used for internet whether it's content consumption or apps, whereas feature phones are primarily to be used with cellular network for making calls and sending sms.
- mic47 7y agoThey are. It's just in today's terms, "smartphone == has touchscreen" and "feature phone == looks like old fashioned phone with keyboard".
- km3k 7y agoYes, they're technically smartphones, but by that use of the word, all phones in the last 15 years are smartphones. Over the past decade, the term smartphone typically refers to a general purpose computing device that fits in your pocket that also acts as a phone. There is also more recently an implied requirement of a touch screen. A feature phone is more of an appliance device, where the primary feature is a phone, but it also has other limited features, some of which are internet enabled. Unlike a smartphone, where you have a lot of control over what software you can put on it (similar to a PC), a feature phone only has a limited set of preinstalled features and optionally has a limited app store to add some more limited features. By those definitions, the phones in the article are more feature phone than smartphone.
- f00zz 7y agoI think that the main difference between smartphones and feature phones is that smartphones have separate processors for applications and for the modem (the "application processor" and the "broadband processor"), whereas in feature phones a single processor handles everything.
- aikah 7y ago> Unlike a smartphone, where you have a lot of control over what software you can put on it (similar to a PC), a feature phone only has a limited set of preinstalled features and optionally has a limited app store to add some more limited features. I used to develop apps and games on feature phones using Java MIDP, so 15 ago phones were already smartphones, there was just no app ecosystem back then nor real economy, that's all. But it was possible to install 3rd party apps and even browsers like Opera Mobile on flip phones. The difference is in the CPU power. Today some phones are more powerful than some cheap laptops.
- WWLink 7y agoYeah it's pretty funny how people have a problem paying as much for their laptop as they do for their phone lol.
- 7y ago